⚙️
🌟 Najlepsze dopasowanie
Wpisz szukaną frazę, aby zobaczyć propozycje AI.

Is sending a cancellation notice enough to cancel an order?

Is sending a cancellation notice enough to cancel an order?

A company entered into a domestic carriage agreement, but it turned out that the goods the truck arrived to collect did not match the order. The transport could not take place. The principal sent a CANCELLATION notice by email the next day after 12:00 PM and announced that they would not reimburse the costs incurred by the contractor. Is it actually enough to send a cancellation notice to cancel an order? Is there a chance to recover the lost money?

Expert’s answer: Canceling a transport order falls under the scope of the right to dispose of the shipment. This right allows the sender to unilaterally amend the carriage agreement or even withdraw from it, both before the shipment is sent and during the transport. According to Art. 53 sec. 3 of the Transport Law, one may dispose of the shipment by submitting an appropriate written statement. The term “storno” (cancellation/reversal) refers to an entry canceling an erroneous accounting operation, so a court may rule that it cannot be treated as a withdrawal from the contract. When we want to amend or withdraw from a contract, a person authorized to represent the company should submit a statement that they are withdrawing from the contract and sign it by hand. I have encountered a judgment in which the court ruled that crossing out an order with the word “storno” does not constitute an effective statement on behalf of the company regarding withdrawal from a contract concluded with a carrier. Therefore, since there was no effective withdrawal from the contract, the carrier is entitled to compensation for damages resulting from the concluded contract.

The provisions of the Civil Code regarding liability for non-performance of an obligation (Art. 471 in conjunction with Art. 361 § 2 of the Civil Code) apply. In my opinion, they do not allow for equating damages with the amount of the freight. When formulating claims for damages, we would have to calculate the amount of the damage, in accordance with the Supreme Court judgment of December 11, 2007, issued in case II CSK 370/07, according to which: “To assess the validity of a claim for damages due to unjustified termination of a contract, it is not sufficient to state how much the injured party would have received if the contract had been performed, but rather what damage they actually suffered. Full remuneration cannot be equated with lost profit, as it constitutes revenue. Its acquisition is associated with specific costs, expenses, taxes, and other burdens that the injured party would have had to bear, and which they avoided as a result of the termination.”

For this reason, in order to pursue claims in the event of a lawsuit, it is necessary to demonstrate the amount of damage suffered by the company in connection with the order in question. The contractor may claim lost profits, i.e., the entire freight minus what they saved by not performing the order. When calculating savings, one must subtract the costs that would have been incurred anyway while performing the order, and one can claim what would have been earned by performing it. Therefore, one should subtract from the freight what the contractor saved by not performing the route, calculating the fuel saved by not driving to the place of unloading or road tolls that did not have to be paid, while leaving the driver’s salary already paid out.

However, I must admit that I have encountered judgments from courts of both instances that awarded the full remuneration, recognizing that since we are dealing with contractual liability (ex contractu), the loss of remuneration constitutes financial damage that remains in a normal causal link with the cancellation of the order, and since the carrier arrived at the loading site, they already incurred fuel costs and are entitled to the full remuneration. On the other hand, if the other party (the Principal) believes that savings were made, they should demonstrate them themselves, by specifying the exact savings or proving that the carrier concluded another contract and thus earned money despite the cancellation of the order. Therefore, one can try to claim the full remuneration, but be aware that the court may not award the entire freight. The Polish legal system allows the court to assess a specific case independently of other rulings, so unfortunately, it is difficult to predict the outcome of the case.

Legal basis:

Legal status of the publication (date): 2017-09-11