We hear about stockbrokers, information brokers, and insurance brokers. Courier brokers have also appeared on the market. What is your opinion on their services? Does courier brokering have a chance for development in Poland?
dr Arkadiusz Kawa, Department of Logistics and Transport, Poznan University of Economics and Business: Brokerage services have been used in business for many years. A broker’s activity most often boils down to acting as an intermediary between a buyer and a seller of a product or service. These services exist in the financial, capital, insurance, and real estate markets. In the case of logistics services, we can look for the origins of mediation in forwarding, where specialized entities – forwarders – organize the transport of shipments and carry out related activities, most often using external transport and handling equipment.
Recently, more and more attention has been paid to courier brokers. Due to the dynamic development of services offered by brokers, it is currently better to define them as CEP intermediaries – courier, express, and parcel services. A CEP intermediary is a company that resells logistics capacity purchased in advance from express carriers, postal operators, and other entities. It allows individuals and companies that cannot or do not want to sign contracts with carriers to use CEP services. To conclude such a contract, it is usually necessary to conduct business activity and declare a minimum number of parcels to be sent.
The first virtual intermediaries offering online platforms were created in 2007-2008. Their dynamic development took place in 2009-2010, during the economic crisis. At that time, a significant portion of consumers began looking for cheaper products online, which translated into increased delivery needs. E-customers only had the choice of cheaper but slower and less convenient postal services, or much more expensive, faster, and direct courier deliveries. For individual customers and small businesses, which make up the majority in e-commerce, the prices of courier shipments were even several times higher than postal ones. The remedy for this was CEP brokerage services. The idea was simple – the broker signed a very favorable contract with a courier, declaring a large number of shipments, and searched for customers for shipments on their own behalf. By collecting orders from many senders, the broker becomes a large client for CEP operators. Thanks to this, they have greater bargaining power and can obtain much better cooperation terms than individual customers sending a small number of shipments.
The clients of courier brokers are mainly companies that conduct their business online, i.e., online stores and sellers on online auctions. However, the largest brokers create professional call centers through which they actively look for clients from outside e-commerce. Their clients are companies that send from a few to several dozen parcels per month. Broker prices are up to 70-80% lower than the prices resulting from publicly available price lists of CEP operators. In the case of sending a larger number of shipments, prices can be even lower. Some brokers offer a business offer with discounts to clients who send more than, for example, 20 parcels per month. The largest differences (80-90%) between the courier company’s price list and the broker’s are in international shipments.
The market for CEP intermediaries is promising. While the growth rate in the number of new brokers has weakened slightly, their scale is still impressive. By the end of 2014, over 100 actively operating CEP intermediaries on the Internet were identified. However, there may be many more, because not all of them position their websites. It is predicted that many new intermediaries will be created in the near future.
A trend of consolidation of entities can be observed in the intermediary market. The poor financial condition of many, especially small, intermediaries forces them to finance current liabilities to the courier operator with the collection payments of the intermediary’s clients. As a rule, such an action leads the broker to bankruptcy. The solution to this problem is the takeover of such entities by companies that are financially stronger.
Additionally, competition from CEP operators is increasing, as they are trying harder and harder to encourage small and medium-sized enterprises to use their services. Examples include pre-paid services from Siódemka and Poczta Polska or the specially created brand K-EX – pewnapaczka.pl. The number of parcel dispatch and collection points (e.g., at gas stations, in stores, kiosks) that offer cost-effective solutions is also growing.
A certain niche that CEP intermediaries for e-commerce can try to develop may be additional logistics services. In the case of micro and small companies expanding their offer, there is a lack of space and the ability to store goods. None of the large logistics operators are currently interested in serving such clients, and the CEP companies themselves are not prepared for such services due to the specificity of their operations, which assumes the flow of shipments without unnecessary storage.







