
In this year’s edition of the Polishopa Honeycombs Award, the project by the Łukasiewicz – Institute of Logistics and Warehousing titled “Mobile and stationary sensor network with a base station and electronic seal” won in the business category. The solution was created by a team led by PhD Eng. Michał Grabia, supported during the project implementation by Design Thinking expert Dr. Piotr Nowak. Joanna Świątek, Head of the Marketing Department at Łukasiewicz-ILiM, and Patrycja Skoczek, Specialist at Łukasiewicz-ITME, interview the award winners.
– Your project received the Polishopa Honeycombs Award. How long did you work on it and what was your goal?
Michał Grabia: We carried out the first development works and technological analyses in search of a product and prototyping its concept as early as 2014. It was then that we became interested in the rapidly developing group of technologies known as low-power sensor networks. These are very energy-efficient wireless communication technologies capable of transmitting signals over very long distances. This is an area of the so-called Internet of Things (IoT) – a field of new communication technologies, of which Bluetooth is an example. We chose a technology already associated with the logistics industry, which was originally developed by SAVI Technology, a company belonging to Lockheed Martin, the American military industry giant. At that stage, it was intended to support logistics processes on the battlefield – it was an active RFID system. Later, this solution also began to be used commercially in the civilian sector. That was the prototype of our technology.
We became members of the DASH7 Alliance in order to develop more extensive methods based on the original solution and utilize their technological capabilities. We asked ourselves: How can we apply such technology in practice? And that is when Piotr appeared with the proposal to use the Design Thinking methodology to answer this question. At the beginning, we analyzed our technology and our solution. We evaluated its features – all of them – both the limitations and the possibilities that distinguish this technology from others. We started looking for practical applications, that is, answers to problems observed in logistics.
Piotr Nowak: A role for Design Thinking emerged. We started wondering – which direction to take with this technology to use it as effectively and practically as possible in widely understood logistics? Not just in the warehouse (intralogistics), but also in transport.
M.G.: And we found an important problem to solve – our goal. How to monitor and track cargo at the level of LU (Loading Units – e.g., a container or a pallet with goods) regardless of whether we use our own transport or the services of a hired carrier.
– What did the competition jury appreciate your project for? What is innovative about it?
M.G.: We were appreciated for a solution for transport control and tracking objects in supply chains, regardless of the means of transport used. Although we focused on the transport part for a while, we also added the aforementioned intralogistics, which we had previously written off because it seemed little “sexy” to us. However, it turned out that only combining both of these parts shows the incredible capabilities of the technology. We developed a solution based on low-power sensor network technologies, which is designed to cover the entire supply chain of products. Its characteristic feature is that it is a single system covering the track&trace method and widely understood product safety in both intralogistics and transport.
The competition jury appreciated us for the functionality, innovation, and scalability of the solution, as well as the market potential and the significant impact on the environment that we can achieve through its application. As part of this solution, it is possible to fully monitor environmental conditions and functional parameters both at the level of entire warehouses and individual vehicles or loading units.
It seemed to us ultra-innovative and interesting that the same technology, the same solution, and the same communication protocol provide a huge range of possibilities for very precise tracking and monitoring of logistics units (pallets, containers, bins) inside and outside the warehouse. You can see the entire process captured by one system and one communication standard – DASH7, and collect data from all locations into one cloud system.
P.N.: In the course of development, the Design Thinking method was used, and this was crucial during the evaluation of this project. The competition jury appreciated the use of elements characteristic of Design Thinking in our design activities, such as user orientation, iterative approach, rapid prototyping, and testing of solution variants.
– Can you explain what the Design Thinking method is generally about? How did you apply this method in the project?
P.N.: Design Thinking is a kind of process that aims to create an innovation that responds to a real need identified among customers. It consists of four stages: observation and redefinition, ideation, choosing an idea and prototyping it, and testing.
The first stage is an in-depth analysis of what is possible in the context of developing technology and how this technology, with its parameters, can be best used. This is the OBSERVATION stage, also often called EMPATHY due to its focus on user needs. After it comes the time to define or redefine the problem to be solved. This phase is an introduction to the next one – IDEATION, where we look for ideas for solving the previously defined problem, in our case, for using the available technology to solve the identified user needs. After making the CHOICE of one of the ideas for further development, PROTOTYPING occurs (we prototyped, for example, elements of the electronic seal solution), and then, in the final phase, TESTING the prototype (various variants and functionalities of the solution were tested with different users).
The whole process is interactive, so there were subsequent approaches to check how the solution we are working on performs in successive industries. We invited companies and potential users to workshops – that is exactly what Design Thinking is about – every action is carried out with the participation of potential users. They were involved in the process from the beginning and their opinion was especially important to us at every stage of the process. The process was very extended in time because we were learning – both the technology and the methodology. The idea of using Design Thinking developed in parallel with the innovation being developed by Michał’s team.
– Do you see applications for the results of your project in other branches of industry?
M.G.: Logistics is horizontal and universal – we have the privilege of being able to address our offer to all industries. Our system is complex and uses low-power sensor network technology. We were focused on logistics, on what we know, and we deliberately chose this industry.
Market analysis showed that there is an American start-up trying to explore a similar technology and this topic, but not as broadly as we propose. Nevertheless, we were glad when it turned out that the market is interested in this company, it has funding, investors, has customers, and is developing dynamically. In a word, there is demand and room for them and for us. And in our opinion, our solution is better. Implementing it in companies brings benefits related to reducing losses and costs and provides the ability to react immediately to events that could potentially limit the value of transported goods.
– Why Design Thinking and not other creative problem-solving methods? Do you know and use other methods to support projects in your daily work?
P.N.: Design Thinking is a universal method and naturally responded to the current need we had in the case of our technology. From an internship at Stanford University, which I completed as part of the TOP 500 Innovators program, I brought knowledge about creative teamwork techniques (including Design Thinking), which we wanted to apply in the institute’s activities and projects.
M.G.: This resulted mainly from the goal that guided us, which was the search for solutions, specific technological niches, innovations, and their selection for implementation purposes. We thought it would be good to handle this professionally. That is how large corporations operate.
Do we know other methods? Trend analysis and foresight methods are extremely interesting. It would be cool to develop and apply them in practice. This all fits in with inventics and strategic thinking about the development of research. Inventics and the development of competencies in this area at Łukasiewicz would be super interesting, and I would be very happy to get involved in such activities.
P.N.: We also had training in other techniques, e.g., TRIZ – it is a method with huge potential, but not yet explored by us, and it is difficult for us to apply it in practice for now. We need more knowledge, but we are aware of its potential, although it is rather attributed to mechanical problems. In the perspective of the entire Łukasiewicz network, TRIZ could have a large application, but this requires an in-depth analysis of how to apply it.
– What tips would you give to those starting their adventure with Design Thinking? Is reading or the Internet enough, or is training necessary?
P.N.: There are many publications, but it is best to take part in the activity itself, in the process, because there are many nuances, and the best learning is learning through experience. Of course, if someone is interested in the topic of DT, there are many materials online, but in my opinion, it is best to participate in courses (even online) and try your hand at workshops that are a response to specific challenges. I especially recommend the currently ongoing course at the Hasso Plattner Institute at the University of Potsdam, which is interactive – which in my opinion is the most important thing.








