Will high-speed lines be used for freight transport?

40 years ago, on October 1, 1964, the era of high-speed rail began with the opening of the line connecting Tokyo and Osaka (515 km long). A new, unprecedented high quality of railway infrastructure (small curve curvature, long straights, minimal gradient) allowed for a maximum speed of 210 km/h, and soon, thanks to the introduction of a better signaling system, it was increased to 250 km/h. Such high speed allowed the travel time between Japan’s two largest cities to be cut in half. Currently, the travel time of the fastest train –
Nozomi (which also stops in Kyoto and Nagoya) is just 2.5 hours (average 206 km/h).

For comparison, the shortest travel time between Wrocław and Warsaw Central (471 km, 3 intermediate stops) is 4 hours and 36 minutes, which is an average speed of 102 km/h. The question therefore arises, what speed determines whether a given line is considered a high-speed line? Is it 160, 210, 250 km/h, or perhaps some other value? Maybe the rolling stock used is the deciding factor?

The answer to these questions is not entirely clear and obvious, as different studies often adopt different interpretations; however, in the author’s opinion, it is best to use Directive 96/48 of July 23, 1996, for this purpose. It defines the high-speed rail system and the conditions it should meet, first of all:
1. Infrastructure, which includes:
• specially built and prepared lines for speeds of 250 km/h and higher
• specially upgraded lines prepared for speeds of around 200 km/h
• specially upgraded high-speed lines with specific features resulting from the topographic properties of the terrain or specific limitations in urban areas, where the speed must be adjusted to these conditions in each case.

2. Rolling stock, which should ensure a safe and uninterrupted journey:

• at a speed of at least 250 km/h on lines specially built for these speeds, and even at a speed of 300 km/h under certain conditions
• at a speed of around 200 km/h on upgraded lines
• at the maximum possible speeds on other lines.

3. Compatibility of infrastructure and rolling stock. High-speed railways require the highest compliance of infrastructure parameters with rolling stock parameters. And the functioning, safety of high-speed railways, and the level of quality and amount of costs result from this very compliance.

Within the framework of the above definition, countries operating high-speed railways can be divided into two groups. The “first league” consists of countries where trains travel at speeds above 250 km/h, and in most cases, it is 300 km/h. It includes:
• Japan (1964)
• France (1981)
• Germany (1991)
• Italy (1992)
• Spain (1992)
• Belgium (1997)
• Great Britain (2003)
• South Korea (2004).

In 2005, Taiwan will join this group, and at the beginning of 2007, the Netherlands as well.

The “second league” consists of: Sweden, Finland, Norway, Denmark, Greece, Portugal, Switzerland, China, and the United States, i.e., countries operating upgraded lines for maximum speeds in the range of 200 –
220 km/h. By 2010, Luxembourg, the Czech Republic, Slovenia, Russia, Kazakhstan, and Poland will also join this group.
Along with the dynamic development of the length of high-speed infrastructure, its qualitative development is progressing (improving safety, increasing capacity, raising maximum speeds to even 350 km/h), and train designs are also being developed. However, all these efforts have so far served almost exclusively for passenger transport. The question therefore arises, where do the reasons lie for which freight transport is not carried out on these lines. From a technical point of view, a certain obstacle is the limited maximum axle load of a wagon at a given speed. This relationship is inverse, i.e., the higher the speed, the lower the axle load and, consequently, the total mass of the train can be. A possible and increasingly common practice is to reduce the mass of the wagons themselves by using modern, lighter wagon bogies.
Another reason is the limited capacity of each railway line. It is true that the higher the speed at which trains can travel, the greater the capacity of a given line, but there are cases where this capacity is used to its limits. Such an example is the aforementioned Tokaido –
Shinkansen line, along which 291 pairs of passenger trains travel per day. This means that for most of the day, a train departs for Osaka or Tokyo every 3 minutes or so. Hence, freight trains could only run during a few night hours, and even then, provided that their movement would not interfere with daily line inspections and any necessary repairs. In Europe, this problem is significantly smaller; additionally, the ERTMS/ETCS (European Rail Traffic Management System/European Train Control System) system currently being introduced in many countries in parallel should significantly increase both the capacity of the entire network (up to 30 trains per hour) and the level of traffic safety. Furthermore, thanks to the standardization of signaling systems and traffic regulations, it will allow for seamless border crossings. It follows that the issue of network capacity, especially in Europe, does not constitute an obstacle to introducing freight trains to high-speed lines.
The article comes from the magazine “Logistyka”, No. 2/2005.

L2005-2s56.pdf