
In the practice of handling transport claims, it is common to encounter an approach by carriers where they dismiss claims regarding shipment damage by pointing out that the consignment note was “cleanly signed.” According to carriers, the fact of a “clean signature” on the consignment note, i.e., signing it by the recipient without reservations, makes the damage disappear as if by magic, and they can sleep soundly regardless of how they handled the shipment during transport. Does the lack of reservations in the consignment note really mean that the carrier will not be held liable for the damage?
Expert answer: At this point, it is worth starting by dividing transport damages into apparent and hidden damages. Hidden damage is damage that cannot be noticed from the outside without unpacking the shipment. Analogously, apparent damage is the opposite of hidden damage. The key point where damage is most often revealed is the receipt of the shipment by the recipient. At this time, the consignment note is signed, and the recipient decides whether to accept the shipment, refuse it, or accept it with reservations. A “cleanly signed” consignment note, i.e., one without any reservations, is not sufficient evidence that the damage did not occur during transport. Only in one case does signing the consignment note without reservations result in the expiration of the recipient’s claims against the carrier. This happens under domestic transport regulations if, despite the existence of apparent damage, the recipient does not enter reservations into the consignment note. In other cases, i.e., with hidden damage in domestic transport and with both apparent and hidden damage in international transport, the lack of reservations worsens the recipient’s legal position in the context of proving transport damage, i.e., for example, a presumption arises that the goods were delivered without damage, but this does not mean that the claim will always be ineffective. However, it forces greater evidentiary activity on the part of the recipient and makes the task easier for the carrier, who, when considering the claim, can first point out that the consignment note was “cleanly signed,” and therefore compensation is not due. If the carrier had no reservations about the condition of the shipment at the time of acceptance for transport, it is assumed that the client handed it over in an undamaged state. If the consignment note does not contain the recipient’s remarks, but the client reported hidden damage within the appropriate time after receipt, to obtain compensation, the client should demonstrate that from the moment of receiving the shipment from the carrier until its unpacking and informing the carrier about the damage, nothing happened to the shipment that could have caused its damage. For this purpose, the client may, for example, call their witnesses – employees, or monitoring footage, if available. If the client shows such initiative, the very fact of a “cleanly signed” consignment note will likely prove insufficient for the carrier to dismiss the claim.
Legal basis:
• Act of 15 November 1984 Transport Law
• Convention on the Contract for the International Carriage of Goods by Road (CMR) and Protocol of signature done at Geneva on 19 May 1956
Legal status of the publication (date): 2017-03-13







