Selected aspects of strategic partnership in transport – part 2

Selected aspects of strategic partnership in transport - part 2

Selected aspects of strategic partnership in transport – part 1

In a situation where the parties to a contract are already cooperating, in addition to the dimensions mentioned above, data collected during the existing cooperation can also be used to assess the bargaining power of the partners, namely: mutual shares in turnover or profit of the companies and their dynamics, as well as an assessment of the overall quality of cooperation between the operator and the carrier. Information about mutual shares in turnover helps to answer the question regarding the carrier’s share in the operator’s turnover and vice versa – what percentage of the carrier’s turnover is accounted for by the operator.

An interesting indicator is also the mutual share in achieved profits, calculated in the same way as mutual shares in turnover. They indicate how dependent the parties to the contract are on each other in terms of generated profits. The results for the indicator of mutual share of cooperating parties in profits may differ significantly from the results for the indicator of mutual share in turnover. This means that a carrier responsible for a large part of the operator’s turnover (high share in turnover) may – due to low percentage profitability – be responsible for a relatively smaller part of the profits (low share in profits).

The possibility/difficulty of replacing a carrier with another subcontractor contains a large dose of subjective assessment due to the fact that it is mostly based on concepts of various scenarios, constructed on the basis of incomplete and often estimated data about companies from the transport sector as potential subcontractors. In a situation where cooperation has not yet been established, from the point of view of a TSL operator, the assessment of this dimension may boil down to answering the question of whether there are other carriers to whom cooperation can be proposed in building or restructuring the operator’s transport network. It is also important whether they can bypass a given carrier in their delivery system by relying on other subcontractors operating in the transport services market or whether the operator is able to carry out deliveries on their own and thus also bypass the carrier as a subcontractor. This is related to the aspect concerning the strength of resources (potentials) of the parties to potential cooperation. A TSL operator usually has greater resources, which automatically translates into greater strength. On the other hand, the consistency of marketing goals is a qualitative dimension subject to subjective assessment, which may consist of determining whether – and if so, to what extent – the carrier’s actions are consistent with the operator’s goals. Since access to the strategic goals of a subcontractor is inherently difficult (especially in a situation where the parties have not yet started cooperation or their previous cooperation was limited), the assessment can be based on fragmentary data, for example from the assessing party’s own observations or opinions of the environment within the TSL sector. The assessment of the overall quality of cooperation can concern many aspects of mutual relations, such as: readiness to cooperate, level of staff involvement, efficiency (ability) to act in disputed matters, timeliness and completeness of deliveries, speed and adequacy of reaction in crisis situations, etc. Some of these indicators are measurable (for example, timeliness or completeness of deliveries), but most of them (readiness to cooperate, speed and adequacy of action in crisis situations, staff involvement), as well as a comprehensive assessment in this dimension, are based on the subjective assessment of people directly involved in the cooperation.

Discussing issues related to cooperation in the TSL services sector, it is necessary to emphasize the problem of consolidation of domestic transport SMEs. It must be considered on two levels – the national and international transport market. In international transport, covering both transport to and from Poland, as well as transit transport, one should not expect such rapid and radical changes. Most companies performing such transport are relatively well prepared technically and personally to function on the European market and are still cost-competitive. Among these carriers, consolidation movements will be visible, allowing for increased profits or offering a wider range of services, rather than resulting from fear of losing financial liquidity. The greatest risk of bankruptcy lies with small companies providing transport within the country.

The article comes from the magazine “Logistyka” 1/2012.

L2012-1s20.pdf