During the international transport of goods with the place of delivery in France, a driver was stopped by a road blockade as part of a protest action on one of the motorways. The vehicle was stopped suddenly and unforeseeably. The resulting standstill caused a one-day delay at the place of unloading, due to which the principal intends to charge the carrier an amount of 10,000 euros. At the same time, the driver exceeded the permitted working time, which was recorded in the vehicle’s tachograph. Is the carrier obliged to pay the amount specified above in such a situation, and is there a risk of a fine being imposed by the relevant road inspection regarding the driver’s exceedance of working time?
Expert response: Considering the scale of international and cabotage transport operations carried out by domestic carriers on the French market (see Transport – activity results in 2017), the problems faced by the latter due to delays in delivering goods seem to be a natural consequence of the protests conducted by the so-called yellow vests. Bearing in mind the nature of carrier liability for transport damage, such liability is not absolute, and there are a number of provisions that a carrier can invoke in a dispute with a person entitled to claim compensation, aiming to be relieved of liability for, among other things, damage caused by delays in transport.
Circumstances exempting the carrier from liability
In the case of international transport, the CMR Convention shall apply. The liability of a road carrier in international road transport is limited by exempting causes. According to Art. 17(2) of the CMR Convention, “The carrier shall be relieved of liability if the loss, damage or delay was caused by the wrongful act or neglect of the claimant, by the instructions of the claimant given otherwise than as the result of a wrongful act or neglect on the part of the carrier, by inherent vice of the goods or through circumstances which the carrier could not avoid and the consequences of which he was unable to prevent.”
In the case of damage caused by a delay in transport resulting from a strike, one should take a closer look at the last exempting circumstance mentioned in the provision cited above – circumstances which the carrier could not avoid and the consequences of which he was unable to prevent. The CMR Convention itself does not contain an exhaustive list of events that can be classified as the above circumstances; however, it should be pointed out that this refers to circumstances to which we can attribute the features of inevitability and irresistible force. Carriers most often invoke this circumstance when damage results from the condition of the vehicle, weather conditions, or theft and robbery.
Referring to the factual situation indicated, if the yellow vests strike was not planned on the transport route chosen by the carrier, but a road blockage occurred anyway, preventing the goods from being delivered as agreed, it should be assumed that, in principle, it could not have been avoided. It should also be noted here that, in general, strikes and protests are announced in advance and the carrier, as a professional, should monitor reports regarding the possibility of difficulties arising from this.
The second condition that must be met to effectively invoke the aforementioned circumstance excluding the carrier’s liability is for the carrier to prove that it was impossible to prevent the consequences of the strike – by taking actions that, despite the occurrence of obstacles in transport, would aim to minimize the damage (e.g., turning back from the road where the protest is being held, choosing an alternative route). If the means of transport stuck on a blocked road has no way to exit it so as not to cause a delay or limit it, this condition should be considered met.
Additionally, the fact that the means of transport was blocked as a result of a strike should be considered in light of Art. 14 of the CMR Convention – as an obstacle to carriage. In the event of an obstacle, the carrier should request appropriate instructions from the person entitled to dispose of the goods, and then act in accordance with them (if the shipment has not reached the place of receipt, the sender will, in principle, be the person entitled to dispose of the goods). Assuming that appropriate instructions have been issued, the carrier should follow them, and in their absence, should take such measures as seem best in the interest of the person entitled to dispose of the goods.
To sum up, in my opinion, taking into account the above arguments, a strike that could not be avoided and the consequences of which could not be prevented should, in principle, be considered a circumstance excluding the carrier’s liability for delay in transport.
Deadline for submitting a claim and amount of compensation
Not every strike carried out as part of the so-called yellow vests action will be considered an exempting circumstance within the meaning of Art. 17(2) of the CMR Convention, and the carrier will be considered the entity liable for the damage in principle. Even in the above situation, the carrier should, firstly, ensure that the person entitled to claim compensation has submitted a reservation to the carrier in this regard within 21 days from the day the goods were placed at the consignee’s disposal (see Art. 30(3) of the CMR Convention). Otherwise, the claims against the carrier will expire.
Secondly, even when claims are submitted within the period provided for by the CMR Convention, the amount of the compensation itself is also subject to limitations – according to Art. 23(5) of the CMR Convention, “In the case of delay, if the claimant proves that damage has resulted therefrom the carrier shall pay compensation for such damage, not exceeding the carriage charges.” In the present factual situation, even if one assumes that the carrier is liable for transport damage and the entitled person has submitted a claim within 21 days, the amount of compensation may also be limited to the amount of the carriage charges. Importantly, the circumstance of the delay, the resulting damage, and its scale should be proven by the claimant.
Issues of exceeding the permitted driver working time norms
According to Art. 12 of Regulation 561/2006, “Provided that road safety is not thereby jeopardized and to enable the vehicle to reach a suitable stopping place, the driver may depart from Articles 6 to 9 to the extent necessary to ensure the safety of persons, of the vehicle or its load. The driver shall indicate the reason for such departure from the provisions of Articles 6 to 9 in the record sheet or on a printout from the recording equipment or in the duty roster, at the latest upon arrival at the suitable stopping place.”
In the event that the vehicle was stopped suddenly, independently of the driver’s will, and was clearly unavoidable and unforeseeable (cf. judgment of the Supreme Administrative Court of 24.02.2015, II GSK 10/14), it should be stated that the driver was entitled to deviate from the application of the provisions of Art. 6-9 of Art. 12 of Regulation 561/2006. Additionally, the driver should remember to properly document the above circumstance.
Summary
The liability of a road carrier for damage caused by a delay in transport, shaped by the provisions of the CMR Convention, is not of an absolute nature, and the carrier has a number of arguments that they can raise in a dispute with an entitled person. In the case of strikes, there is a real chance of acknowledging that this was a circumstance that the carrier could not prevent and could not avoid (Art. 17(2) of the CMR Convention).
Even if the carrier acknowledges their liability in principle, they should verify the deadline for submitting a claim for damage caused by a delay in transport (Art. 30(3) of the CMR Convention), its proper documentation, and the amount requested (Art. 23(5) of the CMR Convention). The protest of the so-called yellow vests may also entail administrative liability on the part of the carrier due to exceeding the driver working time norms provided for by Regulation 561/2006. Also in this situation, the carrier is not defenseless and should refer to Art. 12 of the aforementioned regulation.
Legal basis:
- Convention on the Contract for the International Carriage of Goods by Road (CMR) and the Protocol of Signature, signed in Geneva on 19 May 1956
- Regulation (EC) No 561/2006 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 15 March 2006 on the harmonisation of certain social legislation relating to road transport
Legal status of the publication (date): 2018-11-26








