The transport industry is an undeniable pillar of the global economy, playing a key role in ensuring the fluidity of supply chains. And for years, Poland has maintained its position as a leader in international transport, accounting for as much as 20% of the total transport work in the European Union. However, despite this impressive result, the industry faces numerous legal and organizational challenges every day. What challenges are we talking about?
The strong position of the Polish transport sector on the international stage does not protect it from problems typical of the industry. Even the introduction of the Mobility Package by the European Union, intended to improve working conditions and secure the rights of employees, has brought a series of difficulties for entrepreneurs.
Legal challenges that transport companies most often face in their operations include issues regarding the posting of drivers, the introduction of second-generation tachographs, irregularities in transport contracts, and errors in filling out CMR documentation. Regulations related to entering green zones and issues concerning illegal immigrants entering vehicles during goods transport to the United Kingdom are also problematic. It is therefore worth taking a closer look at these aspects to understand what problems transport companies encounter in their daily operations and which solutions might be helpful to them.
The Mobility Package – help, but also a challenge
The introduction of the Mobility Package by the European Union in 2022, and subsequent changes to regulations in 2023, turned the entire transport sector upside down. This package, aimed at regulating and exercising greater control over the activities of transport companies, as well as protecting the rights of employees in this sector, proved to be quite a challenge for many companies. As it turned out, the obstacle was not so much the legal problems themselves as the new regulations burdening the industry with new obligations. The aforementioned changes led to the generation of new, significant costs, chaotic work reorganization, or the problem of illegal cabotage, which led to unfair competition and threatened the working conditions of drivers:
– One of the main legal problems faced by entrepreneurs in the TSL industry after the introduction of the Mobility Package is the need to comply with complex regulations regarding the organization of drivers’ work and rest, which is associated with restrictions and strict limits. This, in turn, generates significant operational costs and requires strict control and monitoring to avoid violations of the law. An additional challenge is also the obligation to obtain a license for van-type vehicles. A large number of entrepreneurs had a problem with submitting their applications on time, which resulted in them operating without a license, exposing themselves to very high fines, or suspending their operations until they obtained a permit. Moreover, the new Mobility Package regulations forced the necessity to adapt the HR system to the new rules for settling PIT and ZUS. In addition, entrepreneurs had to face challenges related to the ambiguity and sometimes incompleteness of the new EU regulations. Updates to EU regulations unfortunately still require carrying out new legal analyses and consultations – says Maciej Maroszyk, Chief Operating Officer at TC Kancelaria Prawna.
Restrictions on cabotage are also a challenge for transport companies. They are intended to prevent the excessive use of this form of transport by foreign companies. The limitations cause additional difficulties in managing transport operations and can lead to legal disputes. All these issues require TSL industry entrepreneurs to constantly adapt to changing regulations and strictly follow the law, which creates additional operational challenges.
Who is responsible – the carrier or the freight forwarder?
Another important issue is the awareness that the obligations related to the Mobility Package do not only apply to carriers. One must also remember about the offenses of freight forwarders. They play a key role in organizing and coordinating transport. However, they do not always realize that their actions are also subject to regulations and legal requirements, and inaccuracies in documentation or failure to fulfill obligations can lead to sanctions. For this reason, it is important that freight forwarders are aware of their responsibilities and have adequate knowledge of the applicable regulations.
– Freight forwarders are often intermediaries between carriers and customers. Therefore, they must be able to clearly define what obligations rest on the carriers and customers, and ensure that all transactions are correctly documented. Inaccuracies in contracts or the lack of appropriate documentation can lead to misunderstandings, and even legal disputes – says Maciej Maroszyk of TC Kancelaria Prawna.
New and problematic tachographs
In light of the problems with the Mobility Package, one cannot forget about the challenges regarding the mandate to use new second-generation tachographs. As it turned out, due to the lack of this type of equipment on the market, a problem arose with the timely registration of vehicles, as well as fines for providing services excluded from the posting regulations.
– Regulations in force since August 21, 2023, make it impossible to perform loading and unloading without installing a higher generation of tachographs in new vehicles. And failure to comply with these regulations is associated with high fines. What is disturbing is that there are no second-generation digital tachographs on the market, and there will not be until the end of the current year due to the European Space Agency’s problems with implementing the Galileo satellite navigation system. This matter has therefore become extremely alarming for transport companies, which must be ready to adapt to the changing legal and organizational environment – says Maciej Maroszyk of TC Kancelaria Prawna.
Wishing to maintain the schedule for introducing the Mobility Package, the European Commission has taken steps to regulate the requirements for installing new tachographs. The new regulations made it possible to install transitional tachographs until May 2024. However, this does not mean there are no expenses that entrepreneurs must incur when switching to the new devices.
Posting of drivers for international transport
Daily legal problems often also arise when posting drivers for work, especially in international transport. Interestingly, this became much more complicated with the introduction of the Mobility Package. From that moment on, transport companies had to adjust minimum wage rates to the salaries in the countries where the posted workers are employed. This, in turn, led to a sudden increase in operational costs, affecting the profitability and financial liquidity of companies.
– Posting drivers requires attention to many aspects to avoid potential legal problems. Firstly, every country has its own regulations regarding employment and the posting of workers, so companies must be aware of the differences between them. Furthermore, posting workers requires the preparation of many documents, such as contracts, social security certificates, and proof of tax payments, which requires diligence in documenting processes. And the need to adjust contracts to new regulations can lead to conflicts and legal disputes, especially if employees expect an increase in remuneration or other benefits resulting from these changes – explains the Chief Operating Officer of TC Kancelaria Prawna.
The expert also adds that the introduction of new regulations may result in increased supervision by control bodies and labor inspections. Companies must therefore ensure that all requirements are met to avoid potential sanctions.
– Posting drivers in road transport is associated with obligations imposed by the posting law in a given country – for example, in Poland, it is the National Labour Inspectorate. Entrepreneurs must submit an appropriate notification via an online form, and the latest deadline is the day of starting the posting in a given country. It is worth noting that this obligation applies to cross-trade and cabotage transports. And legal problems can also arise from a driver’s improper interpretation of the type of transport, which can lead to tickets and fines – says Maciej Maroszyk.
Irregularities in transport contracts
Beyond legal changes, the very construction of transport contracts remains significant in light of the daily legal problems of transport companies. Although they are a key element regulating the activities of carriers, they often contain errors or absurdities that lead to conflicts and legal problems.
– One of the pressing problems is unfavorably formulated clauses in transport contracts. They lead to misunderstandings and disputes between the carrier and the customer. Poorly written contracts can also result in difficulties in interpreting the rights and obligations of the parties, which creates a risk of litigation – points out Maciej Maroszyk of TC Kancelaria Prawna.
Professional legal advice plays a key role in solving these problems.
Errors in CMR documentation
Incorrectly filled out CMR documentation is also problematic – interestingly, this fact often results not so much from negligence as from the ignorance of carriers. However, the introduction of the electronic version, eCMR, will mean that these problems will be minimized because the system can automatically verify and correct errors in the filled-out documentation, eliminating inaccuracies resulting from the ignorance of carriers and simplifying the process of creating and sending CMR documents. Moreover, the problem of late document delivery will disappear.
– Often it is precisely incorrect or incomplete information contained in the CMR documentation that leads to disputes, especially if it affects the rights and obligations of the parties involved in the transport process. Errors in transport documents also affect disruptions in logistics operations, such as delays in transport, incorrect delivery of goods, or difficulties in resolving transport claims. Such lapses can result in contractual penalties or fines imposed by control authorities in the event of discovering irregularities in the documentation. Therefore, the necessity of correctly filling out traditional CMR documents remains a key aspect in the transport industry’s activities, regardless of the potential conveniences introduced by eCMR – adds the Chief Operating Officer of TC Kancelaria Prawna.
Does ignorance of the law harm?
It is worth keeping in mind that ignorance of the law has a negative impact on business operations. For example, if a driver enters an area where specific traffic regulations apply and does not follow them, they will receive a ticket. The same applies in other cases related to transport activity, for example, in connection with a lack of diligence in registering and declaring vehicles. Many entrepreneurs may skip these obligations or not check for emerging changes in regulations. It often happens that people who registered their vehicles a few years ago believe that these documents are still valid without changes. This is a mistake, however, because regulations change, which is why monitoring and regularly adapting to new standards is essential.
– Transport companies often look for ways to maximize profits, so drivers may try to avoid following certain regulations, e.g., not stopping at the base at a specific time. However, it must be remembered that violating regulations can lead to legal consequences and is a risky action – reminds Maciej Maroszyk of TC Kancelaria Prawna.
Transport companies must face various legal and organizational problems every day that significantly affect their operations. Some of them are related to the introduction of the Mobility Package and new requirements regarding employee remuneration. Inaccuracies in transport contracts and CMR documentation can also lead to serious legal consequences. For this reason, it is important that transport companies regularly update their legal and organizational knowledge. Specialized law firms provide invaluable help in this regard, whose knowledge and experience allow them to avoid or resolve legal problems and conflicts.
Source: TC Kancelaria Prawna








