A dangerous giant

It is said that Poland is a transport power, but is Polish road transport safe?
<\/strong><\/p>

Mariusz Miąsko, President of the Viggen Sp. J. Law Firm, President of Logistic Technologies Sp. z o.o.<\/strong><\/em><\/strong>: <\/em><\/em>Recently, I have been increasingly encountering the claim that Poland is a transport power in the European Union, and it is hard to disagree with that. We have more and more transport companies, and more and more trucks are operating under the “Polish flag.” The rapid growth of our transport power is also evidenced by the fact that there is a shortage of drivers not only here, but also in Ukraine. Is the Loi Macron a problem for our transport? Despite the adversities, we acted quickly and Polish companies are still driving to France. We know how to drive efficiently, cheaply, and profitably, but the question is: is it safe? How does road safety compare to the position of the Polish TSL industry? Well, in my opinion, safety is taking quite a “beating,” and not because of transport entrepreneurs, but for reasons lying mainly with the senders, recipients, and often loaders/transloaders. Thinking about “safety,” I do not mean at all the issues related to drivers’ working time, as this issue is quite well monitored by the Road Transport Inspectorate. Instead, I have in mind the risks resulting from treating matters related to the immobilization of loads during transport in a totally unserious manner. This is not the fault of either the drivers or the transport companies, but they are the ones who fall victim (often literally) to the completely irresponsible and illegal behavior of: senders, recipients, loaders, transloaders, etc.
I have been dealing with transport law in Poland and carrying out corrective audits in the TSL industry for 16 years. The facts are terrible. I estimate that, statistically, about 99% of cargo units transported by trucks are incorrectly immobilized (inadequate selection of securing equipment, wrong immobilization method, poor condition of immobilization devices, errors in friction coefficient calculations, errors in load placement, etc.). Here, one must immediately distinguish between “normative immobilization” of a load (resulting from the PN EN 12-195-1 standard) and simple stabilization. The sender has an obligation to indicate how a load should be “normatively immobilized,” not just how to merely stabilize it. These are two completely different issues. Almost all transported loads are stabilized, but in my opinion, no more than 1% are normatively immobilized. And that is where the proverbial “rub” lies. This is, in a way, a derivative of irregularities in the preparation of transport documents by senders. Almost all transport documents I have audited (transport orders, consignment notes) had cardinal errors, e.g., lack of diagrams and methodology for immobilizing cargo units, lack of definition of the selection and use of immobilization equipment, and methodology for their application. In transport documentation, absurd phrases are often written, such as: “the driver is responsible for immobilizing the load,” without specifying what means and methods must be used to immobilize the given load. There is an infinite number of cargo units, dozens of types of transport equipment, hundreds of types of load-securing devices and methods of their application – so where would the driver or carrier get the knowledge about the appropriate choice of the above variables for a given type of load, its dimensions, characteristics, type of packaging, susceptibility to pressure, and dozens of other parameters? The answer is obvious – the driver and the carrier do not have such extremely precise information and cannot have it unless they receive it from the sender in the transport order or the consignment note. That is why, contrary to the common belief of TSL industry participants, Polish and international transport law clearly specifies that liability for any damage in transport resulting from the lack of precise rules for loading operations during transport, including load immobilization, is borne by entities other than the carrier – that is, the sender, and in certain situations, the recipient. Meanwhile, senders most often limit their own loading guidelines in transport orders to instructing the use of, for example, 12 belts. How is a driver supposed to immobilize almost every type of load with belts – which is most often done by applying the so-called force-locking method – if this method can only be used for loads not susceptible to crushing, and these are transported in the minority (e.g., some paper, steel, granite)? On the other hand, for so-called “susceptible” cargo units, immobilization with belts using the force-locking method is not applicable. Even if it were permissible to use the force-locking method for a given type of load, a whole range of other extremely precise variables should still be taken into account, which I have never seen in any transport order or consignment note in over a dozen years, except for companies where we have introduced post-audit procedures regarding load immobilization. The direct consequence of the lack of proper load immobilization by senders is the results of European Commission studies, which show that as many as 25% of all road accidents involving heavy goods vehicles are a direct derivative of improper load immobilization. For this very reason, a significant portion of Polish transport vehicles are being stopped on EU roads (most often in Germany) and not allowed to continue their transport. The responsibility for as much as 25% of all road accidents involving heavy goods vehicles rests in the “hands” of senders and recipients, and this must finally be said openly and directly. Either senders will realize that they bear the absolute responsibility (administrative, civil, criminal) to define very precise rules for load immobilization during transport, or people will continue to die on the roads in 25% of pointless road accidents.
Several problems can threaten safety in our transport, which have not yet been solved and also require time to be eliminated. The first problem is the absolute lack of knowledge and imagination of people involved in logistics. Harsh words, but unfortunately true, as I have stated after many audits and trainings conducted. Lack of elementary knowledge about securing methods, friction coefficients (knowledge of basic physics taught in high school), and legal issues. What can be done about it? Train, write, tell the truth directly!
Another problem is the short-sightedness of those managing logistics processes, wanting to use the cheapest methods, just to do it quickly, just to tick off the loading process. In fact, this causes losses in cargo, damage to transport equipment, chaos in warehouses, fines for drivers, administrative penalties for senders, and for the “blameless” carriers. And where are the savings on balance? I will not even mention situations in which an unsecured load falls off the transport vehicle and takes the lives of other road users. In such a situation, one can only pray at best or start taking an interest in quantum physics, string theory, and the works of Prof. Hawking in order to build a time machine to try to undo the human tragedies caused by the lack of load immobilization. Unfortunately, that is the brutal truth.
Poland is indeed a transport power, even a giant, but unfortunately, due to the lack of elementary knowledge on the part of senders, recipients, and sometimes loaders, we are very dangerous to others in road traffic. Polish carriers are absolutely not to blame for this state of affairs. For now, we are a bit like China 10 years ago, or the Japanese with their electronics in the 50s – we are everywhere, we are cheap and very competitive, but unfortunately, this does not go hand in hand with the highest quality of safety in transport. In those areas where carriers are responsible for safety, such as working time, quality of transport equipment, and driver training, it is at a quite high level. Where senders, recipients, and loaders are responsible (parameterization of normative load immobilization procedures), safety is dramatically low.
The problems I have mentioned are only the tip of the iceberg, which I hope will not sink our transport like the Titanic. Here, unfortunately, binoculars and good weather conditions are not enough to avoid the iceberg. Here, knowledge, changes in law, and enforcement of elementary principles are needed to improve our safety and for our transport to be a synonym for safety, punctuality, reliability, and highest quality. And then, like China in the economy or Japan in electronics, Poland will be a safe colossus in transport that will hold the cards in the global TSL market.<\/p>