Penalties for exceeding driver working hours. What are the legal consequences?

Photo. Pixabay

The issue of complying with driver working conditions is closely linked to ensuring safety – both for the vehicle driver and for the people or goods being transported. This is regulated by both national law and EU regulations. The obligation to comply with driver working conditions is also backed by financial and criminal sanctions. How should a driver’s working time be calculated correctly, and how high are the penalties for failing to respect their rights?

Regulations governing driver working time

The Act of April 16 on driver working time governs the working hours of those who perform transport only within the country. This applies equally to employees:
– employed under an employment contract,
– performing transport services as self-employed persons,
– not employed by an employer but performing transport on their behalf.

A driver performing road transport of persons or goods using vehicles designed for the carriage of more than nine people including the driver, or those where the maximum permissible mass together with a trailer or semi-trailer exceeds 3.5 tons, is also subject to the following EU regulations:
1. Regulation 561/2006 of March 15, 2006, along with the amending Regulation 2020/1054 of July 15, 2020 – if transport takes place within the European Community, EEA, or Switzerland,
2. The European Agreement concerning the Work of Crews of Vehicles Engaged in International Road Transport (AETR) – if transport is carried out between the European Community, EEA, or Switzerland and a third country.

Driver’s work – explanation

When do we actually talk about a driver’s work? Contrary to appearances, it is not just the time a driver spends actively driving the vehicle. According to Article 6(1) of the Act on driver working time, working time is the “period from the start to the end of work, which includes all activities related to performing road transport.” This primarily includes:
– loading, unloading, and supervision of loading and unloading,
– supervision and assistance to passengers boarding and alighting,
– forwarding activities,
– daily maintenance of vehicles and trailers,
– other work undertaken to fulfill a service task or ensure the safety of people, the vehicle, and goods,
– necessary administrative formalities,
– keeping the vehicle clean,
– mandatory 15-minute break in the case of a 6-hour or longer workday.

The driver’s working time also includes the period when they remain at their workstation in readiness to perform a task. This will therefore be related to loading and unloading operations whose start and end times are difficult to determine.
However, the following are not considered working time:
– on-call time, if the driver did not perform work during that time,
– unjustified stops during driving,
– daily, uninterrupted rest,
– breaks at work (in the case of adopting intermittent working time).

If you are a driver who wants to ensure that your employer is calculating working time in a correct and legal manner, contact a law firm with experience in this field. Lawyers will analyze your contract, working time records, and workplace regulations, allowing you to establish for which activities and in what amount you are entitled to remuneration.

Regulations related to driver working time

A driver’s working time schedule will depend on whether we are considering Polish law or EU regulations.

National regulations
According to Polish regulations, an employer may introduce an individual working time schedule in the workplace for the purposes of calculating working time and remuneration for optional overtime. If this does not happen, it is assumed that a day means consecutive 24 hours (starting from the beginning of the first activity according to the applicable working time schedule).
The Act on driver working time also includes the concept of on-call duty. This is the time during which a driver remains at the employer’s disposal outside established working hours. On-call duty cannot be included in daily, uninterrupted rest. For performing such duty, time off in lieu must be granted or (if that is not possible) remuneration determined based on personal grading or 60% of the base amount.

Daily and weekly working time
Articles 11 and 12 of the Act on driver working time specify that working time may not exceed 8 hours per day in a five-day work week and subject to a four-month settlement period, and 48 hours per week including overtime hours.
Parties may agree that the limit will be increased to 60 hours per week while maintaining the average limit over the specified settlement period. However, the sum of working hours in a calendar year, including overtime due to specific employer needs, cannot exceed 260 hours.
If a driver performs their duties during night hours, the daily working time cannot exceed 10 hours, and night time is considered the 4-hour period between 00:00 and 7:00 of the following day.
Drivers have the right to a break that is not shorter than 30 minutes if working time is 9 hours or less; and not shorter than 45 minutes if working time is more than 9 hours. The break after a long working period is reduced by a fifteen-minute rest period, which the employer must introduce if working time is at least six hours.
Importantly, in every 24-hour period, a driver has the right to a minimum of 11 hours of uninterrupted rest and 35 hours per week. This is performed in the vehicle if the car is parked and has a place to sleep.

Change of working system in road transport
In addition to the basic working time model, an employer may also introduce other solutions, such as:
– Equivalent working time
In this case, the standard method of calculating working time is replaced by equivalent time. Then, 12-hour work periods are interspersed with free time of an analogous length or complete days off from work.
Equivalent working time should be introduced for a maximum of one month, although due to circumstances (work dependent on the season, adverse weather conditions), it can be extended to four months.
– Intermittent working time
This means that there is one break per day lasting no longer than five hours, or six hours for regular transport if working time did not exceed seven hours. During the break, the driver manages their time freely and simultaneously retains the right to half their remuneration.
– Task-based working time
There is also the possibility of introducing task-based working time – provided it results from the nature of the activity or its specific organization. However, the employer is still required to comply with norms related to breaks and rest, while the task must be achievable within the base time of eight hours. Furthermore, the working time schedule is set by the driver themselves, not the employer.

These types of systems are introduced in a collective agreement, notice, or regulation. Sometimes it is also necessary to notify a labor inspector. Furthermore, collective agreements may also introduce lower maximum norms or higher minimum norms than those specified by the Act on driver working time.
Exceeding driver working hours can lead to a court case. In order to avoid such problems and the occurrence of discrepancies, it is worth consulting the content of the regulations or collective agreement with a law firm specializing in this field.

EU regulations
Regulations related to the working time of drivers performing transport within the EU are contained in Regulation 561/2006. Here are the most important ones:

Working time
According to the EU regulation, the employer must organize the work of the transport undertaking so as to enable drivers to return to the base where they start their weekly rest period or to return to their place of residence.
At the same time, the employer is obligated to prepare documentation of drivers’ working time. They also bear the costs related to their accommodation.
– A driver’s daily working time may not exceed 9 hours, with the caveat that no more than twice a week can the employer extend it to 10 hours.
– Weekly working time may not exceed 56 hours, and in two consecutive weeks, 90 hours.
– After a period of continuous driving that lasts at least 4.5 hours, a driver has the right to a break of 45 minutes (no less than 15 minutes if a second part of the break lasting 30 minutes is also taken). The exception is a situation where the driver begins a rest period after finishing work.

Rest time
The regulation also contains concepts defining periods between driving – how should we understand these definitions of rest?
– regular daily rest period – uninterrupted rest lasting at least 11 hours (this time can be divided into parts lasting no less than 3 and 6 hours),
– reduced daily rest period – uninterrupted rest lasting at least 9 but less than 11 hours,
– regular weekly rest period – rest lasting at least 45 hours,
– reduced weekly rest period – rest lasting less than 45 and not less than 24 hours.

A driver has the right to daily and weekly rest periods, with the daily period amounting to a minimum of 11 hours, and between two weekly rest periods, there may be no more than 3 reduced daily rest periods.
When a trip is performed between 10:00 PM and 6:00 AM, the vehicle should have a multi-person crew or the working time must be reduced to 3 hours. As a general rule, during two consecutive weeks of work, a driver utilizes at least:
– two regular weekly rest periods or
– one regular weekly rest period and one reduced rest period lasting at least 24 hours.

However, the weekly rest period must start no later than the end of six 24-hour periods of work, counted from the end of the previous rest period. If the rest period has been reduced, the employee is entitled to an equivalent rest time, which they take along with another rest period of at least 9 hours.

Change in EU regulations
Significant information is the fact that Regulation 561/2006 has been changed by the introduction of Regulation 2020/1054 of July 15, 2020 (in connection with the so-called mobility package). Within this, the following regulations were introduced:
– Rest periods lasting over 45 hours cannot be taken in the vehicle cabin – they must be carried out in a place providing adequate accommodation and sanitary infrastructure.
– Every driver has the possibility to return to the base at least once every 4 weeks, where they will be able to take a rest of at least 45 hours.
– When a driver takes two consecutive reduced weekly rest periods, the undertaking is obligated to enable them to return to the base before the start of the regular weekly rest period.
– A transport undertaking may not pay drivers employed or at its disposal any components of remuneration dependent on distance traveled, delivery speed, or amount of goods transported if this could threaten road safety.

Other changes relate, among other things, to the possibility of extending working time, compensation for reduced rest time, or the necessity to replace devices recording driver working time with new ones no later than 2025 (by this date, heavy goods vehicles must have new tachographs that will record all data necessary to operate in accordance with current regulations).

Sanctions for exceeding driver working hours

Despite existing regulations, exceeding driver working hours remains a huge problem in our country. For this reason, the legislator has surrounded these regulations with a system of penalties imposed after violations of driver working conditions. Sanctions differ depending on whether the driver was hired based on an employment contract or another legal basis.

Penalty under an employment contract
In the case of an employment contract, the rules contained in the Labor Code apply. According to Article 281 §1 point 5 of the Labor Code, violation of working time by an employer or a person acting on their behalf results in a fine ranging from 1,000 to 30,000 PLN. If the employee is in the National Register of Debtors, the penalty amount increases to a sum of 1,500 to 45,000 PLN.
The circumstances of such a situation are assessed individually by the labor court. Furthermore, criminal sanctions also apply for persistent violation of employee rights. According to Art. 218 §1a of the Penal Code, malicious or persistent violation of an employee’s rights arising from an employment relationship or social insurance is subject to a fine, restriction of liberty, or imprisonment for up to two years.
This provision applies, for example, when an employer regularly and intentionally divides tasks among drivers in such a way that it causes a violation of the rights in force regarding working time.

Penalty under another form of cooperation
If a driver works on a basis other than an employment contract, sanctions provided for in the annexes to the Road Transport Act apply. In such a case, the amount of the penalty is determined according to the degree of exceeding the working time.
The greater the infringement, the higher the penalty – as a result, both the employer and the driver themselves must know the applicable working time norms. It must be noted that small time discrepancies not exceeding 15 minutes (!) are not subject to sanctions.

A transport entrepreneur must account for the following penalties:
– For extending working time beyond the statutory norm – from 50 to 550 PLN and more,
– For exceeding the permissible weekly working time – from 150 to 700 PLN and more,
– For reducing the rest period – from 100 to 550 PLN,
– For exceeding the maximum vehicle driving time without a break – from 100 to 350 PLN and more,
– For exceeding the permissible working time during night hours – from 50 PLN to 100 PLN and more,
– For shifting rest time – from 150 to 400 PLN and more,
– For not keeping working time records – 1,000 PLN for each driver,
– For falsifying working time records or refusing to provide them to controllers – 8,000 PLN.

Extensive regulations governing the conditions and working time of drivers, as well as a progressive system of penalties, can be an obstacle in determining optimal solutions for a transport undertaking.
Therefore, regardless of whether you are a driver demanding the imposition of sanctions on an employer or an owner of a forwarding company who needs support in setting up a schedule in accordance with regulations – turn to experienced labor law professionals who will best secure your interests.