⚙️
🌟 Najlepsze dopasowanie
Wpisz szukaną frazę, aby zobaczyć propozycje AI.

Supply chain digitalization: why do two out of three implementations fail and what to do to avoid it?

Digitalizacja łańcucha dostaw: dlaczego dwa na trzy wdrożenia kończą się niepowodzeniem i co robić, aby tego uniknąć?

  • Digitization in logistics is now a necessity, given consumer demands. Expectations are high – we want availability, transparency, 24/7 access to information, and mechanisms for predicting delivery delays. However, according to a Capgemini study, as many as 86% of supply chain digitization projects are not finalized. What causes such a huge gap between consumer and company expectations and the completion of digitization projects? The numbers speak for themselves…

The Capgemini report presents the main goals, problems, and tips regarding the implementation of supply chain digitization. Companies are very enthusiastic about digitization projects, paying particular attention to the return on investment (ROI), which averages 18%. This means a significant reduction in costs (as indicated by 77% of respondents) and an increase in revenue (56%), which are the main goals of supply chain digitization. An additional advantage of such projects is the rapid amortization of investments in automation, which usually lasts up to 12 months. What problems arise on the way to the goal? In many cases, challenges may relate to outdated IT infrastructure, lack of network access in production and warehouse zones. Another barrier is organizational limitations, particularly visible in the case of corporations or too many company branches, which makes it significantly difficult to apply changes throughout the entire organization.
The main problem, according to the report, is, however, the excessive dispersion of investments and the difficulty in implementing pilot projects on a large scale. The surveyed organizations have an average of 29 supply chain digitization projects in the design, proof-of-concept, or pilot phase. Only 14% of them have successfully implemented at least one of these initiatives in several locations or across the entire company. However, among companies that have successfully completed such a project, 94% notice that their efforts have been rewarded with the expected increase in turnover. These companies manage an average of six projects in the proof of concept phase – they have almost twice as few as organizations that failed to introduce digitization on a large scale. The conclusion is simple – focusing on fewer projects guarantees better results. As Capgemini points out, success is also fostered by a clear procedure for evaluating the success of pilot projects, as well as clear criteria for setting investment priorities. To properly implement supply chain digitization mechanisms, it is primarily necessary to adopt a targeted and long-term approach.

Digitization for a medal – what to pay attention to?
Digitization allows for the creation of new business models, and supply chains are on the list of areas where this process (carried out in the right way) creates the most dynamic and spectacular change. From idea to implementation is a long road. How can you be sure that you will achieve success? Certainly, a great help here is the partnership of organizations that have already carried out projects in the field of digitization. These companies point to three basic areas that form the basis of a properly conducted transformation:

– Promoting digitization and aligning goals
The supply chain digitization process cannot be treated in isolation from other departments of the company – it also concerns planning, purchasing, IT, and HR. That is why it is so important that all these departments are involved in change management. The promoters of the transformation should be the organization’s leaders, who set the main goals and priorities in the project strategy. It is not enough to just promote and focus on reducing service costs. It is equally important to align company goals, which should go hand in hand with overall efforts, which in practice means increasing transparency and customer satisfaction.

– Connecting different entities
The flow of information and the integration of partners up and down the supply chain (suppliers and distributors / logistics service providers) is a significant element responsible for the success of the transformation. The elimination of silos and barriers between internal departments and partners also has a huge impact here, in order to extend the required supply chain as widely as possible and maximize the benefits resulting from the digitization process.

– Developing talent
In the long term, creating a digital supply chain alone is not enough. Therefore, it is necessary to invest in the development of talent within the company. This allows not only for a stronger customer orientation but also for continuous improvement of the service itself. The first step is educating employees, presenting the benefits of digitization, and the stages of the process, which often raises fears about existing jobs, and then creating an appropriate strategy for attracting and retaining talented employees.

Maspex and PEKAES – theory put into practice
The Polish company Maspex, a leader in the market for beverages, ready-made meals, and vegetable preserves in over 50 countries around the world, owes about 30% of its turnover to exports. Given the significant role of transport in fulfilling orders, as well as the process of information flow in the supply chain, Maspex decided to implement a uniform GS1 standard for information exchange in relation to a logistics operator – PEKAES, one of the largest companies in the TSL sector in Poland. The choice fell on the GS1 XML schema, which is one of the communication standards of the global GS1 system, while also being a requirement for starting cooperation.

– The documentation regarding the standard, made available by the GS1 Poland Foundation, was well prepared, and the solutions themselves are flexible enough to allow them to be adapted to the operational process in our company. As in most projects of this type, there were some deviations from the original assumptions, but they did not affect the final result. I definitely recommend using this type of solution – emphasizes Piotr Gaik, Head of the Development and Implementation Department at PEKAES.

This standard made it possible to create direct links between the physical flow of goods and the information that concerns these goods. This solution allowed for increased information transparency while monitoring the execution of processes. Shortening the integration time with a new business partner, reducing EDI project costs, transparency of electronic transactions in transport processes, work automation, and speeding up the handling of errors related to incorrect data in messages are some of the greatest benefits noted after the project implementation. Digitization in this case also enabled the development of a procedure for future implementations both on the client side (Maspex) and the supplier side (PEKAES). The project of implementing the uniform GS1 XML electronic data exchange standard in transport processes did not encounter technological and economic barriers. Therefore, one can safely speak of a successful implementation from both an operational and economic point of view.

Recipe for success
Everyone surveyed in the Capgemini report agrees – without digitizing and automating supply chain processes, it is no longer possible to meet consumer expectations.

– I am convinced that standardization is becoming a necessary requirement, a guarantor of process and service quality. After implementing a uniform standard, maintaining, taking care of the infrastructure, and further expanding it becomes much easier than before – assures Dariusz Smaza, Deputy Logistics Director at Maspex.

Thus, digital supply chains are rapidly merging with traditional ones, and printed documentation and local information carriers are being replaced by cloud technology and digital logistics management systems. The positive results of such a transformation are easier to achieve when choosing the right partner who will help finalize the digitization project, focusing on its relevant aspects, such as: promoting digitization and aligning goals, connecting different entities, and focusing on talent within the company.

Implementation from the perspective of Dariusz Smaza, Deputy Logistics Director at Maspex

1. What decided the implementation of GS1 standards?
– The main reasons for implementing such standards are the expectations of our customers and the scale of our company’s business, which we conduct in 7 locations in Poland and abroad. Therefore, we needed optimal communication tools and a uniform standard to make it easier for our suppliers, such as PEKAES, to perform less-than-truckload transport services for us. It is our customers who create needs, e.g., by requiring deliveries with small vehicles, at specific times, with advance notice in the form of a phone call before delivery, etc. We respond to these needs, which is why we implement the best possible service standards to deliver our products faster, cheaper, and more precisely.

2. Capgemini research shows that the success of a project depends on whether the company treats it with due seriousness. Was this project a priority for you?
– That was indeed the case. Implementing the standards was a priority for us. The project lasted almost a year, and during that time we provided the necessary resources to build and execute the new system. We also assumed that this technology is very promising and will provide us with opportunities for rapid development.

3. Project progress: did anything go differently than you expected?
– The construction of the system itself was not complicated, but different standards turned out to be a certain challenge, e.g., the waybills we used did not exist on our supplier’s side. We also had different ways of marking goods, there was a lack of additional marking in the form of “master pallet” labels – so-called sandwiches, i.e., marking pallet spaces, not individual pallets. However, step by step, we solved these situations, and today we fully use the implemented standards.

4. ROI. According to the Capgemini report, investment in the supply chain area is very profitable and results in many benefits. How was it for you?
– Investments in the logistics area are our definite advantage in trade – thanks to them, we can deliver our products faster and more efficiently. The modern technologies we have allow us to create not only new products tailored to market trends and consumer needs but also to deliver them to our customers faster and more efficiently. Implementing GS1 standards simplifies, automates work, and significantly improves the quality of data for analysis.