
The European Labour Authority (ELA)1 is another small step towards enforcing new legislation regarding posted workers, including professional drivers. There is little talk about this institution—which is set to launch this year with a 50-million-euro budget, 140 officials on board, and a vision of reaching full operational capacity by 2023—in the context of road transport. Why? Because the organization’s general goal is to support European Union citizens in understanding and complying with their rights and obligations regarding labor mobility. However, in practice, EU inspectors will pay particular attention to, among other things, the working hours and wages of truck drivers. According to European Commission estimates, more than two million people cross the borders of Community states every day as part of international road transport. Passengers and goods are transported by, among others, Polish drivers. Therefore, there is no shortage of people to monitor.
Once the Mobility Package enters into force, the posted workers regulations will be at the top of the list for many inspections in the countries of the “old” EU. 16 million—that is how many people in Europe live and work in a country other than their own. Furthermore, according to EC estimates, 1.7 million people commute to work across borders every day. The latest report from Statistics Poland (GUS) shows that two million 121 thousand Poles are currently living abroad. Where can they be found? The most popular work destinations are the United Kingdom (approx. 790,000 people), Germany (approx. 700,000), the Netherlands (120,000), and Ireland (110,000). According to the study “Working abroad. Work in the Union,” Poles most often perform duties in construction, interior finishing, electrical work, or plumbing. They are also construction machinery operators. Poland leads in terms of sending its workers to other parts of the Community, but drivers do not appear in any list of the most common professions performed abroad.
– The discussion on whether a driver can be a posted worker under international labor law has been going on for a long time. It seems logical that if someone transports goods from Poland to Munich every day, then returns to the country or passes through subsequent states, they should not be treated as a posted worker within the meaning of EU law. A professional driver, even during the shortest settlement period, can be in different places, crossing borders several times a day. However, at this moment, it does not matter much, as the Mobility Package is on the final stretch to being approved in Brussels. We are only waiting for the result of talks between the new representatives of the European Parliament and members of the Council of the EU and the European Commission. They will assess whether the current proposals will go directly to a vote in the Council or return to parliamentary committees for further work – says Łukasz Włoch, chief expert at the National Center for Driver Settlement (OCRK). – It should be noted that until the fate of the Mobility Package is decided, drivers are subject to minimum wage settlement as posted workers. But at this moment, a Polish entrepreneur has the possibility of including part of the costs resulting from business trips in the settlement of the minimum wage abroad. Such a situation is beneficial for both parties – the employer and the employee. Nevertheless, sooner or later, the rules for settling the minimum wage applicable across the entire European market will be organized and defined. It is not a question of whether they will be, but how they will be calculated, for example, whether allowances for business trips will remain part of them. The question also arises as to what will change in the current scenario, who will check it, and how effective the inspections will be. One of the bodies supporting inspectors monitoring drivers and carriers is to be the European Labour Authority – adds the OCRK expert.
ELA will guard the law
According to the report by MEP Ismail Ertug, if a driver spends most of their time working in another country, Regulation (EC) No 593/2008 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 17 June 2008 on the law applicable to contractual obligations, known as “Rome I,” should apply to them. In such a case, this indicates the necessity of concluding a contract between the employee and the employer based on the laws of the country where the employee performs the majority of their duties, i.e., for example, in accordance with German law. Is this correct? The EUP established in Brussels is intended to help resolve such doubts and any disputes regarding the equalization of local working conditions with the wages of drivers.
– The Authority, according to the assumptions, is to implement in particular goals related to supporting Member States in facilitating access for citizens and employers to information about their rights and obligations regarding mobility and social security. It is also intended to facilitate joint inspections and improve the exchange of information between countries. Finally, it will be responsible for mediation and assistance in finding solutions in the event of disputes between Member State authorities – says Mariusz Skurzyński from OCRK. – Such an institution should ensure a fair and effective way of enforcing EU regulations in the transport industry. How it will turn out remains to be seen. One thing is certain. If the provisions of the Mobility Package are approved, the carrier will have to adapt to the remuneration rules applicable in all countries where the driver has spent more than three days. This may lead to a change in the business model, i.e., limiting transport to only one country and specializing the service, or a significant increase in return trips without cargo. Let us remember that the principals, i.e., the contractors of Polish carriers, as well as the consumer, i.e., every EU citizen, will pay for this – adds the expert.
A union of equality, not freedom
A fragment of the EU directive from June 28, 2018, regarding the posting of workers in the framework of the provision of services, reads: Due to the highly mobile nature of work in international road transport, the implementation of this directive in this sector raises particular doubts and legal difficulties, which are to be resolved in specific provisions regarding road transport, as part of the Mobility Package, which also strengthens the fight against fraud and abuse.
What will MEPs decide regarding the so-called Mobility Package? We do not know yet, but it is certain that in 2020 an amendment to the directive on posted workers is to enter into force, which the package was supposed to supplement. If these provisions are not approved in the currently discussed form, drivers will not be subject to its new regulations, but the European Labour Authority will already be developing and strengthening its position. It is worth following its actions.
1 European Labour Authority, abbreviated as ELA.








