Order fulfillment in fashion stores under the microscope

Order fulfillment in fashion stores under the microscope

 

Although returns are most often discussed in the context of the product return process, their causes often arise much earlier – at the order fulfillment stage. Delivery timeliness, packaging methods, and customer communication affect not only the shopping experience but also subsequent costs of managing returns. To see how this looks in practice, Shopreturns conducted a mystery shopping study among online fashion stores operating in Germany. The results can be a valuable guide for Polish stores developing cross-border sales as well.

 

Key findings of the study

The analysis showed that:

  • About half of the analyzed stores did not meet the declared delivery date. The biggest discrepancy involved a store promising delivery within two days that did not deliver the parcel until the fifth day. The longest delivery took eight days against a declared term of five days.
  • About half of the shipments reached customers without any internal protective materials. Products were transported in boxes or envelopes without paper, fillers, or other elements protecting the contents.
  • The delivery cost ranged from 1.49 to 9.90 euros, however, no correlation was observed between the delivery price and the quality of packaging.
  • About 80% of shipments were handled by one national courier network, while other operators appeared sporadically.
  • Tracking the shipment from dispatch to delivery was available in 95% of cases, which proved to be the best functioning element of the entire shopping process.

Stores struggle to keep their own promises

Every store included in the study informed the customer about the expected delivery date when placing an order. Despite this, about half of the sellers did not complete the delivery within the declared time. Several retailers advertising delivery within two days delivered orders only after four or five days. In another case, delivery took place three days after the expiration of the declared five-day period. The study showed that about half of the analyzed stores did not meet the declared delivery deadline. This means that the actual order fulfillment time often differed from the information provided to customers when placing the order.

The study shows that the quality of order fulfillment is determined not by one element, but by the entire process – from preparing the order and packing, to delivery and communication with the customer. In cross-border sales, each of these stages matters because potential errors are much more difficult and expensive to correct than in domestic sales.

– says Paweł Zakielarz, CEO of Shopreturns & Global24.

Large differences in packaging quality

The study revealed significant differences in how shipments are prepared for dispatch. About half of the analyzed packages did not contain any protective materials inside the packaging, allowing products to move freely during transport. Such cases were noted both among large international brands and smaller companies operating in the direct-to-consumer model. In the fashion industry, the way a product is packaged matters not only for the delivery itself. Lack of proper protection increases the risk that the goods will reach the customer creased, with damaged packaging, or with minor aesthetic defects. If such a product is returned, its commercial value may be lower even before its condition is assessed. The study results indicate that the way a shipment is prepared for dispatch can affect the total cost of managing returns.

Higher delivery fees do not mean better quality

The delivery cost in the analyzed stores ranged from 1.49 to 9.90 euros. However, the study did not observe a correlation between the delivery fee and the way products were secured for transport. There were cases where stores charging higher fees used less careful protection than sellers offering cheaper delivery.

Communication problems still affect customer experience

The study also revealed inconsistencies in operational communication. One of the stores canceled an order after payment was accepted due to lack of stock. In another case, the shipment went missing during transport. The customer received an automatic refund but did not receive any proactive information explaining the cause of the situation. In both cases, the financial process was completed correctly, but the customer experience remained incomplete.

Returns begin much earlier than the moment of sending the product back

The study results indicate that many factors affecting return costs arise even before the customer makes a decision to keep or return the purchased product. Inventory management, realistic delivery time declarations, packaging standards, and communication quality affect both customer satisfaction and the financial cost of managing returns.

In cross-border e-commerce, returns have ceased to be just a customer service challenge. Today, they are primarily a challenge for business profitability. A significant portion of the costs associated with returns is generated even before the customer decides to return the product at all.

– says Paweł Zakielarz, CEO of Shopreturns & Global24.

The study results show that the quality of order fulfillment can affect not only the customer experience but also the operational efficiency of sellers. In the case of cross-border sales, even seemingly small errors at the order fulfillment stage can translate into higher service costs at later stages of the process.

What can stores check?

Based on the study results, Shopreturns experts suggest several simple questions worth asking when analyzing your own order fulfillment process:

  • Does the delivery time declared during purchase match the one that the store actually achieves?
  • Does the customer receive proactive information if an order is canceled or a shipment goes missing?
  • Does the method of securing products correspond to the risk of damage during transport?
  • Is the delivery fee reflected in the quality of order fulfillment?
  • Does customer communication cover all relevant stages of order fulfillment?

The simplest way to verify your own process is to place an order in your own store and follow the entire path exactly as the customer does. It is worth then comparing this experience with purchases from a few competitors. Such a practical test can reveal problems that procedures, declared standards, or basic operational indicators do not show.

– summarizes Paweł Zakielarz, CEO of Shopreturns & Global24.

Methodology

The study was conducted in 2026 using the mystery shopping method. For the analysis, 20 online fashion stores operating on the German market were selected, representing various market segments, including international fashion brands, premium brands, footwear manufacturers, outdoor companies, brands operating in the direct-to-consumer model, and sellers offering sportswear, lingerie, accessories, and workwear. One real order was placed in each store, paid for with Shopreturns funds. The cart value ranged from 10 to 50 euros, and all shipments were delivered to an address in Germany using the standard delivery method offered by the seller. The analysis covered, among other things, the timeliness of order fulfillment, compliance of delivery with the declared deadline, packaging quality, communication with the customer, and the course of the shopping process until the shipment was delivered. The goal of the study was to identify recurring practices and phenomena occurring in the market, not to evaluate individual sellers. For this reason, the results are presented in an aggregated form, and the names of the analyzed stores remain anonymous.

 

Source:  AP Communication