⚙️
🌟 Najlepsze dopasowanie
Wpisz szukaną frazę, aby zobaczyć propozycje AI.

Resolving disputes with e-shops in the EU

Resolving disputes with e-shops in the EU

By 2018, global consumer spending on cross-border online shopping will reach 300 billion dollars. More shopping opportunities mean more transactions, as well as more potential complaints and disputes. How can they be resolved in borderless shops?

We are increasingly willing to shop online, both in Polish and foreign e-shops. More e-shopping also leads to more potential disputes. According to the European Consumer Centres Network (ECC-Net), the most common problems with virtual shopping mainly concern non-delivery, delays or cancellation of orders, and receiving a defective product or goods inconsistent with the order. How to resolve potential disputes with an e-shop in the EU? What additional facilities for resolving problems with online shopping is the European Commission preparing?

Dispute resolution
In the case of disputed amounts exceeding 2,000 euros, the regulations of the Member State in which the court proceedings are conducted apply.

– This means that a person wishing to assert their rights directs the case to a court in their own country, competent for their place of residence – informs Rafał Stępniewski from the RzetelnyRegulamin.pl service.

If, however, the subject of the dispute does not exceed 2,000 euros, Regulation 861/2007 of the European Parliament applies within the European Union. What are its basic guidelines?

Procedure for resolving a dispute with an e-shop in the EU
1. Preparation and filing of the claim. First, the consumer prepares a letter and submits the document directly to the competent arbitration court. The claim can be delivered by all means of communication permitted by the state in which the proceedings were initiated. In the event that the injured party, referred to in the proceedings as the plaintiff, does not provide sufficient information, the court may request the completion or correction of the data contained in the submitted claim. The parties may refuse to accept a claim in a language they do not understand – in such a situation, the court notifies the other party of the need to have the document translated.
2. Notification of the defendant. The court sends the defendant a copy of the claim with any attachments within 14 days. Documents are delivered by post. Delivery constitutes confirmation of receipt and includes the date of delivery.
3. 30 days for the defendant. The defendant, e.g., an online store, has 30 days from the moment of service of the claim to provide the court with an answer and explain the situation.
4. The court responds to the plaintiff. Within 14 days of receiving the response from the defendant, the court forwards their response to the plaintiff. At this point, the suing consumer has 30 days to respond to the defendant.
5. 30 days for the court’s decision and dispute resolution. The court issues a ruling within 30 days from the date of receipt of the response from the defendant or the plaintiff (if the plaintiff responded to the defendant in a counterclaim). In case of additional questions, the court may summon both parties to provide additional information within 30 days.
6. The loser bears the costs. The losing party, in addition to paying the amount to the injured party, is also obliged to cover the costs of the court proceedings. The losing party has the right to appeal. A defendant who does not agree with the court’s ruling and has arguments confirming their position should immediately take appropriate appeal actions.

Dispute resolution with an e-shop soon also online
The European Commission is working on creating a simplified dispute resolution procedure. An online ODR platform is being prepared, which is intended to enable consumers to resolve disputes online within the EU. It is to be a tool for communication on disputed issues between consumers, entrepreneurs, arbitration courts, and mediation institutions. Additionally, so-called contact points are to be created to help with technical issues. People who encounter problems with online shopping will be able to file a complaint online via the platform in the language of their choice. The ODR will notify the seller about the complaint. Later, the consumer and the shop will jointly determine which out-of-court dispute resolution entity will help them settle their case. The platform is intended to be very intuitive and resemble a bank account access or online shopping site for consumers. The application submission procedure itself is to be simple – the consumer will provide a few basic details, briefly describe the problem, and attach documents regarding their case. They do not need to have extensive substantive or legal knowledge. However, consumers and e-entrepreneurs will only be able to use the new solution from January 2016, as work and tests on this project are currently still ongoing. Through the ODR, it will be possible to resolve disputes with both Polish and foreign e-shops. However, the system will not be able to be used to clarify complaints with traditional shops.

Translations may be an ODR problem
For the consumer, submitting an application will be very simple, but the tool itself is quite complicated because it will be possible to communicate from the platform level with all consumer arbitration institutions in all European Union countries. Experts point to possible difficulties in connection with the correct translation of complaints. The platform is to perform them automatically.

– At this moment, the weakest point of the ODR platform seems to be the translations, which will be automatic. Correctly translating certain phrases or legal concepts into 24 EU languages may cause distortions and a lack of accurate understanding of a given issue – explains Rafał Stępniewski from Rzetelnyregulamin.pl.

The creation of the ODR platform is accompanied by the harmonization of mediation regulations throughout the EU. In Poland, the Office of Competition and Consumer Protection (UOKiK) is preparing an act on out-of-court consumer dispute resolution, and its draft should reach the Sejm at the end of March 2015. The new regulations are intended to unify the arbitration system in the country based on existing mediation institutions, both public, e.g., the Insurance Ombudsman, and private, e.g., the Banking Arbiter at the Polish Bank Association. Fields excluded by the EU directive, including medical and educational services provided by the state, will be excluded from the new law.