“YES” to longer leases

The Sejm has passed an amendment to the Civil Code proposed by the “Friendly State” committee. The bill is currently awaiting the Senate’s position, and its changes concern lease agreements, specifically issues related to their duration. Previous regulations provided for the legal possibility of concluding a lease agreement for a fixed term of no more than 10 years.

In the case of concluding a lease agreement for a period longer than ten years, after the expiry of this period, it is considered to have been concluded for an indefinite period. This is significant mainly in terms of the possibility of terminating such an agreement, and thus, in a broader sense, in terms of protecting the stability of the lease relationship. According to the authors of the draft, the ten-year term is merely an artificial limitation.

Attempts to circumvent existing regulations
– In my work at the Jartom real estate agency, I often encounter situations where entrepreneurs, in order to better estimate the profitability of their investments and secure their interests, compete in finding solutions aimed at circumventing the current regulations regarding the length of the lease relationship – says Małgorzata Papaj, a lawyer at the Jartom Agency. – They conclude preliminary agreements stating that after 10 years they will conclude (sign) subsequent lease agreements for the longest possible – ten-year period. Sometimes they also construct an agreement calling it a lease (tenure) agreement just to be able to extend its duration to thirty years. However, I strongly advise clients against using such solutions.

Need for change
The proposed amendment is a change long awaited by certain circles. Such a change has been postulated by business communities for several years, and it should be noted that it concerns precisely this category of entities. It would introduce into legal relations between entrepreneurs the possibility of concluding a long-term lease agreement for a fixed term of up to 30 years. The practical application of these changes is visible mainly in the issue of the possibility of terminating the lease relationship, because it depends on whether the lease is concluded for a fixed or indefinite period. If the duration of the lease agreement is indefinite, both the tenant and the landlord can terminate it by observing the deadlines set in the agreement, and in their absence, by observing the statutory deadlines specified in the Civil Code. In the case of a lease agreement concluded for a fixed term, the possibility of termination is limited to the catalog of reasons listed in the agreement. The authors of the amendment draft argue that in buildings that generate income based on commercial lease agreements, the certainty of renting space of a specific size is of fundamental importance for both parties to the transaction.

What for the landlord?
The amendment in question gives an investor deriving profits from renting space the ability to estimate when the investment might pay off. According to the authors of the draft, it also provides a sense of financial security, as well as the ability to determine whether it is worth building another facility for rent in the future. According to the Jartom agency, on the Polish market, there is an increasing number of “build to suit” type agreements being signed between entrepreneurs, i.e., concluded before the facility is built. Extending the lease period is undoubtedly a beneficial solution for the investor. By building a facility for a specific tenant, taking into account their (often quite specific) requirements, the landlord may have trouble finding another tenant after the lease ends due to the “non-standard nature of the facility.” The costs incurred are often so high that the entrepreneur wants to rent the premises for as long as possible, in the safest form for themselves. The possibility of concluding a 30-year lease agreement with the tenant for whom the facility was built largely solves this problem.

What for the tenant?
Extending the lease period for a fixed term, according to some, also brings many benefits to the entrepreneur who is the tenant. Often, the tenant themselves, at their own expense, carries out adaptation work in the rented facility, optimally adjusting it to the needs of their business. This is obviously associated with the necessity of incurring (usually very high) costs. A long lease period eliminates the need to look for a new facility (after the current lease ends), and thus the need to incur costs related to adapting a new facility again, as well as the costs of another move. An important argument for the enthusiasts of the amendment is also the fact of avoiding the need to change the company’s headquarters, as the entrepreneur may lose some of their existing contractors who will simply find it too far to travel to the new location.