Road hauliers in Europe doomed to rising costs

Road hauliers in Europe doomed to rising costs

Road hauliers operating in Europe must face numerous barriers to development in the coming years. It is clear that their operating costs will rise, due to, among other things, legislative changes related to the Mobility Package, which the industry is awaiting with concern, toll hikes in many countries, and increasing traffic restrictions in Austria. Poland, the current absolute leader in road transport in Europe, has the most to lose in this situation.

Driver shortages are here and it is unlikely to get better
– While one of the fundamental challenges for the transport sector is the shortage of employees, it seems that all countries (even on a global scale) are in the same boat in this regard. For example, Germany is short of over 40,000 truck drivers, similarly to France, and demographic changes will exacerbate this deficit. In the significantly smaller Netherlands, at the end of 2017, there was a shortage of as many as 7,000 drivers. In Austria, meanwhile, 77 percent of hauliers have to decline some orders due to a lack of workforce. In Poland, data from 2016 mentions 100,000 additional people needed to work behind the wheel of a truck. However, it must be noted that with the increasing growth rate of goods transport by Polish entrepreneurs (estimated at 2.5-3 percent annually in the 2016-2025 period), this shortage will be felt more and more – comments Łukasz Włoch, chief expert at the National Centre for Truck Driver Settlement (OCRK).

Poland is solving its problem for today by employing drivers from outside the EU, mainly Ukrainians. However, there is a risk that Germany, with its proposed changes to migration policy and attractive initiatives aimed at foreigners, may soon poach some of the Ukrainian workers from Polish hauliers. Positive changes in the domestic labour market may come with increased access to vocational education: at the end of 2018, the President of the Republic of Poland signed an act intended to facilitate the process of obtaining truck driving licences.

Rising labour costs
Apart from purely staffing problems that are undeniably dragging the industry down, European hauliers must contend with rising labour costs and administrative burdens. An example is the minimum wage and employee posting legislation introduced by the Germans in January 2015, the so-called MiLoG; and subsequently, the Loi Macron established by the French, which is similar in its intent. According to OCRK experts, these regulations, due to the increase in driver remuneration, have contributed to an increase in labour costs by a total of as much as approximately 20 percent. It is no wonder, given that the minimum wage rate for a driver posted to perform professional duties in Germany is 9.19 euros gross per hour in 2019, while in France it is at least 9.88 euros gross. Added to the rise in these direct costs are a number of specific administrative requirements (e.g., appointing a representative in the host country or hiring personnel to handle the settlement of posted drivers), so legal uncertainty and the risk of business operations are also growing. Many entrepreneurs prefer in such a situation to hand over all formalities, including entrusting the settlement of employees according to laws such as MiLoG or Loi Macron to external, specialised companies.

Mobility Package on the way: are we moving away from the free market?
However, it is the Mobility Package, which, at least theoretically, is to be finally approved before July 30, 2020, that should ensure uniform legal standards regarding the posting of highly mobile workers. It generates, however, a huge dispute, the essence of which is the conflict of interest between the “old Union” (especially France and Germany) and the “new Union” countries that support pro-market solutions, along with peripheral countries (such as Ireland and Portugal). It is known that the position of the Council of the European Union (as well as the European Parliament’s position similar to it) is extremely unfavourable to the interests of Central and Eastern Europe and is considered protectionist.

– The new composition of the European Parliament is even more protectionist, which will be reflected in the closing of the internal markets of the Western European Community states. It seems, therefore, that the fate of the Mobility Package is sealed, or at least its main elements, including limiting access to free and unrestricted trade in goods between member states. To a large extent, cabotage operations will be limited, of which Polish truck drivers perform the most, as much as 40 percent. Romania is second with a 9 percent share, which only shows to what extent international transport on European roads currently depends on Polish entrepreneurs. This will certainly change, because the new law called the Mobility Package will certainly enter into force. The only question is when? – says Bartosz Najman, Vice President of OCRK and Inelo.

Drivers have nowhere to rest…
The ban on spending the 45-hour rest period in the cabin also complicates the actions of hauliers. Countries such as Belgium, France, Germany and the Netherlands, Italy, and Spain are already enforcing it, although it basically applies to the entire European Union. Both the haulier and the driver are punished for violating the ban. In France, the fine can reach as much as 30,000 euros. In Denmark, a time limit on truck parking has been introduced as a result (the stop cannot last longer than 25 hours). On the other hand, the infrastructure for heavy goods vehicles in Europe is not adapted to the exorbitant requirements regulating drivers’ working and rest times. There is a shortage of parking spaces (31,000 in Germany alone), and there are also few truly secure parking lots. The result? Fines for exceeding working hours and an increasing number of cargo thefts, which means additional costs.

Rising fees on European roads
Another obstacle thrown in the way of road hauliers in Europe is the truck traffic restrictions applied in Tyrol, Austria. The so-called block processing, which causes multi-kilometre traffic jams, makes life difficult for truckers there, as well as the sectoral driving ban, which will be further expanded to include more groups of goods. Old vehicles that do not meet the stringent emission standards will sooner or later have to disappear from the roads of Tyrol (Euro 4 from August this year, Euro 5 in 2021), and Euro 6 vehicles will be burdened with higher fees. The Tyroleans also want to introduce a corridor toll from Munich to Verona, but that would be equivalent to raising rates in the adjacent regions in Germany and Italy. Their increase and the expansion of paid roads is in fact a trend visible throughout Europe. In 2019, fees are rising on German, French, and Hungarian roads, and in 2023 they will be introduced for the first time in the Netherlands. To the greatest extent, the costs are borne by the owners of old, non-ecological vehicles. Let us recall: according to PZPM data, only 17.5 percent of trucks meet the Euro 6 standard.

Łukasz Włoch, an OCRK expert, assesses that the lack of qualified personnel to work in road transport will remain the main challenge that company owners will have to face.

– We recently asked our business partners what they fear the most. More than half of the respondents pointed exactly to staffing shortages. It was only in second and third place that difficulties with understanding complicated regulations in Polish legislation (38 percent) and EU body regulations, including the Mobility Package (33 percent), were found. Entrepreneurs are focusing on the situation here and now, but they are also looking to the future more consciously and with concern – said Łukasz Włoch.

– The Polish transport industry is facing a slight slowdown, and this is because of the changes that Brussels is preparing for us. Nevertheless, well-managed companies prepared for change should be able to protect themselves from it. Although hauliers are actually operating in difficult conditions – different laws in individual Community countries concerning, for example, posting and minimum wage – equal rules for everyone should be thought through, created with the free market Union in mind, and processed in a transparent manner, which has been doubtful so far – claims Bartosz Najman.