The Mobility Package and driver remuneration

The Mobility Package and driver remuneration

The Mobility Package consists of three groups of regulations. The first includes requirements regarding maximum daily and weekly driving times, minimum breaks and daily and weekly rest periods, as well as provisions on tachographs (EU Regulation 2020/1054). The second defines the conditions for pursuing the occupation of road transport operator and access to the international road transport market (EU Regulation 2020/1055). The last one concerns the posting of drivers in the road transport sector and roadside checks (EU Directive 2020/1057).

The Mobility Package was published in the Official Journal of the European Union on July 31, 2020, and some of its provisions entered into force on August 20, 2020. The remaining provisions, including those concerning cabotage, smart tachographs, regulations for transport with a GVW of less than 3.5 tonnes, and the posting of drivers, will become effective 18 months after the date of publication.

Consequently, on February 2, 2022, the provisions of Directive (EU) 2020/1057 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 15 July 2020 laying down specific rules with respect to Directive 96/71/EC and Directive 2014/67/EU for posting drivers in the road transport sector and amending Directive 2006/22/EC as regards enforcement requirements and Regulation (EU) No 1024/2012 will enter into force. These include specific solutions regarding the posting of drivers in the road transport sector and regulate, among other things, the recognition of representatives of this professional group as posted workers. They also indicate situations in which drivers will not be considered posted workers.

The provisions concerning the posting of drivers require implementation into the legal systems of individual member states. Therefore, a transitional period applies – initially 18 months, but time is passing and currently only 12 months remain. This means that the new rules applicable to drivers will come into force in February 2022. Implementing regulations should be expected at the end of 2021. An update to the Posting of Workers Directive 96/71/EC of 1996 and the enforcement Directive 2014/67/EU is expected. Thus, the most painful change for Polish companies – the directive on posted workers introducing the principle of equal pay for equal work in the same place – will take effect in February 2022.
According to the Mobility Package, cabotage operations (i.e., transport of goods between collection points located in a member state (EU or EFTA) other than the country where the carrier has established their business) and cross-trade operations (i.e., transport of goods between two countries by a carrier not based in either of those countries) shall be subject to remuneration settlements in accordance with the rules of the host country. Conversely, an exemption from the posting of driver rules will apply when performing transit and bilateral transport operations.

Based on the provisions of Directive 96/71/EC and Directive (EU) 2018/957, a kind of “revolution” will occur in the remuneration of drivers. It will no longer be sufficient to pay drivers the minimum wage applicable in the host country, as was the case until now. For the correct settlement of employee remuneration, it will be necessary to apply:
– statutory provisions of the host country,
– general implementing provisions – the Posting of Workers Directive,
– local administrative regulations,
– industry-specific regulations and collective bargaining agreements,
– arbitration awards.

A fundamental change is the introduction by the provisions of Directive (EU) 2018/957 of rules preventing the inclusion of allowances resulting from business trips (in transport, primarily per diems and lump sums for accommodation) as part of the driver’s remuneration. What does this mean? The EU legislator has decided that when performing cabotage and cross-trade operations, a driver must be treated as a posted worker, to whom the solutions adopted in Directive 96/71/EC and Directive 2018/957, the provisions of which entered into force on July 30, 2020, will apply. Under these rules, a posted worker will be entitled, for work performed abroad, not just to the minimum wage as before, but to the full remuneration defined by the generally applicable provisions and industry rules of the host country. The concept of remuneration has been defined in the aforementioned directives as provided for by national law and collective agreements (collective labor agreements, industry agreements, or collective arrangements), determined in accordance with the national legislation and practice of the state to whose territory the worker is posted. This means that the driver’s remuneration should include all components mandatory under national statutory, regulatory, or administrative provisions, or under collective agreements or arbitration awards that have been recognized as generally applicable in the given European Union member state.

Unfortunately, this is not the end of the unfavorable changes for Polish carriers. Article 3(7) of Directive 96/71/EC specifies that allowances specific to the posting shall be considered to be part of the remuneration, unless they are paid in reimbursement of expenditure actually incurred on account of the posting, such as expenditure on travel, board, and lodging. Where the terms and conditions of employment applicable to the employment relationship do not determine whether and which components of the posting allowance are paid as reimbursement of expenditure actually incurred on account of the posting and which are part of remuneration, the whole allowance shall be considered as reimbursement of such expenditure. This means that no business trip allowance can be a component of wages and be counted towards remuneration.
Consequently, it is estimated that after the entry into force of the Mobility Package regarding posting, labor costs for Polish entrepreneurs may increase by even 30-40 percent. Why such a change? Because it will not be possible to include business trip reimbursements as part of remuneration, companies will be obliged to pay social security contributions and income tax on the entire remuneration due to drivers.

In view of the above, the question arises as to what happens with the obligation to pay drivers for business trips, which Polish entrepreneurs are required to do under the generally applicable provisions of Polish labor law? According to a specific provision for the professional group of drivers, the Act of April 16, 2004, on Working Time of Drivers, drivers on a business trip are entitled to reimbursements for covering costs related to the performance of this business task, determined based on the principles set out in the provisions of Art. 77(5) § 3–5 of the Labor Code (Art. 21a of the aforementioned Act). Thus, a Polish entrepreneur is obliged to pay their drivers both per diems and lump sums for accommodation. However, neither the Labor Code nor the regulation of January 29, 2013, on the amounts due to an employee employed in a state or local government budget-funded unit for a business trip, issued in accordance with the statutory mandate, specifies which parts of the business trip entitlements are a reimbursement for an actually incurred expense – so it must be considered that the entirety of the business trip entitlement is a reimbursement of expenses. This is an extremely unfavorable regulation for Polish transport entrepreneurs, because when the Mobility Package provisions enter into force in February 2022, in accordance with the still-applicable national regulations, employers will have to pay drivers business trip entitlements which, under EU rules, cannot be counted towards the remuneration earned in the member state where the driver performed the work. This will cause the need to pay the driver additional remuneration (representing the difference between the Polish wage and the wage earned abroad) for work abroad and, in effect, will significantly increase labor costs for Polish transport companies. Therefore, it is necessary and advisable for the legislator to take action and prepare appropriate changes in Polish labor law, especially in the Act of April 16, 2004, on Working Time of Drivers, which would adapt the Polish driver remuneration system to the requirements imposed by the provisions of Directive 96/71/EC and Directive 2018/957.

Another problem that Polish carriers will encounter is access to the labor law provisions applicable in the host country. It will be necessary to correctly calculate the driver’s remuneration while avoiding very high penalties from European Union inspection authorities. It will be necessary to apply the appropriate labor law provisions of the host country. Let us recall that this involves not only generally applicable provisions (such as – in Polish conditions – the Labor Code, statutes, and secondary legislation) but also local administrative regulations, industry-specific rules, collective bargaining agreements, and arbitration awards. Another question arises regarding the availability of these provisions and their correct translation into Polish. The provisions of the aforementioned directives oblige member states to publish information on terms and conditions of employment on a single official national website in such a way that it includes a list of remuneration components considered mandatory, as well as additional employment conditions. It is to be hoped that such official information will be widely available. There is no doubt that all this will significantly complicate and hinder salary settlements. The changes related to posting will certainly be a challenge for Polish transport companies, as they will require knowledge of foreign law and industry regulations, which will make calculating driver remuneration more difficult and will involve increased costs for determining salary calculation rules, as navigating the maze of foreign regulations will be extremely time-consuming and may pose interpretative challenges.

The EU legislator has not introduced any changes in the Mobility Package regarding the definition of activities (tasks) performed by the driver and the rules for remunerating these activities. Answers to how and in what amount a driver should be remunerated can be found in the regulations in force in a specific member state. As for Polish regulations, to date, no changes have been introduced in the Act on Working Time of Drivers or in the Labor Code that would define a different approach to calculating driver remuneration.

Currently, the entire transport industry is anxiously awaiting action from the legislator and the authorities regarding the determination of whether a driver posted within the meaning of EU law is entitled to business trip reimbursements. Entrepreneurs are calling for action that would allow for the optimization of Polish drivers’ remuneration and keep Polish international transport competitive. Perhaps legal changes will move in the direction of introducing various types of allowances (e.g., separation allowances) which, under tax laws, would be exempt from income tax and social security contributions. At the same time, the question arises as to how interested the government is in tax changes favorable to the transport sector – after all, exempting part of the remuneration paid to drivers from taxation will lead to a decrease in state budget revenues.

The Mobility Package regulations are intended by the EU legislator to ensure equal rules of participation in the transport market for all entrepreneurs of member states. These regulations are meant to mean equal rules, equal conditions, and equal opportunities – however, whether in practice this wording of the provisions turns out to be equal for everyone, and consequently proper and beneficial, we will only be able to judge after they enter into force and after some time. Currently, a significant part of them, especially those concerning posting, raises justified doubts and fears about how international transport performed by Polish companies will look after their entry into force. No one likely has any doubts anymore that the new regulations were aimed at the dynamically developing transport enterprises of Eastern Europe. The question arises as to how they will cope in the new reality. It is impossible to avoid fears and doubts regarding the posting solutions for drivers contained in EU law, because only with the passage of time and operation in legal circulation will we receive an answer to the question of how the market for transport companies has changed and how Polish entities have coped with the application of the new regulations.