⚙️
🌟 Najlepsze dopasowanie
Wpisz szukaną frazę, aby zobaczyć propozycje AI.

Digital tachograph failure and carrier liability

Digital tachograph failure and carrier liability

During an international transport of goods, a driver noticed that the digital tachograph was not working correctly and a data reading error pictogram appeared on the display. What should the driver do in such a situation: should they return to the company’s base, or should the tachograph be repaired on the road?

Expert response: The procedure for a driver in the event of a tachograph failure is regulated by Article 37 of Regulation (EU) No 165/2014 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 4 February 2014 on tachographs in road transport, repealing Council Regulation (EEC) No 3821/85 on recording equipment in road transport (hereinafter Regulation 165/2014).

Article 37(1), first sentence, of Regulation 165/2014 establishes the general principle that in the event of a breakdown or faulty operation of a tachograph, the transport undertaking must have it repaired by an approved installer or workshop as soon as circumstances permit. Furthermore, in accordance with Article 37(1), second sentence, of Regulation 165/2014, if the vehicle cannot return to the transport undertaking’s base within one week from the day of the breakdown or the detection of the faulty operation, the repair must be carried out on the road.

Taking the above regulations into account, it should be clearly stated that a driver may drive with a faulty tachograph for up to one week from the day of the breakdown or detection of the faulty operation if returning the vehicle to the company’s base was not possible during that time. Of course, the question arises: what should be understood by the term “impossibility of returning the vehicle with a faulty tachograph to the company’s base for repair”? Should the interpretation of this provision lean towards the actual impossibility of reaching the base from the location where the vehicle was when the fault occurred or was detected, or rather towards protecting the continuity of the supply chain in which the vehicle with the faulty tachograph is participating?

Driving with a faulty tachograph imposes an obligation on the driver to manually record their activities. According to Article 37(2) of Regulation 165/2014, while the tachograph is not working or is working incorrectly, the driver must mark data enabling their identification (name, driver card number, or driving license number) along with their signature, as well as information regarding various periods that were not correctly recorded or printed by the tachograph: a) on the record sheet or sheets; or b) on a temporary sheet to be attached to the record sheet or driver card. Consequently, the driver should keep an ongoing record of their activity by making manual entries on the reverse side of the printout in the case of a digital tachograph or on the reverse side of the record sheet in the case of an analog tachograph (in the spaces intended for manual activity entry).

To avoid misunderstandings during an inspection, it would also be advisable to include the legal basis that allows for manual entries (for example, Article 37(2) of Regulation 165/2014).

It should also be noted that incorrect operation of the tachograph selector cannot be justified by a malfunction. Such action is incorrect and may lead to a penalty during an inspection. In the case of a driver operating with a faulty tachograph without meeting the conditions mentioned above, in accordance with Annex 1 to the Act of 6 September 2001 on Road Transport, item 13.4, performing road transport by a driver with a non-working or improperly working recording device or digital recording device after the expiry of the permissible period of driving is subject to a penalty of 1,000 PLN.

Incorrect operation of the recording device or digital recording device switch, which allows for changing the type of driver activity, is subject to a penalty of up to 1,000 PLN (100 PLN for each day).

At the same time, it should be pointed out that in accordance with Annex 2 to the Act of 6 September 2001 on Road Transport, item 16, allowing the performance of road transport with a vehicle causing noise exceeding the permissible level is subject to a penalty of 2,000 PLN.

In summary, in the presented situation, the driver may continue driving with a tachograph that has broken down or is working incorrectly for up to one week from the day of the breakdown or the day the faulty operation was detected. After this period, the tachograph should be repaired at the company’s base or on the road – in the event that returning it to the company’s base was impossible. At the same time, it should be remembered that the driver should make manual entries of their activity on the reverse side of the printout.

Legal basis:

Legal status of the publication (date): 2018-01-08