
A carrier was transporting agricultural machinery from Great Britain to Poland. The machine was properly secured and delivered to the recipient in accordance with the arrangements. During unloading, it turned out that hydraulic oil had leaked from the machine during transport, which caused the loading area to become soiled. This situation resulted in the inability to load the next cargo and the necessity to clean the semi-trailer, which in turn involved additional costs for the carrier. In such a situation, can the carrier demand that the sender reimburse the costs of cleaning/replacing the semi-trailer floor and refund the lost amount of the entire freight?
Expert’s answer: Considering the international nature of the transport, in order to answer the above questions, one should refer to the CMR Convention. According to Article 10 of the CMR Convention, “The sender shall be liable to the carrier for damage to persons, equipment or other goods, as well as for costs caused by defective packing of the goods, unless the defect was apparent or known to the carrier at the time of taking over the goods and the carrier made no reservations in this regard.” The above provision, together with Article 17(4)(b) of the CMR Convention, establishes the obligation for the sender to properly pack the consignment.
A situation in which liquids (e.g., hydraulic oil) leak from the transported goods during transport, causing damage and costs to the carrier, should be clearly classified as improper packing of the consignment. Importantly, for the sender to be held liable, the damage must have occurred between the loading and unloading of the goods (temporal connection with the transport).
Bearing in mind the above considerations, the sender should reimburse the costs of cleaning the means of transport that was soiled in connection with the transport performed. At this point, it should also be mentioned that the damage must be properly documented (photos of the semi-trailer, valuation/invoices documenting the cleaning of the soiling). The calculation of the amount of damage should be realistic, as the sender, despite accepting liability, will in principle be able to effectively challenge its amount. The necessity to replace parts of the means of transport (for example, the semi-trailer floor) due to the extent of the damage should be documented. However, taking into account the wording of Article 362 of the Civil Code, the carrier should strive to minimize the damage so as not to be exposed to the charge of contributing to its occurrence. Replacing the semi-trailer floor in a situation where it is possible to restore all functionalities of the means of transport by cleaning it should be classified as an incorrect action.
Reimbursement of freight costs as lost profits of the carrier, due to the inability to perform the next transport, has no basis in light of the provisions of the CMR Convention and the Civil Code. The amount of compensation should include the amount of the carrier’s lost profits in connection with the non-performance of the contract, reduced by the benefits the carrier obtained due to the fact that it did not perform the transport (in other words – what the carrier would have earned by taking on the next order). The burden of proving the defectiveness of the packaging, the costs incurred or the damage, and the relevant causal link between the defectiveness of the packaging and the damage rests with the carrier.
Of course, the sender will not be liable for damages in all situations. Article 10 of the CMR Convention establishes the premises under which their liability will be excluded, i.e.:
– the defectiveness of the packaging (including its complete absence) was apparent or known to the carrier at the time of taking over the goods, and
– the carrier made no reservations (in the consignment note) regarding the packaging.
The obligation to prove the above situations rests with the sender. If this circumstance is proven, the carrier may try to demonstrate that they made reservations regarding the defectiveness of the packaging.
Legal basis:
- Act of April 23, 1964 – Civil Code
- Convention on the Contract for the International Carriage of Goods by Road (CMR) and Protocol of signature, done at Geneva on 19 May 1956
Legal status of the publication (date): 2018-11-05








