Legal aspects of passenger transport services via ride-hailing applications

Legal aspects of passenger transport services via ride-hailing applications

Providing passenger transport services using ride-hailing applications popular on the Polish market has become a modern and, by design, cheaper alternative to traditional taxi services. Given the multitude of regulations governing road transport in general1, legal questions inevitably arise regarding free access to the provision of these services2 and the administrative and legal liability of the entity involved in such activities. The attractiveness and use of new technologies mean that this type of activity may seemingly fall outside the legal framework created by the legislator for conducting passenger transport businesses.

The purpose of this article is to identify the legal status of the entity providing passenger transport services, the consequences provided by the legislator for carriers in the event of failure to meet statutory criteria, and to assess legislative changes for the future regulation of road transport of passengers by passenger car in domestic law. The consequence of answering these questions is to indicate the administrative liability regime of the carrier, which is extremely important from the point of view of the legality of their operations and, consequently, the protection of consumers’ legitimate rights.

The essence of activities performed within a popular ride-hailing application
The carrier’s activity is based on the relationship between three entities: the application user, the application provider, and the carrier itself. From the perspective of this article, the position of the carrier is significant – the entity that offers transport services to application users through the app. The application allows for transport service requests to be sent. The decision to accept or reject a request on each occasion lies solely and entirely with the carrier. At the same time, it should be noted that the application provider itself does not provide transport services; it only acts as an intermediary between the user and the carrier. Using the application is free of charge, however, transport services provided by carriers are paid, and their rates are available in the application.
In the presented situation, we are dealing with the following civil law contracts. First, a contract between the user and the application provider. Second, between the application provider and the carrier. Third, between the user and the carrier. From the point of view of the subject under study, the contract between the application user and the carrier, as well as the carrier’s normative status, will be relevant.

Business activity
Taking into account the series of actions taken by the carrier within the scope of using the application, one should answer the question of whether the latter conducts a business activity. According to Article 3 of the Act of March 6, 2018, Entrepreneurs’ Law3, “business activity is an organized profit-seeking activity performed in one’s own name and on a continuous basis.” The Act partially replicates the regulations of the now-repealed Act of July 2, 2004, on Freedom of Economic Activity4, hence both jurisprudence and all official interpretations issued under the cited Act, as well as the very extensive literature, remain current in relation to Article 3 of the Entrepreneurs’ Law Act to the extent that they concern these premises5. Based on the above provision, four normative features of business activity can be indicated: organization, profit-seeking, performance of activities in one’s own name, and continuity.
Literature indicates the material and formal aspect of the organization of business activity. Formal organization of business activity should be understood as the legally defined scope of obligations related to the conducted business activity, for example, registration of business activity, tax and statistical notifications, and the necessity to obtain specific administrative acts, i.e., concessions, permits. As for material conditions, a list of organizational activities is mentioned regarding obtaining financial resources to start a business activity or employing staff. All these indicated organizational activities unequivocally determine that business activity is an activity that is not accidental in nature6.
The second premise specified by the legislator in Article 3 of the Entrepreneurs’ Law Act is profit-seeking as inherently linked to business activity7. The purpose of performing an activity determines its profit-seeking nature. If it is assumed that in connection with the activity and as a result thereof, a surplus of revenues over incurred costs, and thus a profit, will be achieved, it means that the profit-seeking objective of this activity has been defined. However, the definition of the goal itself has a subjective dimension8 and lies within the sphere of the entity’s intent9. The lack of the expected effect in the form of profit and the occurrence of a loss does not mean that the performed activity has ceased to be profit-seeking; its character will not change as long as the person performing it has in mind the achievement of profit from this activity – even in the long term10.
To classify an activity as a business activity, it is also necessary to perform it in one’s own name. As indicated in the justification for the draft Entrepreneurs’ Law Act, this means that the entity organizing such activity does so on its own behalf and simultaneously bears liability for obligations incurred in connection therewith11. A feature inherently linked to business activity, as well as to the feature of organization, is continuity. Performing business activity on a continuous basis is understood as the intention to perform it in a repeatable manner12. It should be noted, however, that continuity is not synonymous with the obligation not to interrupt the activity, as this would contradict the freedom to cease (end) business activity13.
If the manner of performing road transport does not allow for any of these features to be attributed to it, these transports cannot be considered a business activity and, consequently, will not fall within the definition of domestic road transport14. To determine whether the services provided by the carrier through the application can be classified as business activity, one must perform a subsumption of the features that the subject activities possess under the norm expressed in Article 3 of the Entrepreneurs’ Law Act. Undoubtedly, the activities undertaken by the provider of transport services are profit-seeking. The goal of this entity’s operation is to achieve a profit in connection with the activity and as a result thereof, a surplus of revenues over incurred costs. This is evidenced by the established rates for transport services, which should be paid by the application user.
The carrier’s activity should be attributed the quality of organization. This is evidenced by the circumstances of concluding contracts, operating in a specific territory and at a specific time, and possessing the required bank account for settlements with customers. The above activity also has the feature of continuity, an exemplification of which is undertaking specific actions to prepare for the business activity, and meeting and adhering to the terms of contracts that are necessary to provide transport services.
It is therefore reasonable to conclude that the carrier’s activity within a popular application is a business activity within the meaning of Article 3 of the Entrepreneurs’ Law Act.

Road passenger transport as a regulated activity
As demonstrated above, a person performing transports within a popular application conducts business activity. However, given the nature of the activity – road passenger transport, one should consider the additional normative qualification of the subject of activity and the carrier itself. The fundamental legal act defining the principles of undertaking and performing domestic road transport is the Act of September 6, 2001, on Road Transport15. According to Article 4 point 1 of the Road Transport Act, domestic road transport is the “undertaking and performance of business activity in the scope of passenger transport […] on the territory of the Republic of Poland.”
Citing the above definition is necessary because Article 5b section 1 point 1 refers directly to the concept of domestic road transport, according to which “undertaking and performing domestic road transport in the scope of passenger transport by passenger car requires obtaining an appropriate license”16.
The provisions indicated above explicitly state explicite that the activity in the scope of domestic road transport of passengers by passenger car is a regulated activity and undertaking activities in this area requires fulfilling additional administrative obligations – obtaining a license.
An additional issue is the legality of performing occasional transport by the carrier17. According to the condition expressed in Article 18 section 4a of the Road Transport Act, “occasional transport is performed by a motor vehicle designed for the transport of more than 7 people, including the driver.”

Consequences of the carrier failing to meet the requirements
As established above, a driver performing transport within a popular application performs business activity in the scope of domestic road transport of passengers by passenger car within the meaning of Article 4 point 1, in connection with Article 5b section 1 point 1 of the Road Transport Act. The entity providing the above-mentioned transport services is under an obligation to obtain an appropriate license18. Obtaining it is a public law obligation, failure to comply with which is subject to a sanction. The provision of Article 92a section 1 of the Road Transport Act establishes the liability of the entity performing road transport based on the principles of administrative liability. The list of violations of obligations for which these entities are liable is specified in Annex 3 to the Act19.
Committing a violation listed in the annex is subject to a monetary penalty, and depending on the violation, the penalty may range from PLN 50 to PLN 12,000. The inspecting authority is entitled to impose an administrative penalty separately for each of the violations. A certain softening of the Act’s provisions is provided by Article 92a section 3 of the Road Transport Act, according to which “the sum of monetary penalties referred to in section 1, imposed for violations detected during one road inspection, may not exceed the amount of 12,000 PLN.”20
A carrier performing business activity in the scope of domestic road transport of passengers by passenger car within the meaning of Article 5b section 1 of the Road Transport Act without the required license, in accordance with Annex 3 item 1.1. 21 is subject to a monetary penalty of 12,000 PLN.
Additionally, attention should be paid to the carrier’s liability for occasional transport using a vehicle that does not meet the construction criterion specified in Article 18 section 4a of the Road Transport Act. The vast majority of transports within the application are performed by motor vehicles structurally designed for the transport of five or fewer people. According to Annex 3 item 2.11, “Performing occasional transport using a vehicle that does not meet the construction criterion specified in Article 18 section 4a of the Road Transport Act, subject to the transports referred to in Article 18 section 4b of this Act” is subject to a monetary penalty of 8,000 PLN22.

Changes to the Road Transport Act
The legislator noticed the dynamics of the changing passenger transport market and amended the Road Transport Act23, which enters into force on January 1, 2020, and amends Article 5b section 2 of the Road Transport Act, introducing a license for brokerage in passenger transport – a document authorizing an entrepreneur to perform road transport in the scope of brokerage in passenger transport. The obligation to hold a license for brokerage in passenger transport and to meet the conditions related to its acquisition by all intermediaries is aimed at introducing equal and fair rules for conducting business in this area of the transport market.
The amended Act explicitly prohibits an entity that is an intermediary in passenger transport from ordering transport to carriers that do not hold a license, as referred to in Article 5b section 1 of the Road Transport Act. Multiple breaches of the above prohibition may lead to the imposition of a sanction in the maximum amount of 100,000 PLN.
The direction of the changes indicates that the legislator has noticed the disparity between the full liability of the carrier performing passenger transport and the lack (or small amount) of liability of the intermediary (the application provider). The above changes should, in principle, be assessed positively because transports carried out by drivers who do not possess the appropriate license to perform commercial road passenger transport take place outside the regulated market and, consequently, can lead to abuses in the intermediary-carrier and carrier-application user relationships.

1. Attention should be paid to the extensive regulation of road transport both in terms of public law at the level of European Union law (see, for example: Regulation (EC) No 1071/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 21 October 2009 establishing common rules concerning the conditions to be complied with to pursue the occupation of road transport operator and repealing Council Directive 96/26/EC (OJ EU L 300 of 14.11.2009, p. 51, as amended); national law (see, for example: Act of September 6, 2001, on Road Transport (uniform text: OJ of 2019, item 1123, as amended) serving to apply, among others, the above-mentioned regulations) as well as private law (see, for example, the Act of November 15, 1984, Transport Law (uniform text: OJ of 2017, item 1983, as amended).
2. Traditional forms of activity within transport companies that provide passenger or cargo transport services are, in principle, met with a unified view by inspection bodies, judicature, and doctrine regarding the principles of their execution.
3. Uniform text: OJ of 2018, item 1292 as amended, hereinafter: Entrepreneurs’ Law Act
4. Uniform text: OJ of 2017, item 2168 as amended, hereinafter: Act on Freedom of Economic Activity
5. A. Kruszewski in: A. Pietrzak (ed.) Entrepreneurs’ Law, commentary https://sip.lex.pl/#/commentary/587788765/586205/pietrzak-aldona-red-prawo-przedsiebiorcow-komentarz?pit=2019-08-14&cm=URELATIONS accessed on August 16, 2019.
6. M. Zyb, M. Sieradzka, Act on Freedom of Economic Activity, Commentary, Warsaw 2013, pp. 42-43. It is worth noting that it is rightly pointed out in jurisprudence that organization should not be narrowed only to conducting business activity in the form of an organizational unit. Business activity can be conducted by a natural person who personally performs all activities related to a given task. See the judgment of the Supreme Administrative Court (NSA) of July 14, 2005, file no. FSK 1971/04, LEX no. 173219.
7. M. Zyb, M. Sieradzka, Act on Freedom of Economic Activity, Commentary, Warsaw 2013, p. 32.
8. See M. Szydło, Freedom of Economic Activity, Warsaw 2005, pp. 36-46.
9. A. Powałowski, Act on Freedom of Economic Activity, Commentary, Warsaw 2009, p. 29
10. A. Ibid., p. 30.
11. Draft Act – VIII.2059, https://sip.lex.pl/#/act-project/102539647/1, accessed: August 16, 2019.
12. G. Lubeńczuk, K. Sikora. Road Transport Act, Commentary. Warsaw 2013, p. 30.
13. J. Odachowski, Continuity of Business Activity, Glosa 2003, no. 9, pp. 31-32.
14. G. Lubeńczuk, K. Sikora. Road Transport Act, Commentary. Warsaw 2013, p. 30.
15. Uniform text: OJ of 2019, item 1123 as amended, hereinafter: Road Transport Act. As stated in the justification of the draft act, the fundamental goal of the regulation was to create a comprehensive regulation regarding the principles of access to the profession of road transport operator and the conditions for access to road transport markets, which, in the legislator’s opinion, was missing in the existing acts (Justification of the draft Road Transport Act, parliamentary document No. 2644 of February 16, 2001, p. 34).
16. According to Article 4 point 17 of the Road Transport Act, a license is an “administrative decision issued by the Chief Inspector of Road Transport or a local government body specified in the Act, authorizing the undertaking and performance of business activity in the scope of road transport.”
17. According to Article 4 section 11 of the Road Transport Act, occasional transport is “transport of persons which does not constitute regular transport, special regular transport, or shuttle transport.”
18. The provision of Article 5b section 1 of the Road Transport Act
19. See Article 92a section 7 of the Road Transport Act
20. See the judgment of the Supreme Administrative Court (NSA) of November 17, 2016, file no. II GSK 1010/15 LEX no. 2228114.
21. “performing road transport without the required authorization to pursue the occupation of road transport operator or without the required license”
22. See the judgment of the Voivodeship Administrative Court (WSA) in Łódź of February 8, 2018, file no. III SA/ŁD 900/17 LEGALIS no. 1731551.
23. Act of May 16, 2019, on the amendment of the Road Transport Act and certain other acts (OJ of 2019, item 1180).

Bibliography
List of legal sources

1. Regulation (EC) No 1071/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 21 October 2009 establishing common rules concerning the conditions to be complied with to pursue the occupation of road transport operator and repealing Council Directive 96/26/EC (OJ EU L 300 of 14.11.2009, p. 51, as amended)
2. Act of July 2, 2004, on Freedom of Economic Activity (uniform text: OJ of 2017, item 2168, as amended)
3. Act of September 6, 2001, on Road Transport (uniform text: OJ of 2019, item 1123, as amended)
4. Act of November 15, 1984, Transport Law (uniform text: OJ of 2017, item 1983, as amended)
5. Act of March 6, 2018, Entrepreneurs’ Law (uniform text: OJ of 2018, item 1292, as amended)
6. Act of May 16, 2019, on the amendment of the Road Transport Act and certain other acts (OJ of 2019, item 1180)

List of jurisprudence
1. Judgment of the Supreme Administrative Court (NSA) of July 14, 2005, file no. FSK 1971/04, LEX no. 173219
2. Judgment of the Supreme Administrative Court (NSA) of November 17, 2016, file no. II GSK 1010/15 LEX no. 2228114
3. Judgment of the Voivodeship Administrative Court (WSA) in Łódź of February 8, 2018, file no. III SA/ŁD 900/17 LEGALIS no. 1731551

List of subject literature
1. Kruszewski A., Pietrzak A. (ed.), Entrepreneurs’ Law, commentary, https://sip.lex.pl/#/commentary/587788765/586205/pietrzak-aldona-red-prawo-przedsiebiorcow-komentarz?pit=2019-08-14&cm=URELATIONS; accessed on August 16, 2019.
2. Lubeńczuk G., Sikora K., Road Transport Act, commentary, Warsaw 2013
3. Odachowski J., Continuity of Business Activity, Glosa 2003, no. 9
4. Powałowski A., Act on Freedom of Economic Activity, commentary, Warsaw 2009
5. Szydło M., Freedom of Economic Activity, Warsaw 2005
6. Zyb M., Sieradzka M., Act on Freedom of Economic Activity, commentary, Warsaw 2013