⚙️
🌟 Najlepsze dopasowanie
Wpisz szukaną frazę, aby zobaczyć propozycje AI.

Lack of parking infrastructure and the possibility of invoking Article 12 of Regulation 561/2006

Lack of parking infrastructure and the possibility of invoking Article 12 of Regulation 561/2006

During international road transport operations, drivers often face the problem of a lack of parking infrastructure. In cases where they want to fully utilize their available driving time, it happens that they commit violations due to the lack of access to a parking space. Can a driver invoke Article 12 of Regulation 561/2006 in this regard? What penalties are provided for the indicated violations?

Expert response: The issue of permissible derogations from the application of regulations concerning drivers’ working time is regulated in Article 12 of Regulation (EC) No 561/2006 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 15 March 2006 on the harmonisation of certain social legislation relating to road transport and amending Council Regulations (EEC) No 3821/85 (hereinafter Regulation 561/2006).

According to Article 12 of Regulation 561/2006, “Provided that road safety is not thereby jeopardized and to enable the vehicle to reach a suitable stopping place, the driver may depart from Articles 6 to 9 to the extent necessary to ensure the safety of persons, of the vehicle or its load. The driver shall indicate the reason for such departure manually on the record sheet of the recording equipment or on a printout from the recording equipment or in the duty roster, at the latest on arrival at the suitable stopping place.”

The fundamental issue to consider at the outset is whether the departure referred to in Article 12 of Regulation 561/2006 does not jeopardize road safety and enables the vehicle to reach a suitable stopping place. Driving from one parking area to the next in accordance with applicable regulations should, in principle, meet these conditions.

Reasons justifying a departure
To correctly identify the circumstances that a driver may invoke to justify a departure from the working time regulations, one must refer to the case law, which is relatively extensive in this regard.

According to the judgment of the Supreme Administrative Court (NSA) of 24 February 2015, II GSK 10/14, “it concerns situations of extraordinary difficulties, independent of the driver’s will and clearly unavoidable and unforeseeable, even with the exercise of the highest diligence. This provision does not authorize a driver to depart from the regulation for reasons that were known before the start of the journey”.

A similar position was taken by the European Court of Justice in its judgment of 9 November 1995, C-235/94, stating that Article 12 of Regulation 561/2006 does not exempt carriers from taking into account traffic jams, weather conditions, or the availability of parking spaces on busy routes that occur regularly on roads.

Reasons that cannot be considered as justifying the ability to invoke Article 12 of Regulation 561/2006 include:
– road works (see judgment of the NSA of 06.03.2012, II GSK 71/11);
– difficult weather conditions in the form of heavy precipitation (see judgment of the Provincial Administrative Court (WSA) in Lublin of 12.01.2012, III SA/Lu 542/11);
– organizational issues related to the unloading of goods (see judgment of the WSA in Łódź of 06.06.2014, III SA/Łd 303/14);
– reasons related to an urgent delivery deadline for goods (see judgment of the WSA in Wrocław of 13.06.2014, III SA/Wr 245/14).

The impossibility of invoking Article 12 of Regulation 561/2006 is also confirmed by the guidelines of the Chief Inspectorate of Road Transport (GITD) of 28 July 2011, according to which the necessity of finding a suitable parking space is not a circumstance unknown before the start of the journey.

Proper documentation of the departure
If a driver has decided to depart from the application of the regulations based on Article 12 of Regulation 561/2006, they should properly document this circumstance.

The primary and only evidence forming the basis for establishing a departure is a handwritten annotation on the record sheet of the recording equipment or on a printout from the recording equipment, or in the duty roster. Attention should be paid to the closed catalog of evidence mentioned above and the simultaneous ineffectiveness of the driver or entrepreneur invoking other means of evidence such as witness testimony or the driver’s daily activity report.

To avoid misunderstandings that may arise during a roadside inspection, the driver’s handwritten annotation should contain a description of the reason for the departure, the place where the departure occurred, the date, and the driver’s signature. It is also recommended to include a short formula stating that the driver invoked Article 12 of Regulation 561/2006, adding the aforementioned legal basis.

In the case of international transport performed in several European Union countries, the problem arises as to which language the description should be made in. Article 12 of Regulation 561/2006 does not decide on this issue, and at the same time, considering that Polish is one of the official languages of the European Union, a description in Polish should be honored throughout the territory where Regulation 561/2006 applies, which was confirmed in the GITD guidelines of 28 July 2011.

The description referred to above should be made by the driver at the latest upon arrival at a place allowing for a stop.

Summary
Taking into account the above findings, it must be concluded that invoking Article 12 of Regulation 561/2006 in the case of violations of drivers’ working time caused by a lack of parking infrastructure is an incorrect procedure, which is reflected in both the GITD guidelines and the case law of courts in Poland and the ECJ.

According to Annex No. 1, item 4.1 to the Act of 6 September 2001 on Road Transport, item 13.4, exceeding the maximum daily driving period by up to 1 hour and for each subsequent started hour is subject to a penalty of 100 PLN, while exceeding the maximum driving time without a break by more than 15 minutes up to 30 minutes and for each subsequent started 30 minutes is subject to a penalty of 150 PLN.

Legal basis:

Legal status of the publication (date): 2018-03-26