
The organization acting on behalf of EPAL pallet producers has filed a notification with the Office of Competition and Consumer Protection (UOKiK). It suspects an abuse of a dominant position by the FMCG market leader and the conclusion of an agreement by the company that restricts competition in the wooden pallet market.
The issue of pallets in the Biedronka chain has landed on the desk of the President of UOKiK. EPAL Polska, an organization representing producers and repair facilities for “white” pallets, has filed a formal notification regarding the suspected use of anti-competitive practices by Jeronimo Martins Dystrybucja and CHEP Polska. EPAL is requesting the initiation of antitrust proceedings. There is a suspicion that Jeronimo Martins is abusing its dominant position in the FMCG procurement market. Biedronka currently controls over 46% of the modern grocery retail segment in Poland. With such a scale of operations, imposing a specific type of pallet on suppliers – under penalty of seizure without compensation – may constitute a practice prohibited by competition law.
UOKiK is also to investigate whether an agreement was reached between Jeronimo Martins and CHEP Polska aimed at eliminating entrepreneurs offering white pallets from the market. CHEP, with an estimated 40-50% share of the Polish pallet market, has a clear interest in weakening competition from the open Euro-pallet system.
The mechanism of exclusion
From August 1, 2027, suppliers who deliver goods on a white Euro-pallet will lose it irretrievably – the chain will take ownership of the pallet, treating it as “disposable.” This is, in fact, a financial penalty for failing to comply with the requirements.
The supplier faces a choice: incur additional costs of switching to a color-coded system or lose pallets with every delivery – explains Elżbieta Modzelewska-Wąchal, a legal advisor specializing in competition law. – Given the scale of deliveries to Biedronka, this is a calculation that leads to an unambiguous conclusion.
In its notification, EPAL points to three types of potential violations. The first is the imposition of purchase conditions (Art. 9(2)(1) of the Antitrust Act) by forcing suppliers to use a specific type of transport packaging. Secondly, the prevention of competition (Art. 9(2)(5)), i.e., taking actions leading to the marginalization of the competing white pallet system. And thirdly, the imposition of burdensome contract terms (Art. 9(2)(6)), i.e., taking ownership of pallets without compensation.
Why the suspicion of collusion?
CHEP is a global giant – in Europe, it has over 120 million pallets in circulation, seven times more than its direct competition. In some countries, such as the UK, its market share reaches 90%.
Eliminating white pallets from the circulation of the largest retail chain in Poland is a strategic success for the operator of blue pallets.
The other pools approved by Biedronka – LPR and NDHP – have marginal shares, not exceeding a few percent – notes Roman Malicki, President of the Board of EPAL Polska. – In practice, we are talking about a situation that will primarily benefit CHEP.
Safeguarding against irreversible effects
EPAL is also requesting the application of a protective measure – ordering Biedronka to refrain from refusing to accept goods on white pallets until the case is resolved. The argument? The consequences of introducing the new rules may prove impossible to reverse.
If hundreds of pallet producers go bankrupt, repair shops close down, and suppliers switch to closed systems, returning to the state before the decision will be unattainable – argues Roman Malicki.
A modern alternative
Meanwhile, the open white pallet system is developing technologically. EPAL pallets marked with an individual QR code enable full traceability of each carrier, verification of authenticity, automation of records, and integration with logistics systems. This is a response to allegations that closed pools offer better control and transparency. EPAL pallets are produced locally by Polish plants, provide employment in the regions, and meet the requirements of the EU PPWR regulation regarding reusability and recycling.
What can UOKiK do?
The Office may initiate explanatory proceedings, followed by antitrust proceedings. In the event of finding anti-competitive practices, financial penalties of up to 10% of the company’s turnover may be imposed. With Biedronka’s revenues exceeding 100 billion PLN, we are talking about a potential penalty in the billions. The pallet and logistics industry are waiting for the regulator’s move.
Source: EPAL








