The article presents the issues of VAT deduction limitations related to the acquisition of passenger cars used in business activities and fuel for them. The effects of the judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Communities (ECJ) of December 22, 2008, in case C-414/07 Magoora sp. z o.o. are discussed. The interpretation of the Minister of Finance of February 13, 2009, containing explanations related to the deduction of value-added tax on the acquisition of both motor vehicles and the fuel used to power them is also presented. Attention is drawn to the rules for making VAT adjustments in the scope of the discussed issue, as well as discrepancies in the jurisprudence of administrative courts on the above matter.1. Introduction
The purpose of this study is to present issues related to the right to a refund of non-deducted VAT charged on passenger cars purchased after May 1, 2004, and VAT charged on fuel purchased for the vehicles in question. The discrepancies that have appeared in the jurisprudence concern the application of limitations on input tax deduction in a situation where such limitations existed in national law at the time of Poland’s accession to the European Union (the so-called “stand still” clause) in the context of the judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Communities in Luxembourg of December 22, 2008, in case C-414/07 Magoora Sp. z o.o. v. the Director of the Tax Chamber in Krakow. In this regard, against the background of a similar legal and factual state, the judgment of April 3, 2009, in case ref. no. I SA/Kr 147/09 was appealed to the Supreme Administrative Court, and no decision has been reached to this day. In the scope of the addressed issue, there is a significant discrepancy in the jurisprudence of the Voivodeship Administrative Courts in Poland, and consequently, the filing of cassation complaints to the Supreme Administrative Court. Therefore, the addressed issue deserves to be examined. (…)
The article contains 28,961 characters.
Source: Logistyka Magazine
Department of Economics and Enterprise Organization – PDF file for download








