Who has replaced Ukrainian drivers in Poland?

Who has replaced Ukrainian drivers in Poland?

Back in 2022, there were over 127,000 valid driver certificates for Ukrainian drivers in circulation. In 2023, there was a clear decline, marking the beginning of a new trend. By the end of 2024, the number of Ukrainian drivers in Poland had dropped by as much as 40 percent compared to the end of 2022. Other nationalities have taken their place. In some cases, the growth is spectacular—by 96 percent, or even over 1100 percent.

The shortage of drivers in Poland is currently estimated at 100,000–200,000, “depending on the demand for transport,” says Maciej Wroński, president of the Transport and Logistics Poland association, as quoted by Money.pl.

This does not, of course, mean that so many trucks are sitting in parking lots waiting for drivers. It does, however, mean that there is a shortage of that many drivers in the Polish market. Carriers therefore have to manage by filling these vacancies with, among others, workers from abroad, including from countries outside the EU
– explains Artur Kalisiak, Director of Strategic Projects at TLP, in an interview with PITD.

First and foremost, they fill them with workers from third countries, as there is no chance for the European Union to come to the rescue of Polish carriers—the problem of driver shortages affects the entire Community. And it is acute. The International Road Transport Union estimates that by 2028, the EU will be short of more than 745,000 qualified workers for driving heavy vehicles.

It is therefore not surprising that systemic solutions are being sought, an example of which is the Skilled Driver Mobility for Europe program announced last year, which is intended to facilitate the recruitment of drivers from more distant locations, primarily from Africa. The program includes Egypt, Kenya, Nigeria, and Ethiopia, among others.

Will there be a shortage of Ukrainian drivers?

Meanwhile, however, among drivers from third countries in Polish transport companies, Ukrainians and Belarusians predominate, although after Russia’s attack, the number of the former has clearly fallen, as shown by data on driver certificates valid in a given year. Until the end of 2022, their number was growing—in December of that year, Ukrainians held 127,389 certificates. A year later, it was only 88,923. Two years later—76,310.

I would see several reasons for this state of affairs. First, of course, the outbreak of war and the need to stay in or return to the country. Second, the availability of drivers on the market. In Ukraine, the pool of drivers who could fill vacancies in Polish companies was simply being exhausted
– explains Artur Kalisiak, Director of Strategic Projects at TLP.

Additionally, over the last few years, the perspectives and opportunities for Ukrainian carriers have changed dramatically.

This state of affairs is the result of an agreement concluded between Ukraine and the European Union. After the outbreak of the war, the requirement for permits was abolished in transport between the European Union and Ukraine, which may have led to Ukrainian drivers returning to their country and taking up employment again in local companies. Previously, there were defined permit limits for each year; today, such permits are not required. This means that companies from across our eastern border have much greater opportunities than before to carry out transport to Western Europe. I do not think, however, that drivers from Ukraine began to move en masse to Western companies. In Poland, competitive working conditions are offered, they are closer to their home country, and drivers’ wages in international transport are already actually comparable or close to those in the West
– adds Artur Kalisiak, Director of Strategic Projects at TLP.

Heading East

The decline in the number of Ukrainian drivers working for Polish carriers led to a simultaneous decline in the total number of drivers from third countries, as Ukrainians made up the majority in this group. At the end of 2024, there were over 6 percent fewer non-EU drivers than at the end of the first year of the war with Russia. This decline would, however, likely have been much larger if not for the fact that entrepreneurs began to turn toward other nations. It is no surprise.

There is beginning to be a problem with the availability of workers from Ukraine, so we must diversify the countries where we look for workers in advance, so as not to have problems filling trucks in some time. We must secure ourselves for the future, especially since we are already receiving signals that there are no workers left in Ukraine
– confirms Remigiusz Gąsiorowski from Legarto Logistic.

Thus, the number of Moldovans increased—comparing the status at the end of 2024 with the end of 2022, the year the war began—by 8.5 percent. Even more so for Russians—by 33 percent. Belarusians by over 96 percent. And Kazakhs—by a spectacular over 1136 percent.

More and more drivers from Asia

During this time, the number of driver certificates from countries placed by the Road Transport Inspectorate (GITD) in the “Other” category increased by nearly 176 percent. By the end of 2022, there were 1,643 valid driver certificates from third countries less popular among Polish entrepreneurs, and thus not listed by name in the GITD reports.

At the end of 2023, there were already 3,543 such certificates. At that time, as the Information and Communication Team of the Chief Inspectorate of Road Transport explains, “due to a request from institutions and entities researching transport activity in Poland, this list (referring to the annually published list of countries of origin of employees who were issued a driver card – editor’s note) was expanded by another 5 countries.”

Alongside Ukraine, Belarus, Moldova, Russia, and Kazakhstan, which were mentioned in the years 2015–2022, Uzbekistan, Georgia, the Philippines, India, and Kyrgyzstan (previously included in the “Other” category) appeared in 2023. No surprise there. Almost as many driver cards were issued to citizens of these countries as to Russians or Kazakhs.

Number of valid driver certificates in legal circulation in a given year

Country

2024

2023

2022

Ukraine

76,310

88,923

127,389

Belarus

56,038

56,256

28,496

Uzbekistan

2,833

2,349

x

Georgia

2,018

2,284

x

Moldova

2,295

2,451

2,114

Philippines

1,587

1,288

x

India

1,570

1,457

x

Kyrgyzstan

1,050

1,249

x

Russia

1,245

1,664

936

Kazakhstan

1,063

1,025

86

Other

4,540

3,543

1,643

TOTAL

150,549

162,489

160,664

Source: GITD

In 2024, the ‘Other’ category included 57 countries for whose citizens at least one driver certificate was issued. Among them are, for example: Zimbabwe, Turkey, Sri Lanka, Azerbaijan, Nepal, Pakistan, Armenia, Serbia, and Rwanda”
– reported the GITD.

Cultural differences

Which country transport companies are looking for drivers in today depends on the business approach. Various variables are taken into account—for some, it is important that the employee comes from a country with a culture similar to the Polish one, to avoid differences that could pose a challenge in work organization. For others, it is that a driver recruited from far-away Asian countries has experience gained previously, for example, in Middle Eastern countries, where European heavy-duty vehicles can often be found, and the driving culture is similar to ours
– points out Artur Kalisiak.

Legarto Logistic primarily hires drivers who already have experience driving on European roads.

What helps in running the business is the fact that all the drivers we finally hire can communicate in English. And this is met with satisfaction from our clients in the West
– admits Remigiusz Gąsiorowski.

On the other hand, drivers from Asia and Africa have a completely different rhythm of life, a different concept of time and specific concepts, so many things have to be carefully explained to avoid problems.

For example, they need to be sensitized to the need to report any obstacles in the execution of transport. Even trivial ones like traffic jams. Because a driver from Asia or Africa will consider them a natural thing on the road, so they will not see the need to report them to the dispatcher. Even if it entails a clear delay in delivery
– describes Remigiusz Gąsiorowski.

Long months of waiting for an employee

Nevertheless, the biggest problem remains not cultural differences, but domestic bureaucracy.

Let’s be blunt—this is a drama. From the moment the first application related to the employment of a worker from a third country is sent to the moment that person gets behind the wheel of a truck, at least half a year passes. That is a long time!
– concludes Remigiusz Gąsiorowski.

As a result, only about 2–3 percent of people for whom the company has initiated the procedure related to verifying skills and bureaucracy will ultimately be interested in establishing cooperation.

There is nothing surprising in this. Over half a year, a person’s life can change. These people get other offers, they move. It happens that when we call them after half a year, they don’t even remember the matter
– says Remigiusz Gąsiorowski.

Similar observations are made by Izabela Szerszeń, a proxy at the transport company De Rooy Poland, where employees from third countries are primarily Ukrainians, Turks, Belarusians, and Filipinos. However, there are also drivers from India, Nepal, and Pakistan on the waiting list.

For the work permit alone, one has to wait up to three months today. There were better times when the wait was a month to a month and a half. Then a problem with visas appears. Obtaining this document in some countries is extremely difficult. Let me give you an example—in April 2023, we received a work permit for seven Indians. So far (that is, after almost 2 years), only two have managed to schedule an appointment for a visa, and in the end, their applications were rejected. This is a radical example, but unfortunately not isolated. Certainly, the situation would be improved by launching visa centers in Poland, which would relieve Polish consulates, which are unable to process such a large number of visa applications
– recalls Izabela Szerszeń.

The issue of obtaining a residence and work permit (residence card) is also problematic.

In some offices, this takes over a year, and visas are only valid for 12 months. The mere fact of submitting an application is not enough to work legally, because we employ international drivers, and they must present a visa or a residence card abroad. Both for visas and residence cards, a fast-track procedure would be useful when it comes to the driver profession
– appeals Izabela Szerszeń.

What’s more, some countries have additional restrictions related to the employment of workers by companies from abroad.

For example, in the Philippines, a recruitment agency certified by the local government must mediate in the process, and the employer must obtain accreditation from the Philippine consulate. And all of this, of course, involves additional costs
– describes the representative of De Rooy Poland.

Verification once again

With the expiration of work permits, the problem returns. Extending a permit is by no means a formality.

We have to go through the same procedure that we went through when hiring an employee for the first time again after a year or three years, depending on the period for which they were issued a permit. Once again, deal with bureaucracy for several months and hope that it will be possible to pass it positively
– describes Remigiusz Gąsiorowski.

And he argues that under these conditions, everyone loses.

We have a verified person who has worked for us for three years, paid taxes. Meanwhile, they are being screened again like someone being brought in for work for the first time. Fingerprints are being taken! This is an absurdity, which the state primarily loses out on, because the crisis related to the labor market affects key economic indicators. The driver loses because they cannot take up work. Officials lose because they are buried in pointless work, and finally, the carrier loses because they have to wait for a person, and in the meantime, the truck cannot just sit in a parking lot, right?
– concludes Remigiusz Gąsiorowski.

As a result, in a company with a fleet of 160 trucks, 300 drivers are employed, of which nearly 100 are “virtual”—these are workers who are waiting for the relevant documents to be processed.

This is not an exception. Izabela Szerszeń estimates that for every 10 drivers, for example, from Turkey, the company hires two additional ones so as to staff all vehicles while the workers are getting visas.

Knowing what the procedures look like, we have to provide ourselves with this kind of staffing buffer. Even though considerable costs are associated with it
– admits Remigiusz Gąsiorowski.

Recently we had a record holder. A driver, a verified man, worked for us for three years, had no criminal record. When his documents expired, thanks to which he could leave with transport abroad, he waited a year and 4 months to have new ones made and go through the entire procedure. In this way, we lose people. Because they don’t want to and cannot wait a year for documents. They look for other work, any work, in Poland. And then we see them, for example, on Uber
– concludes Remigiusz Gąsiorowski.

Source: PITD