⚙️
🌟 Najlepsze dopasowanie
Wpisz szukaną frazę, aby zobaczyć propozycje AI.

The consignee refuses to accept the goods – what can the carrier do?

The consignee refuses to accept the goods - what can the carrier do?

During a transport from France to Germany, a road collision occurred. The police were at the scene, and after completing the formalities, the carrier continued the transport. During unloading, it turned out that part of the goods on the pallet (bags of cement) was damaged, as a result of which the consignee refused to accept the entire pallet. The carrier contacted the sender for instructions, and the sender ordered the tractor to return to France, despite the carrier’s explanations that the damaged semi-trailer was unfit for driving. The carrier’s client has no further willingness to communicate or cooperate, and it seems that the matter is unsolvable. What do the regulations say in such a situation?

Expert answer: Since the transport was taking place from France to Germany, the CMR Convention applies to the order in question. According to Article 14(1) of the CMR Convention, if for any reason the performance of the contract of carriage under the conditions set out in the consignment note becomes impossible before the goods reach the place designated for delivery, the carrier is obliged to ask for instructions from the person entitled to dispose of the goods. It was therefore very good that the carrier asked the sender of the goods for them. In a situation where the consignee refuses to accept the goods, the sender has the right to dispose of them without the obligation to present the first copy of the consignment note (Article 15(1) of the CMR Convention).

If it is not possible to carry out the instructions, according to Article 16(2) of the CMR Convention, the carrier may immediately unload the goods at the expense of the person entitled, and after this unloading, the carriage is considered completed. The carrier is responsible for the custody of the goods, but may entrust the goods to a third party and is then only responsible for the reasonable choice of that person. This means that the carrier can find a warehouse to store the goods as close as possible to the place of unloading and rent storage space until the goods are collected by the sender or consignee. The goods are charged with the amounts resulting from the consignment note and all other costs, which means that the carrier will be able to pass these costs on to the sender by issuing a debit note.

However, one should remember to document the situation. This means that all reservations should be entered into the CMR note by the driver, and photos of the damage should also be taken. It is worth inviting the sender to the unloading to draw up a damage report with them. If there is no willingness on their part, photos should be taken and the situation described together with the warehouse worker who is receiving the goods. They are an impartial person, and it is worth having them certify the condition of the goods. When charging the sender with additional costs, the carrier should indicate the legal basis, i.e., Article 16(2) of the CMR Convention.

Legal basis:

Legal status of the publication (date): 2018-02-07