What are the obligations of online platforms? The Digital Services Act

What are the obligations of online platforms? The Digital Services Act

The new European regulation, known as the Digital Services Act (DSA), introduces many real changes to this rapidly developing market. One of the most important novelties is the implementation of additional obligations for online platforms. What should you pay attention to when running an online platform in the face of new European regulations?

What is an online platform?

We can find the definition of an online platform in the Digital Services Act in Article 2(h) of the draft DSA. According to this definition, an online platform should be perceived as: a provider of a hosting service which, at the request of a recipient of the service, stores and disseminates information to the public, unless that activity is a minor and purely ancillary feature of another service and, for objective and technical reasons, cannot be used without that other service, and the integration of such a feature into such other service is not a means to circumvent the application of this Regulation. This means that the new regulation covers all websites and social media portals.

Nevertheless, the new rules will not affect, for example, online editions of newspapers that have sections for comments, as this functionality is of an additional/ancillary nature (the main service is the publication of news). The new regulations will also not apply to providers of electronic communications services – provided that their application only allows for communication, without being merely an addition to a social media portal (as is the case, for example, with Facebook and Messenger), as well as providers of services such as email, group chat services, and instant messengers.

The new provisions of the Digital Services Act will cover:

  • social media services,
  • online marketplaces, e-commerce,
  • online app stores (e.g., Google Play or App Store),
  • content sharing platforms,
  • online services enabling, for example, the purchase of tourist services or the rental of premises from private individuals,
  • platforms that qualify as micro-enterprises or small enterprises within the meaning of the annex to Recommendation 2003/361/EC (Art. 16),
  • platforms to which additional – relative to hosting services – obligations apply (Art. 17 et seq.),
  • “very large online platforms” (Art. 25 et seq. – this concerns, among others, Facebook or Twitter),

In the case of the last three groups, the application of specific obligations contained in the draft Act has been linked to the size of a given platform based on the principle of proportionality. Within this, we distinguish 3 categories:

  • Platforms meeting the criteria of a micro-enterprise, i.e., employing fewer than 10 people, with an annual turnover and/or annual balance sheet total of less than EUR 2 million (Art. 2(3)),
  • Platforms meeting the criteria of a small enterprise, i.e., employing more than 10 but fewer than 50 people, with an annual turnover and/or annual balance sheet total of less than EUR 10 million (Art. 2(2)(c)),
  • Platforms that meet the criteria of a “very large online platform,” i.e., employing over 50 people, with an annual turnover and/or annual balance sheet total exceeding EUR 10 million (i.e., for example, Facebook or Twitter).

Such a distinction serves to assign the largest number of new obligations to the third group, i.e., very large platforms. In contrast, for the remaining, smaller entities, there will only be a slight change in the current situation.

What are the obligations of online platforms? The Digital Services Act

What obligations does the Digital Services Act include?

To begin with, one should check to which category of platforms our business belongs, because each group has different obligations. In the case of “ordinary” platforms, i.e., those that do not constitute very large online platforms, the new requirements will consist only of:

  • obligations related to content moderation posted on platforms;
  • obligations regarding the transparency of online marketplaces;
  • obligations regarding the transparency of online advertisements;
  • reporting obligations of online platforms.

In turn, “very large online platforms,” in addition to the above, must also meet further reaching obligations. What will the law provide for within the aforementioned groups of obligations?

  • Obligation to moderate the platform – i.e., the necessity to take actions aimed at detecting, identifying, and combating illegal content or information inconsistent with the terms of service of the platform. For this purpose, it is necessary to implement measures affecting the availability, visibility, and accessibility of such illegal content or information. In practice, platform owners must implement tools on their sites that allow limiting the exposure of such content, as well as enabling the blocking or removal of such posts, or the suspension and deletion of accounts of persons who post these entries. The removal of the content alone is not enough – according to the new regulations, it must also be guaranteed that the given content will not be reposted.
  • Easy and effective challenging of online platform decisions – if a platform’s decisions have a negative impact on a user, they must have the ability to simply and effectively challenge such decisions. This refers mainly to decisions related to the removal of information or preventing access to it, suspension or termination of service provision to such a user, or suspension and deletion of an account. As a result, platforms will be obliged to create an internal complaint-handling system for the indicated decisions (Article 17, paragraphs 1-4). The system should be easily accessible and user-friendly, and also not fully automated (Art. 17(5)).
  • Cooperation with certified bodies – platforms must cooperate with out-of-court dispute resolution bodies in order to resolve conflict situations with users (Article 18(1)). These bodies must be certified, and the certification is to be carried out by the Digital Services Coordinator, while decisions issued by a given body will be binding on the platforms. At the same time, it will still be possible to use other remedies admissible in a given member country.
  • Priority treatment of reports from trusted entities – the obligation to moderate also applies to the obligation to prioritize reports from entities that have received the newly introduced status of trusted flaggers, which will be granted by the Digital Services Coordinator at the request of the interested party.
  • Informing law enforcement in case of suspected serious crimes – platforms must inform the appropriate law enforcement authorities if they obtain information providing grounds for suspecting a “serious crime,” i.e., one that may pose a threat to the life or safety of individuals (Article 21). This concerns information obtained both on their own and that provided by a user. However, it must be remembered that this requirement cannot be the basis for mass profiling of service recipients.
  • Protection against misuse of the platform and the “notice & take action” system – i.e., the introduction of measures to prevent improper use of the platform and the “notice & take action” system, which will allow for countering the dissemination of illegal content (Art. 20(1)), as well as abuses in terms of submitting unfounded notices and complaints within the “notice & take action” mechanism (e.g., when someone does this to block competition). Sanctions are provided for such abuses, so after a mandatory warning to the user, the platform may suspend the provision of services to them or deprive them of the ability to submit complaints and notices using the mentioned mechanisms.

In addition, platforms are required to describe the above issues in their terms and conditions, especially the method and basis for assessing behaviors that will be considered “improper use,” as well as the anticipated period of suspension (Article 20(4)).

The issue of illegal products

One of the premises of the draft is to discourage entrepreneurs from selling products or services that violate relevant regulations. As part of this, the act assumes the introduction of 2 further groups of obligations.

The first is to oblige platforms to block the sale of illegal goods or services placed on the platform, including blocking advertisements. Such actions are to be implemented based on specific rules and regulations related to the removal of illegal content that function in member countries.

The second group of obligations is to force platforms that enable consumers to conclude distance contracts with entrepreneurs to ensure the traceability of those entrepreneurs. Therefore, the mentioned platforms will have to identify their business users each time. In turn, they should clearly explain to customers who is selling them a specific product or offering a service. This is intended to contribute to easier detection of dishonest sellers and better protection of buyers online.

Importantly, for the first time at the European level, an obligation has been introduced to verify the submitted data based on available databases. It is planned to oblige platforms to take reasonable actions, i.e., bypassing excessive burdens, which will aim to verify the reliability of information provided by partners. For this purpose, it is recommended to “use publicly available official online databases and online interfaces, such as national commercial registers and the VAT information exchange system.” Besides that, there is also the possibility of requiring platforms to present credible documentation that confirms information provided by potential partners, e.g., copies of identity documents, or even certified bank statements, certificates of business registration, and certificates from commercial registers.

Nevertheless, the above solutions are only optional possibilities for online platforms. The regulation explicitly indicates that one does not have to engage in excessive or costly activities related to partner verification. This does not change the fact that the more actions the platform takes, the better.

Furthermore, platforms are also obliged to store information concerning entrepreneurs using their services for the duration of the contractual relationship with a given entrepreneur (Article 22(4)).

Advertisements in the light of the Digital Services Act

According to the proposed changes, platforms will also have additional information obligations regarding advertisements. Article 24 of the DSA states that platforms must ensure users have the ability to read information about when and on whose behalf a given advertisement is displayed to them. Platforms will therefore transmit information about advertisements in real-time, which will allow for their identification, indicate on whose behalf they are displayed, and provide “significant information” about the main parameters used to target advertisements to the consumer (in the context of a specific advertisement and a specific user).

How is this supposed to look in practice? Probably, after hovering over an advertisement, a message will appear informing the user that they are dealing with an advertisement, who its author is, and why it was displayed to them.

Reporting for digital services

Another novelty is numerous, additional obligations for online platforms regarding reporting issues (Article 23). Platforms will therefore be obliged to publish reports on their actions related to the removal of and preventing access to information that is considered illegal or contrary to the terms of service (Article 23(1)). It will likely take the form of a structured report containing relevant descriptions and figures.

Besides that, at least once every six months, platforms will have to publish information on the average number of monthly active service recipients broken down by each European Union country (Article 23(2)). The purpose of such actions will be the ongoing verification of the platform’s status and its obligations by the Digital Services Coordinator.

What are the obligations of online platforms? The Digital Services ActMore obligations for certain platforms

The reason for the greater number of obligations for very large online platforms is the fact that it is their activity that can cause social risks. The scope of these risks and their consequences are potentially more dangerous than is the case with small platforms. As a result, it was established that these largest entities must meet elevated standards of obligations regarding due diligence.

Five groups of obligations were distinguished for them:

  • obligations regarding the management of systemic risk resulting from the functioning of very large platforms;
  • obligations related to recommendation systems;
  • additional requirements regarding the transparency of online advertisements;
  • rules for data access and data control;
  • obligation to appoint compliance officers.

As can be seen, very large platforms must first conduct an assessment of so-called systemic risks contained in Art. 26(1) of the draft, taking into account the specificity of the services provided by them. These are, for example:

  • risks related to the improper use of their services through the dissemination of illegal content, e.g., inciting hatred,
  • conducting illegal activities, such as the sale of products or services prohibited by Union law or national law, including counterfeit products,
  • conducting illegal activities through the use of the platform’s accounts;
  • risks of deliberate and often coordinated manipulation of platform services, which has a predictable impact on health, civic discourse, electoral processes, public safety, and the protection of minors, etc.

The next step after conducting such an analysis will be to choose appropriate measures that will prevent or at least minimize the risk of the detected risks occurring. Importantly, very large platforms will also be obliged to undergo external control in the form of an independent audit.

In the case of recommendations, the regulation of this aspect is the result of insufficient information provided to users. Part of the activity of a very large online platform is the way of ranking and presenting information so as to facilitate and optimize access to it for users. Usually, this consists of, for example, suggesting, ranking, and ordering information by an algorithm, and highlighting it through text and various graphic representations. As a result, it was decided that the user should be informed about why they are seeing specific content.

Recommendation systems can significantly influence the ability of users to obtain information online and interact with it. Therefore, the draft provides that very large online platforms must properly inform users and provide them with influence over the presented information. They should present the main parameters of the systems in an easily understandable and accessible way so that the recipient understands how information is ranked. Furthermore, recipients should be provided with the possibility of modifying relevant criteria and opting out of receiving personalized recommendations.

Transparency of online advertisements

Transparency of online advertisements is intended to provide a chance for more effective supervision over how they are displayed. As a result, platforms will have to maintain and provide access to advertisements displayed on their pages in order to enable, among others, users and supervisory authorities to check how advertisements were displayed and targeted (e.g., in order to verify whether there was no use of illegal messaging, manipulative techniques, or disinformation). Such databases are to contain: the content of advertisements, the period of their display, the number of target recipients, and the number of recipients reached, as well as data concerning the advertiser (Article 30 paragraphs 1 and 2) for at least one year from the last display.

The rules for data access and their control consist of the fact that upon a reasoned request of the Digital Services Coordinator or the European Commission, very large platforms will provide data needed to monitor the compliance of their functioning with the provisions of the DSA (Art. 31(1)). As a result, they will have to provide data related to risk and possible harms, data regarding the accuracy, functioning, and testing of content moderation algorithms, recommendation or advertising systems, data regarding the processes and results of content moderation or internal complaint-handling systems, etc. The aforementioned authorities may also request the provision of such data to verified academic researchers, which is discussed in Article 31 paragraphs 2 and 4.

Another obligation of very large online platforms will be the necessity to appoint compliance officers. As part of this change, it will be necessary to appoint at least one employee responsible for monitoring compliance with the provisions of the regulation (according to Article 32(1)).