
Sales growth does not always mean a proportional increase in financial results. A good example is a situation where, with the same sales volume, changing sets from 16 to 8 pieces can mean twice as many co-packing operations. This is one of the examples described in the FM Logistic e-book “When growth stops being profit. The hidden cost of volatility and the moment to change the operating model.” The case shows how a commercial decision can increase operational burden, even though sales volume remains unchanged.
Promotions, short series, or new product variants often have a destructive impact on operational processes, generating costs that are not visible at first glance.
Sales growth is a natural business goal. From a logistics perspective, however, what matters is not only how many products need to be handled, but also how much work their preparation requires. Promotions, short series, new variants, or additional packaging requirements may mean the need for repacking goods, additional operations, and schedule changes.
Under stable conditions, a larger volume usually means proportionally more work. With high volatility, however, this relationship often ceases to be linear – one shift can affect subsequent tasks and increase the burden on the entire operation.
– Volume alone does not tell us how difficult it will be to handle. Executing one large order or a repeatable series looks different than handling a dozen short campaigns requiring frequent changes. Operational capacity is a combination of technology, people, space, and the time we have for preparation – says Michał Wawrzyńczak, Business Development Director at FM Logistic, author of the newly published e-book.
Execution cost is not everything
It is easiest to calculate what is directly visible: the time needed to complete a task, the materials used, or the equipment. Based on this, one can compare, for example, the cost of repacking products in one’s own warehouse with the price of the same service provided by an operator. Such a calculation, however, does not show how the execution of this task affects other processes.
In the e-book “When growth stops being profit. The hidden cost of volatility and the moment to change the operating model”, Michał Wawrzyńczak distinguishes three levels of cost: execution, disruption, and decision. The execution cost includes direct expenses related to task completion. The disruption cost, on the other hand, appears when an additional operation affects other processes – e.g., engages employees, occupies part of the warehouse space, or requires a schedule change.
The most difficult to capture, however, is the decision cost. It appears when operational constraints force a company to give up sales opportunities – e.g., an additional promotion or order that cannot be handled without disrupting other processes. The cost then is not the execution of the work itself, but the lost business opportunity.
The problem usually does not start with suddenly running out of people or space. Before that, there are more and more plan changes, additional arrangements, and resource shifts. We are still able to do the same work, but it requires much more effort from the team and making decisions on the fly. This type of situation is a signal that it is worth checking whether the current operating model is still effective.
– points out Michał Wawrzyńczak from FM Logistic.
One change can trigger a domino effect
The more changes that need to be introduced during execution, the harder it is to maintain the planned work rhythm. One delay can trigger a domino effect. If, for example, a packaging delivery is delayed, the campaign completion date must be changed. This may overlap with another planned project, and suddenly two projects that were supposed to be handled in different weeks need the same resources at the same time. The problem that started with the lack of one component then spreads to subsequent areas of operation. As a result, the cost of the initial disruption is no longer limited to just the schedule shift.
When is it worth changing the way of working?
Not every volatility means that the current way of working needs to change. If additional processes are repeatable, they can be well-planned and do not disrupt basic operations, so executing them with internal resources may be the most effective solution. The situation changes when short series, promotions, or different product variants regularly require work reorganization. One possible solution may then be to transfer some of these processes to a logistics operator. Outsourcing can include, among other things, product kitting, i.e., repacking, labeling, preparing promotional sets, but also comprehensive handling of short series.
It is not profitable to outsource every operation. If the process is stable, repeatable, and we use our own resources well, such a model can work very well. Outsourcing begins to have value when it allows taking over part of the volatility and thus keeping the basic operation in the planned rhythm. Therefore, it is not worth comparing only the cost of performing a specific activity. One should look at what impact a given solution will have on the entire operation.
– summarizes Michał Wawrzyńczak.
Source: FM Logistic Central Europe








