The proposal to build a shipping canal across the Vistula Spit was put forward as early as 1945 by Eugeniusz Kwiatkowski, the pre-war Deputy Prime Minister and Government Delegate for the Coast. The decision to implement this project was announced in 2006, and serious preparations for it are currently underway. Despite certain arguments in its favor, such as the development of Elbląg, ecology, or the possibility of utilizing EU funds, the project sparks much controversy. What is your assessment of this concept?
prof. zw. dr hab. Włodzimierz Rydzkowski, Department of Transport Policy, Faculty of Economics, University of Gdańsk: I read the opinions of some “experts” on the Vistula Spit canal with some astonishment. They claim it will be an opportunity for the region’s development. I argue the opposite. There are 3 projects currently functioning in Poland that Americans call “white elephants.” The first is High-Speed Rail, the second is the Central Airport, and the third is the Vistula Spit canal itself. All three share the fact that they lack economic justification. It is one thing when these topics are brought up during the “silly season,” much like the Loch Ness monster. Unfortunately, the latest government statements prove that the construction of the canal may actually begin. Editor Marek Błuś rightly stated in his commentary in “Dziennik Bałtycki” on February 8th this year that “from the point of view of (project) profitability, money will be thrown into the mud of the Lagoon.” He calculated that if maritime transshipments reach 1 million tons per year, it would require 300 vessels with a capacity of 3,500 tons each to transport this cargo through a 5-meter deep canal. Even with this assumption, the canal would earn less than 2 million PLN annually, which means a return on investment in 500 years. I share the opinion of editor Błuś that Elbląg does not have industries that require large quantities of raw materials; therefore, there is no critical mass to economically justify the need for the port’s creation. The worst thing that could happen, and which will likely happen, is for work to begin and then be abandoned by the next government team. In a comment on Ryszard Socha’s article in “Polityka” some time ago, I stated that this project is an absurdity and not worth commenting on, and today this absurd project is returning and, worse yet, has a chance of being implemented.







