
As a transport company, we perform most of our routes as part of cabotage and cross-trade transport. Until now, it happened that a driver returned to the company’s base once every 3 months. In light of the Mobility Package regulations, can a driver return to the country with the above frequency?
Expert answer: The Mobility Package regulations amending Regulation 561/2006 have significantly reshuffled some of the rules regarding driver driving time. The first changes began to apply from August 20 of this year.
Regulation 561/2006 in its current wording did not regulate the issue of a driver’s forced return to the company’s base. However, in accordance with Art. 8(8a) of Regulation 561/2006, “A transport undertaking shall organise the work of drivers in such a way that they are able to return to the employer’s operational centre, which is the usual base for the driver concerned and where the driver’s weekly rest period begins, in the Member State of the employer’s establishment or to return to the driver’s place of residence within each period of four consecutive weeks, so that they can take at least one regular weekly rest period or a weekly rest period of more than 45 hours taken in compensation for a reduced weekly rest period”.
The first doubt arises when interpreting the concept of “enabling the return to the employer’s operational centre“. From the information provided so far by inspection authorities, it can be concluded that it is not so much about the possibility of returning itself, but about fulfilling it through the physical return of the driver. We see here a clear emphasis on a broad interpretation, and any other interpretation of the provision may result in the imposition of a fine.
However, on the other hand, it is pointed out that the carrier can fulfill the obligation arising from Art. 8(8a) of Regulation 561/2006 by documenting that the driver was provided with the opportunity to return (e.g., proving a reserved seat on a coach) and a statement from the driver that they voluntarily resigned from returning to the country despite such an opportunity being provided by the carrier. The second interpretation seems less safe from the carrier’s point of view and, knowing the practice of Western road services, may be the cause of negative financial consequences for the company.
Another doubt concerns the deadline for taking the rest periods to which the driver is entitled. In a model situation, the driver takes a regular weekly rest (min. 45 hours) in week no. 1 and by the end of the fourth week following that week, they should return in order to take at least one regular weekly rest period or a weekly rest period of more than 45 hours taken in compensation for a reduced weekly rest period. The above standard can be understood in two ways.
Firstly, that by the end of the 4th week, the driver should start taking the rest periods they are entitled to (in this situation, the deadline for returning expires at the end of the 4th week). At the same time, the rule from Art. 8(9) of Regulation 561/2006 will apply, according to which a weekly rest period that falls in two weeks may be counted to either of them, but not both.
Secondly, that the driver must not only return before the end of the fourth week but also take the rest periods by the end of that period, so that for every four weeks, there is a fully taken regular weekly rest period.
Doubts also concern the entrepreneur’s operational centre. It happens that carriers have several bases in different parts of Poland, having their headquarters, for example, in Warsaw. In such a situation, it is worth taking care to report information about additional operational bases in order to avoid doubts as to whether a given place should be treated as the employer’s operational centre, to which Art. 8(8a) of Regulation 561/2006 refers.
Summary
Answering the question asked, applying a liberal interpretation regarding only ensuring the possibility of the driver’s return to the base within a period of four weeks, it seems that the driver will still be able to remain on an international route longer than in the period indicated above. It should be noted, however, that such an approach may not be accepted at the inspection stage, which will obviously lead to negative financial consequences for the carrier. At the current stage, it seems that the “safer” form of applying the new regulations is the driver’s return in every period of four consecutive weeks, so that they take at least one regular weekly rest period or a weekly rest period of more than 45 hours taken in compensation for a reduced weekly rest period.
Legal status of the publication (date): 2020-11-13








