⚙️
🌟 Najlepsze dopasowanie
Wpisz szukaną frazę, aby zobaczyć propozycje AI.

Operational center – or the continuation of controversy

Operational center - or the continuation of controversy

The Mobility Package uses the term “employer’s operational center” several times. What is it, where must it be located, and what conditions must it meet?

According to current regulations, an operational center is the place to which an employer must organize a driver’s return for the purpose of taking a weekly rest period. Naturally, they can also organize a return to the employee’s place of residence. Similarly, the possibility of exceeding driving time limits as indicated in the current Article 12 of Regulation (EC) No 561/2006 is conditional upon returning to the employer’s operational center to take a weekly rest period. It is not the intention of this article to discuss the rules for recording weekly rest periods by drivers, as this topic has already been covered extensively in numerous studies. The author’s intention, however, is to attempt to define the term “employer’s operational center,” which has not been formally defined.
One should begin with the interpretation of the rule set out in Article 8(8a) of Regulation (EC) No 561/2006. It follows from this that the operational center must be located in the country of the employer’s registered office. The EU legislator deliberately used the term “employer’s operational center” – and not, for example, “transport operator’s.” Therefore, for a business entity employing drivers and registered in Poland, the operational center will be located within our country. This is important in current conditions due to the multitude of companies that employ drivers in Poland while sending them, for example, to other parts of Europe to perform transport using vehicles registered in another Member State. There are known examples of companies based, for example, in Germany, possessing vehicles and transport permits issued in that country, which do not employ any drivers. The company employing them is, however, a business entity located in Poland, which in fact does not possess any vehicles in the country. Consequently, one must support the thesis that the employer – which in such a case would be a Polish company, often a “subsidiary” of an entity from another country – will have to provide the driver with the opportunity to return to their operational center located precisely within the territory of the Republic of Poland. It is worth emphasizing again that EU regulations use the term “employer’s operational center.” The employer in the case analyzed here remains the Polish entity, even though it does not possess any vehicles or a transport license. However, it employs drivers, and thus gains the status of an employer.

The second element defining a given place as an employer’s operational center in accordance with the regulations amended by the Mobility Package is custom. The driver must be provided with the opportunity to go for a weekly rest to the place that constitutes their customary base. There are, therefore, no obstacles to an employer having several locations within the country of company registration to which the employer assigns the role of such a center. It must be remembered, however, that it is highly likely that there will be a need to organize travel to one of the employer’s bases for the group of drivers who customarily start work there, as well as a simultaneous obligation to organize the return of another group to a different base – because that is where that specific group of drivers starts work. The EU legislator emphasizes the term “custom” here.

It is worth citing here the view expressed in this regard by the Court of Justice of the European Union in the case marked with the reference number: C-124/09 (Smit Reizen). [quote:]The concept of “operational center” […] should be defined as the place with which the driver is normally associated, namely the establishment of the transport undertaking where they regularly perform their duties and to which they return after their completion in the course of their normal work, without following specific instructions from their employer.
Although this view was the result of examining a case pending before the court under the old Regulation (EEC) 3820/85, it seems to remain valid today. After all, the purpose of the regulation contained therein is analogous to the purpose of adopting the provisions of Regulation (EC) No 561/2006. The Court answered a preliminary question asked by a Dutch court considering the issue of drivers starting work in a place other than the employer’s registered office.

It is also worth considering whether this operational center should be identified with the registered office of the undertaking referred to in Article 5 of Regulation (EC) No 1071/2009. The author is far from this concept. It is obvious that an employer employing drivers performing transport on their behalf has a registered office where, as a rule, the documents of employed persons are kept. However, it does not have to be identical to the base where vehicles are stationed, and it may differ from the place where drivers customarily start their work. Thus, for some carriers, the registered office may simultaneously be that operational center. For others, however – this will be especially true in the case of multi-branch enterprises – the registered office will not fulfill the role of such a center. It is worth emphasizing again that the custom of a given driver starting work in that place – or the lack of such practice – will be decisive here.
As has been shown, when determining the place where a given employer has located their operational center, operational practice becomes extremely important. The center is where the given driver starts work. Ultimately, it may be that for one employee, the operational center will be a different place than for another driver, even though both perform the same type of transport for the same entity.

National law also distinguishes the concept of an operating base of a transport undertaking. It was defined in Article 4(21a) of the Act of September 4, 2001, on Road Transport. It may – but does not have to – fulfill the role of an operational center. In defining the concept of an operating base, the national legislator based it on its functions. Thus, this base is to create conditions for parking vehicles and be equipped with technical equipment necessary for conducting transport activities. The base must have at least one parking space or a place enabling loading or transshipment. Therefore, the national legislator does not decree any requirements related to drivers in relation to the operating base. It is more concerned with the space necessary for the technical functioning of the transport company. It is therefore obvious that a base defined in this way can fulfill the role of an employer’s operational center to which drivers will return in a manner agreed with the company employing them and at its expense. Because it is the employer who must provide the possibility of return. Nevertheless, the operating base does not have to fulfill such a role. Again, this must be made dependent on the practice regarding the start and end of work.
The regulations also do not comment on the form of ownership of such a place, which must be considered for a given employer as their operational center. There are, therefore, no obstacles to such a place being the subject of a lease or tenancy. It is also obvious that it can be the property of a given business entity.

After the analysis, a reflection arises about the law-making process correctly conducted by EU bodies. Life is always richer than the norms created. Remembering this, a great deal of freedom was left as to what to consider as an entrepreneur’s operational center. This place must meet two requirements. It must be located in the country where the employer’s registered office is registered and at the same time constitute the place where the given driver customarily starts and ends work. It is obvious that the carrier also has the possibility of organizing the driver’s return to their place of residence. Nevertheless, in both the first and second variants, it is important to prove that such an opportunity was available to the employee, organized by the company at its expense. Any way of proving this fact is good – as long as it is effective and convincing during an inspection. Therefore, all contracts will come into play, e.g., for renting a bus or a smaller passenger vehicle, declarations, invoices for the transport of drivers to the operational center, emails, or text messages about the possibility of using transport to the country. Finally, it is also worth remembering that such a return does not yet constitute the driver’s rest. During it, the employee cannot freely dispose of their time. However, that is a topic for another publication.