Working hours and shift handover

Working hours and shift handover

I was recently hired as a foreman in an electronic equipment manufacturing company. I work in a three-shift system, and according to the work schedule, these shifts start and last from 6:00 to 14:00 (1st shift), from 14:00 to 22:00 (2nd shift), and from 22:00 to 06:00 (3rd shift). Before starting work, I participate in a shift handover each time, and the employer always requires me to arrive at work early enough to obtain all information related to the tasks performed from the previous shift. Am I entitled to remuneration for arriving 15 minutes before the start of work in connection with the shift handover?

Expert response: When attempting to answer this question, one must start by defining what is understood as working time. This concept is defined in the Act of June 26, 1974, Labor Code, and in accordance with Art. 128 § 1, working time is the time during which an employee remains at the disposal of the employer at the workplace or at another place designated for the performance of work. Shift work, on the other hand, is the performance of work according to an established work schedule that provides for a change in the time of work performance by individual employees after a specified number of hours, days, or weeks (Art. 128 § 2 of the Labor Code).

Employees employed in a shift-based work organization often encounter situations where they must obtain information regarding completed activities and the status of work from the previous team. For this purpose, they are either required to arrive at work earlier or stay longer. However, this state of affairs is legally unacceptable because activities related to the shift handover belong to standard employee duties and, therefore, should fall within the established working hours. Consequently, any work performed outside the established working hours is non-scheduled work for which the employee should receive additional compensation. However, to avoid such a situation, employers can organize shifts with an “overlap,” where employees finishing work would have the opportunity to meet and hand over the shift to employees just starting work, i.e., for example, shifts would be set between 6:00-14:00, 13:45-21:45, 21:30-5:30. However, this results in a lack of coverage for a specific time of the day. Therefore, the most common practice is to introduce an additional break that is not counted as the employee’s working time. According to Art. 141 of the Labor Code, an employer may introduce one break from work not included in working time, not exceeding 60 minutes, intended for a meal or personal matters. However, this break must be introduced in a collective labor agreement or work regulations, or in the employment contract if the employer is not covered by a collective labor agreement or is not required to establish work regulations.
In summary, we recommend checking whether such regulations regarding an additional break not included in working time have been introduced, and then—if they are absent—requesting appropriate compensation.