
73 percent of online shoppers expect free returns. However, according to the law, this cost is covered by the buyer, and the e-shop refunds the cost of the purchased goods along with the costs of the initial shipment. It turns out that in practice, things are often different. Who pays for returns, how much, and in what situations?
According to research, 6 out of 10 consumers will not use an online store’s offer again if it does not cover the costs of potentially returning the purchased goods. In accordance with current regulations, the cost of return shipping lies with the buyer, while the store must refund the costs of the initial shipment of the goods. However, matters are not always straightforward, and the costs of return shipments become a cause of misunderstandings between the e-shop and the consumer.
The e-shop pays if it does not inform
A customer buys goods online worth 200 PLN and additionally pays 30 PLN for shipping. The purchased item does not meet the consumer’s expectations, so they decide to withdraw from the distance contract within the 14 days they are entitled to.
– The Consumer Rights Act provides that in such a situation, the cost of return shipping is borne by the consumer, unless the e-shop has agreed to bear the cost of return shipping, for example, because it wanted to offer such a bonus to the offer – informs Rafał Stępniewski from RzetelnyRegulamin.pl.
The online store must inform the customer, e.g., in the terms and conditions, before placing an order, about the necessity to pay for shipping in case of a return. Furthermore, the consumer should receive such information either in writing along with the package or on another durable medium, e.g., in an email. If the store does not inform the customer, it will have to cover such costs itself.
– Moreover, the lack of such information is a failure to meet the statutory information obligations. An entrepreneur concluding a contract with a consumer without meeting the requirements regarding providing information or issuing a document is subject to a fine. This action may also constitute a practice violating the collective interests of consumers, which is punishable by a fine of up to 10 percent of the revenue achieved in the fiscal year preceding the year of its imposition – explains Stępniewski.
Shipping costs depend on providers
While the consumer must pay the cost of return shipping to the e-shop, the e-shop should refund the buyer the cost of the initial shipment of the goods. The consumer is entitled to a refund of the shipping cost incurred at the time of purchase, but only up to the amount corresponding to the cheapest shipping option available in the given offer.
– In the event that a customer, wanting to receive the expected goods as quickly as possible, chooses a more expensive means of transport, they will not receive a refund of the difference between the value of the chosen delivery and the cheapest method of transport. It should also be remembered that this rule does not apply to personal pickup as the cheapest form of delivery – says Rafał Stępniewski from RzetelnyRegulamin.pl.
In the case of offering goods that cannot be sent back by regular mail, the obligation to inform the consumer about higher costs, along with an estimate of the costs the consumer will have to bear in case of returning such goods, is also problematic for sellers. Sellers have lower delivery rates due to constant cooperation with courier companies and do not have knowledge regarding the availability of courier companies in the consumer’s area of residence and knowledge of whom the consumer will choose. The seller’s estimated calculations may therefore differ significantly from the actual costs that the consumer will have to bear. This can be a problem and cause unnecessary disputes between e-shops and consumers.
Refund for goods not always in full amount
When returning goods, the consumer should also remember that they are responsible for any reduction in their value. This means that if they pack the goods incorrectly for return and they get damaged, or if they want to return goods that they have used in a way that goes beyond what is necessary to establish their nature and functions, then the seller is entitled to make a claim against the consumer. The seller should then present the consumer with a proposal for valuing the reduction in the value of the goods, supporting their position with appropriate calculations and evidence. The consumer can, of course, accept it or not. If the parties do not reach an agreement, the matter may be referred, for example, to an arbitration court, where it will be resolved. Unfortunately, the regulations do not specify methods for how to calculate the reduction in the value of goods. This should be done in relation to the actual costs that the seller must incur to restore the full value of the goods. In a case where restoring the full value is impossible, it should be estimated based on the market price of such used products. This applies primarily to exclusive and expensive goods. An example could be the latest smartphone model, the removal of which from the original and sealed packaging causes a loss of its value. The seller cannot offer the returned copy to another customer, as they expect a phone in the original, sealed packaging. Otherwise, they may accuse the seller of delivering used or display goods.
To avoid misunderstandings related to the refund of shipping costs when canceling goods purchased online, the e-shop should clearly and transparently provide the customer with information about the rules for returning purchased goods and the associated costs. In turn, the consumer must read the terms and conditions of the online store where they are shopping. This will allow both parties to avoid unnecessary disputes.
Source of research:
Royal Mail Report: “Delivery Matters Returns Special”








