
As part of the settlement with the principal – Company X, Company Y decided to assign the receivables due to the contractor from its debtors. Most of the debtors transferred the amounts covered by the assignment, however, some of them refused, citing an additional provision in the transport contract regarding the prohibition of the assignment of receivables. In such a case, can Company Y still pursue claims against the entities for which the assignment was made?
Expert’s answer: The basic normative act regulating the issue of the assignment of receivables is the Civil Code. Pursuant to Article 509 § 1 of the Civil Code, “A creditor may, without the debtor’s consent, transfer a receivable to a third party (assignment), unless this would be contrary to the law, a contractual stipulation, or the nature of the obligation”.
It happens that principals include clauses in their contract templates that are intended to result in a prohibition of assignment. Taking into account the wording of Article 509 § 1 of the Civil Code, the agreement between Company X and the carrier regarding the assignment of receivables, for which the possibility of assignment has been effectively excluded, will not have legal effects, and consequently, the possibility of pursuing payment of the amount in court will be pointless.
A separate issue is the liability of the assignor to the carrier for making an assignment of a receivable for which such a possibility was excluded.
Legal basis:
Act of April 23, 1964 – Civil Code
Legal status of the publication (date): 2019-11-05








