
Zinc, sodium, or calcium are just a few of the chemical elements being used as the basis for solutions tested as successors to lithium-ion battery technology. Is there any chance that one of them will replace it in the foreseeable future?
“Li-Ion is dead,” announced a technical journalist for Power Electronics News in 2016. Although more than 4 years have passed since his article was published, lithium-ion batteries remain the most popular solution for powering portable electronic equipment and in e-mobility. They are also constantly gaining popularity in the electric forklift market. Is there a grain of truth in the news about the twilight of Li-Ion? Are we ready for the end of the currently dominant technology? Can we already identify the future king among the candidates fighting for the throne?
Must Li-Ion go?
According to World Economic Forum forecasts, global demand for batteries will increase more than 9-fold between 2020 and 2030, from 282 to 2,623 thousand GWh. The sectors with the highest demand for batteries will be the passenger car and commercial vehicle markets. This will mean the need to extract minerals such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel on a scale 4 to 24 times greater than in 2018. Their acquisition, transport, and processing on such a massive scale will require significant investment, pose a huge logistical challenge, and also lead to a significant increase in the generated carbon footprint. Taking into account the extraction and purification of raw materials, the implementation of necessary chemical processes, the production of cells and their packs, and recycling, greenhouse gas emissions from the lithium-ion battery manufacturing industry will increase eightfold by 2030 compared to 2018 levels, to 182 Mt CO2 per year. Limiting the impact of human activity on the pace of climate change is one of the most important reasons why we are moving away from conventional fuels. Even if there are investors willing to put money into mines and refineries, it would be reasonable to look for technological solutions that will allow for the diversification of supply chains in battery production and reduce the carbon footprint of this industry.
Crowds in the queue for the throne
In research centers and R&D departments of companies around the world, research is simultaneously underway on the construction of various batteries based on more accessible raw materials. For instance, scientific journals have reported on successful tests of a cathode that increases the lifespan of sodium-ion batteries conducted in South Korea and the United States. In 2019, the Karlsruhe Institute of Technology in Germany presented an electrolyte that allows calcium batteries to be charged at room temperature. However, researchers caution that this is only the first step toward introducing such batteries to the market. Meanwhile, the US Navy research laboratory is working on a solution using spongy zinc structures. In January 2020, the creators assessed the technological readiness of their battery at 5-6 on a 9-point scale (where 9 means successful tests in combat conditions). John Goodenough, one of the Nobel Prize winners for the lithium-ion battery, has initiated patent proceedings for batteries with a glass electrode. At the same time, research is underway to simplify the production process in Li-Ion technology and further improve it. Tesla is working on, among other things, lithium-ion batteries with phosphate cathodes, which can eliminate the need for cobalt. Similar solutions are also successfully used in forklifts today.
– Li-Ion batteries equipped in STILL vehicles operate based on lithium-iron-phosphate technology. They are available with voltages from 24 to 80 V, matched to the specific forklift model, and with chargers with a charging current of up to 375 A – says Grzegorz Kurkowski, product specialist at STILL Polska. – The solution is being continuously improved and optimized for new forklift models – he adds. We can expect that in the medium term – until one of the technologies moving away from the use of lithium takes a decisive lead – other suppliers of electric internal transport vehicles and the traction batteries that power them will follow a similar direction. However, to increase the probability of quickly inventing an alternative, the European Union has launched the “Battery 2030+” project.
Artificial intelligence will help in discovering the successor
Forklift manufacturers understand the need for intensive research and development. – The growing interest in lithium-ion technology and the possibilities for work optimization it provides makes the integration of the battery into the forklift’s design increasingly important – says Grzegorz Kurkowski. – Therefore, the KION Group, to which STILL Polska belongs, has created a joint venture with BMZ Holding and launched a plant under the Kion Battery Systems banner that manufactures batteries for forklifts produced by the Group’s companies. Thanks to the cooperation of research and development departments, there is a chance to accelerate discoveries that improve the performance of batteries and the vehicles equipped with them – explains the STILL Polska product specialist. The goals of “Battery 2030+” were formulated similarly – a long-term EU research project intended to ultimately lead to the invention of batteries whose parameters will enable Europe to reach climate neutrality by 2050. The essence of the project is to bring European research centers and industry closer together and enable the rapid exchange of information between them – so that the next dominant technology has a chance to be created in our region. The assumptions of the initiative do not prejudge what kind of chemical reaction the functioning of the battery of the future will be based on. Instead, the project aims to create a data exchange network between European inventors and artificial intelligence that will analyze them to find promising solutions that might otherwise be overlooked. We still do not know whether the future of traction batteries is zinc, sodium, glass, or calcium. What is certain, however, is that the race is on and all market players will do everything to increase their chances in it – including creating a broad front of cooperating entities.
Source: Newseria








