⚙️
🌟 Najlepsze dopasowanie
Wpisz szukaną frazę, aby zobaczyć propozycje AI.

Transshipment of goods without consent – what are the consequences (based on the CMR Convention)

Transshipment of goods without consent - what are the consequences (based on the CMR Convention)

The purpose of the CMR Convention (Convention on the Contract for the International Carriage of Goods by Road of 19 January 1956) is to protect customers and freight forwarders against unfair practices. Thanks to the CMR agreement, to which the carrier and the sender are parties, the safety of transport and the timeliness of the service are ensured.

A consignment note is a document issued for transport, created in 3 copies, which are signed by both the sender and the carrier. One of them is delivered to the recipient. In addition to mandatory elements, such as names, addresses, date of issue, the consignment note must indicate the type and number of goods. Another possible provision is a ban on transshipment. In this article, we explain what to do in a situation where the carrier breaks such a ban.

What is a transshipment ban?

As a rule, it is assumed that transshipment of goods is permissible. Nevertheless, the parties may agree between themselves that transshipment will be prohibited. Such a decision stems from the fact that transshipment increases the risks associated with transport. In order to establish a ban, a contractual penalty is indicated in the contract, i.e., the payment of a specified amount.

By including this circumstance in the consignment note, it will be easier to prove the carrier’s fault. Additionally, this extends the transshipment ban to successive carriers. In the event of a breach of this ban, it will be possible to demand payment of the contractual penalty.

When is transshipment necessary?

It happens that in some cases transshipment is necessary. For example, when there are problems with meeting the transport deadline or there is a need to use specific transport. Of course, despite such difficulties, the carrier must still perform the contract in accordance with its terms. Only when, despite taking diligent actions, the performance of the contract under the established conditions is not possible, an obstacle occurs. This happens, for example, when an accident occurs, as a result of which it will be necessary to perform a transshipment.

If the parties have previously agreed on a transshipment ban in the contract, the carrier must obtain consent for such an action under Article 14(1) of the CMR. They should request instructions directly from the person entitled to manage the goods. Usually, the authorized person is the sender, who is a party to the contract of carriage and, together with the carrier, determines its content.

The right to dispose of the goods may also pass to the recipient. This will be possible from the moment the transport begins, provided that such a reservation is made by the sender in the consignment note. In order for the recipient to effectively exercise this right, it is necessary to provide them with the first copy of the consignment note.

Actions on the part of the carrier

It is worth remembering that the carrier should immediately request instructions. In addition, they must inform the authorized person of the circumstances that may be important when making a decision regarding the instructions that will be issued by them.

However, if the carrier does not receive instructions quickly enough, they may independently decide to change the way the contract is performed. These changes also include unplanned transshipment. This may happen, for example, when contact with the authorized person is impossible or significantly hindered, there are doubts as to who is the authorized person, or the authorized person does not know what instructions to issue.

The assessment of the inability to obtain instructions in a sufficiently short time is made on a case-by-case basis, taking into account all circumstances.

This is justified by the judgment of the Court of Appeal of 10 February 1981. The court considered a situation in which the carrier, during transport, decided that it was impossible to cover the last section of the route by ferry due to the excessive weight of the vehicle. After fruitless attempts to communicate with the sender, which lasted about 6 hours, the carrier decided to transship the goods and sent them by boat. According to the court, the carrier’s actions were correct, and it ordered the sender to reimburse the expenses incurred and the costs resulting from the contractual penalty.

Who is responsible for violating the transshipment ban?

Liability for damages on the part of the carrier arises provided that, after the obstacles occurred, they did not ask the authorized person for instructions. Therefore, if they perform a transshipment without consulting the authorized person, and also do not take independent steps in a situation of difficult contact, they are liable for failure to follow instructions and for following those that were not issued by the authorized person.

In this case, the general principles of liability for damages for non-performance or improper performance of a contract (Art. 471 et seq. of the Civil Code) or the contractual penalty included in the contract apply.

Non-performance or improper performance of a contract, even without causing financial damage, exposes the other party to additional effort and serious inconvenience. It thus fulfills the hallmarks of a tort. The contractual liability of the debtor, i.e., here – the carrier breaking the terms of the contract through transshipment – is a type of claim for damages or a non-monetary obligation. In this case, the carrier’s fault is presumed.

Compensation for improper performance of a contract is a benefit intended to compensate for damage resulting from the improper action or omission of the carrier. Its purpose is therefore to compensate for the damage caused by the improper behavior of the contractor in relation to the amount of the loss incurred, and not to force them to perform in accordance with the wording of the contract.

The creditor does not have to prove the circumstances covered by the legal presumption. The carrier may be released from liability for damage if they provide counter-evidence and prove that the breach of the obligation occurred due to circumstances for which they are not responsible. The second situation is one in which the carrier proves that they exercised due diligence in fulfilling the obligation, i.e., they did not lead to a breach of the contract in a culpable manner. It will be different in the case of claims stated by a payment order in writ-of-payment proceedings.

Breaking the ban and causing damage

If damage to the goods or a delay occurs due to the breach of the transshipment ban, the carrier faces additional, greater consequences. They will also be liable for causing damage under the regulations of the CMR Convention. The amount of compensation is determined based on the market and stock exchange value of the given goods.

The persons entitled to claim damages for damage to goods are the sender or the recipient. This depends on which of them is entitled to manage the goods. Damage can take 2 forms:

  • losses incurred by the injured party
  • benefits that the injured party could have gained if the damage had not occurred

The carrier will be liable for the total or partial loss of the goods, as well as for their damage, if it occurs between the time of taking over the goods and their delivery, and for delay in delivery.

  • Total loss – occurs when, after the transport deadline has expired, the carrier cannot deliver or make available to the recipient any part of the shipment at the destination;
  • Partial loss – occurs when, at the time of delivery of the goods, there is a shortage consisting of a reduction in the measure, weight, or number of pieces compared to the state at the time of acceptance for transport;
  • Damage – qualitative changes causing a decrease in the commercial or utility value of the goods, e.g., destruction of products.

The most important thing is to prove that the damage occurred during transport. The carrier will be responsible for the condition of the goods even if the cause of the damage is not explained.

When is the carrier not at fault for the damage?

When they have exercised due diligence, i.e., the damage occurred as a result of circumstances that they could not avoid. This refers to situations whose consequences the carrier could not prevent. For example, they will not be liable for the loss of goods if they performed a transshipment at a designated station where an attack by armed assailants took place at that time. In that case, they will only be liable for breaking the terms of the contract regarding the transshipment ban.

  • At the same time, the burden of proof in each of the given situations rests with the carrier.

Importantly, the carrier is not liable for damage to goods resulting from their natural properties or improper packaging.

In summary, when transshipment is necessary, formal requirements must be followed in order not to suffer negative consequences. Breaking this ban can be associated with severe consequences, such as liability for breach of contract, as well as causing damage.