
For years, we have been observing a gradual shift of trade to the Internet. As a result, sellers must reckon with an increasing number of requirements they need to meet. Consumer protection is therefore becoming increasingly rigorous. We can notice such trends not only in Poland but throughout the European Union, where almost the same rules apply. The purpose of introducing standardized rules is to ensure consumer safety, which simultaneously puts a burden on sellers.
In this article, you will find an overview of the most important issues related to conducting transactions with a consumer from the perspective of an entrepreneur running an online store. We also explain when one can actually speak of a consumer purchase. To begin with, it is worth noting that in the case of online stores, the most commonly used types of contracts are those concluded using means of distance communication, i.e., e.g., the Internet.
Consumer – definition of the concept according to the Civil Code
A direct definition of a consumer can be found in the provisions of the Civil Code (Art. 22 [1] CC). The Consumer Rights Act does not contain a separate explanation of this term, which is why the definition from the Civil Code is treated as binding for its purposes.
According to this provision, a consumer is a natural person performing a legal act with an entrepreneur that is not directly related to their business activity. Here is an explanation of each element of this definition:
- Natural person – according to EU regulations applicable in the Polish legal order, a consumer cannot be any entity other than a natural person. Therefore, it is excluded to include such entities as, for example, commercial companies, associations, municipalities, or foundations in this category.
- Performing a legal act with an entrepreneur – here we find as many as two premises: first, performing an act with an entrepreneur, and second, performing a legal act. We explain the concept of an entrepreneur in the next paragraph, while the premise in the form of the occurrence of a legal act signals that many other factual acts of the consumer directed at the entrepreneur will not benefit from protection.
- Lack of a direct connection with the consumer’s business activity – consumer regulations are intended to reduce the advantage of one party to a transaction over the other. The legislator assumes that one of the reasons for this imbalance can be the lack of knowledge about concluded contracts, which the consumer exhibits. In a situation of a direct connection with business activity, however, this entity exhibits specialized knowledge, sometimes even higher than the other party to the contract. As a result, they do not need to gain greater protection in the event of concluding contracts. Importantly, if we were to consider such an entity a consumer, it would be contrary to a large number of previously implemented national regulations, while the scope of activities defined as being performed between entrepreneurs would be small.
Only meeting all the above-mentioned premises entitles a given entity to use the protection guaranteed to a consumer. However, the situation in which a person concludes a contract both for conducting business activity and for private purposes raises significant doubts. In such a case, it is assumed that the main purpose of concluding the contract will prevail. An entity concluding a contract for a purpose other than conducting business is referred to as an entrepreneur with consumer rights. Such an entity may benefit from some consumer rights.

Who is an entrepreneur and what are their obligations?
In the face of the definition of a consumer and the functioning of one of the premises, i.e., concluding a contract with an entrepreneur, it will be important to indicate who an entrepreneur is.
An entrepreneur is defined as any natural or legal person who conducts business or professional activity on their own behalf, and it is irrelevant whether this entity is a private or public entity. It is important, however, that this activity must be of a commercial nature and should be performed continuously (in accordance with Art. 43 [1] CC).
An entrepreneur is considered to be the party to a contract possessing greater knowledge and the ability to shape the legal relationship according to their preferences, i.e., in the opinion of the legislator, it is they who should bear special obligations.
Interestingly, the obligations of an entrepreneur running an online store are not contained in one single legislative act. Their shape is therefore quite complex and complicated. In order to facilitate the understanding of this matter, we will discuss the most important of them in chronological order: from the moment of establishing contact with the consumer, through the sale, to post-sales service.
Stage 1: before concluding a contract
First of all, it is most important to fulfill information obligations. The entrepreneur should inform the consumer in Polish about all the most important issues regarding their own performance and that of the consumer. They must, among other things, specify the total price or the method of calculating it, and other specific issues required by regulations. Any assurances that an entrepreneur makes publicly are considered binding.
The template of the contract applicable to the consumer must be made available to them. Contrary to popular belief, it is not enough that the consumer can easily familiarize themselves with it (385 CC). It is not possible to conclude a contract with a consumer by referring to terms and conditions that they have never seen. In the situation of using provisions from a contract template that are contrary to good customs, they are considered non-binding.
Stage 2: during the conclusion of a contract
An entrepreneur has no right to charge the consumer higher payment costs than those the entrepreneur has incurred themselves (383 [1] CC). Besides, when a seller concludes a contract with a consumer, they must reckon with the fact that any unclear contractual provisions will be interpreted in favor of the weaker party to this relationship. At the moment of ordering, the consumer must receive information that it involves an obligation to pay. When the buyer addresses the seller with any question about the contract, the seller is obliged to provide an answer.
The Civil Code contains an entire list of prohibited clauses that cannot be included in contracts with a consumer. In the event of their inclusion, they will be considered invalid (Art. 385 [3] CC). This refers, among other things, to the exemption from liability by the entrepreneur in specific situations.
Stage 3: contract performance
The place of performance is considered the place of delivery of the goods to the consumer, and provisions to the contrary are considered void (Art. 454 [1] CC). The delivery of the item to the consumer must take place no later than 30 days after the conclusion of the contract. In the case of exceeding this deadline and the entrepreneur setting a new one again to no avail, the buyer may withdraw from the contract. The risk of accidental loss of the object passes to the consumer only at the moment of delivery of the object (Art. 546 [1] CC). The exception is a situation in which the consumer had complete freedom in choosing the method of delivery.
Stage 4: after contract performance
In the event of a change of mind and considering even a non-defective item as not meeting expectations, the consumer can return it within 14 days of receiving the item (Art. 494 CC), and the entrepreneur should return the received benefit without delay. One should inform the consumer about such a right at the stage of concluding the contract (Art. 12 of the Consumer Rights Act). The seller may withhold the return of the paid amount until the moment they receive information confirming the dispatch or the return of the package (depending on which occurs earlier).
In a situation where a defect in an item purchased by a consumer is discovered within a year of its sale, it is presumed that the defect occurred while still at the seller’s. The burden of proof to the contrary rests with the entrepreneur. In such a case, the consumer can report a claim under the warranty. The seller has 30 days to recognize it and justify their own position. Limiting the scope of the warranty in contracts with a consumer is impossible (Art. 558 CC).
All the obligations of the entrepreneur described above could be the subject of a separate study. When concluding a contract with a consumer, one must exercise special caution and try to fulfill all required standards. It is also worth mentioning that it is prohibited to present statutory consumer rights as “bonus” rights. Such behavior has already been the subject of proceedings before the Office of Competition and Consumer Protection, where it was stated that it is a misleading move.

Dispute between an e-shop and a consumer. Principles of conduct
Due to the fact that this article is intended to explain the situation of an entrepreneur in relations with a consumer, we will omit discussing the possibilities for the buyer to pursue their claims. As you can guess, there are really many of them. We will, however, present what an entrepreneur can do in a situation of a dispute with a consumer.
- Before we get into any dispute, it is worth considering whether we have actually fulfilled our obligations, which were described above. If this was not the case, sometimes it is worth making a concession and resolving the matter amicably. Unfortunately, in the event of failure to fulfill obligations, the chances of success are slim, while Polish courts are much more favorable to consumers than to entrepreneurs.
- Do not panic – this is the main principle worth remembering. The Office of Competition and Consumer Protection is often involved in consumer disputes. Most sellers, out of fear, agree with the consumer to avoid a dispute. However, this is not always a good path, as every situation should be preceded by proper consideration, about which we wrote in the previous point.
- Thirdly, the consumer must obtain exhaustive answers to all questions and allegations from us at every stage of contact. In this way, we will be able not only to review the correctness of our reasoning again, but we will also obtain an excellent basis for proving the correctness of our conduct in the event of a possible court trial.
Finally, it must be noted that a consumer is a party to a legal relationship like any other entity. If they do not fulfill their obligations, and e.g., have already received the ordered item, you can sue them and pursue justice on general principles. Unfortunately, many entrepreneurs unnecessarily give up even before an official court dispute arises.
Consumer legal protection in the European Union
In all EU countries, almost identical consumer legal protection applies. National legislators have only minimal ability to adapt these regulations to their own needs. Such a system serves to maximize protection and create a simple path for the consumer in disputes with an entrepreneur, although for the latter, it is also a significant facilitation.
Uniform regulations are the result of applying the rule of maximum synchronization of standards of all countries, which the Union has adopted in this area. This means that the EU not only sets minimum standards but also indicates the highest level of consumer protection. Therefore, one cannot either reduce this protection in national legislation or extend it.








