With the current or against it? Which industries will benefit from electrification?

With the current or against it? Which industries will benefit from electrification?

Perfect solutions are very rare. Something that is useful for one business may have questionable utility for another. It is no different, at least for now, with electric commercial vehicles. Which industries will benefit from the electrification of transport, which ones not necessarily, and which are practically doomed to it?

Discussing the topic of electric vehicles – whether passenger cars or trucks – should begin with the caveat that these deliberations concern only the current state of technology. And what will the future look like?

This is not an evasion of responsibility for one’s words, but a sober look at reality. Although electric cars were built as early as the 19th century, widespread electromobility has been with us for a short time and is developing very dynamically. There is a chasm between the electric cars of 10 years ago and those presented today in terms of performance and range. Manufacturers are constantly looking for solutions that will be the final nail in the coffin for combustion vehicles, providing electric cars with a range and charging time comparable to how long it takes to refuel a diesel and how far one can travel without visiting a gas station.

I am from the city, it shows, but it is not heard

An industry where electric vehicles are already increasingly successfully undermining combustion commercial vehicles is municipal services and public transport. Here, we have key points met that negate the weak point of electric vehicles, i.e., the issue of range at high speeds and heavy loads.

In cities, electric propulsion is very efficient. It consumes energy only while driving, does not emit exhaust fumes, and is much quieter and more comfortable to drive. Electric motors are very flexible and allow for free, dynamic acceleration from a standstill. At the same time, at low speeds developed in cities, energy consumption is not increased by air resistance, which occurs, for example, during highway driving.

Added to this is the issue of the availability of charging infrastructure and the existence of time slots that allow for replenishing energy in the batteries. Electric buses are already being operated in large cities, which are recharged during short breaks at loops. It is similar with garbage trucks, which can “refuel” electricity while emptying. Currently, fast chargers have sufficient efficiency to add several dozen kilometers of range to a truck in a dozen or so minutes. This is quite enough for a garbage truck or bus to work in such a mode practically without interruption, around the clock.

The ability to work at any time is also one of the advantages of electric vehicles in the context of municipal or urban applications. Quiet propulsion, also when driving equipment, means that electric vehicles can deliver goods, remove waste, or perform other work in cities even after dark, without causing the anger of local residents.

In the case of municipal applications, the benefit also comes from the possibility of replenishing energy from one’s own photovoltaic installation. For example, a waste collection company can have solar panels and an energy storage system at its base, which will produce electricity during the day that will be used at night to charge the batteries in electric garbage trucks.

The municipal industry may be doomed to life with electricity not only for practical reasons but also due to regulations. Already, a portion of the fleet used to carry out municipal tasks must consist of vehicles with so-called alternative propulsion. It should be expected that legislation will move towards increasing the share of electric cars in public services.

I work by day, I charge by night

Relatively small daily mileages, breaks from work lasting from evening to morning, as well as driving at relatively low speeds. This is what the work of couriers or drivers in the distribution industry looks like. They drive mainly in cities, primarily during the opening hours of shops or offices, and their cars stand idle at night.

This is also an ideal scenario for using an electric car. If this can also be combined with the use of energy from sustainable sources, e.g., a photovoltaic installation, we can drive much cheaper than with a car running on fossil fuels.

From to, regularly

The ranges currently offered by electric trucks do not allow for the efficient conduct of international transport over long distances. In reality, with a load, a tractor unit is able to cover about 300 km. The network of chargers is too sparse to allow for continuous driving and charging during work breaks specified by regulations.

However, there are industries where these 300 km are already quite enough. In Sweden, one courier company uses electric tractor units on the route between the port and the transshipment center. The distance separating these two points is about 200 km. In turn, the time needed for loading and unloading allows for replenishing energy in the batteries. In such a scenario, electric, zero-emission trucks are able to handle transport tasks without problems.

Don’t buy, rent

Specialized vehicles, with bodies adapted to carry out strictly defined tasks, are often operated for many years, if not decades. This is the complete opposite of international transport, where many companies operate tractor units in three- or five-year cycles, combining this, for example, with financing in the form of long-term rental.

The point is that long-term rental is also, if not more, a beneficial tool in the case of electric vehicles. Entrepreneurs have perfectly worked out and calculated diesels, their failure rate, depreciation, and long-term operating costs. Electric vehicles are still a bit of an unknown. It is difficult to estimate every component of TCO. Moreover, technology is changing so fast that a model that is popular today may be unattractive on the secondary market in three or four years, and consequently lose a lot of value.

Entrepreneurs renting electric vehicles are free from such problems and puzzles. After the end of the usage period, they have full freedom of decision – they can return the vehicle, buy it out, or possibly extend the rental. In short, they do not bear the risk associated with potential resale and loss of value.

Long distance, distant future

The sector that is currently furthest from benefiting from the electrification of transport is the long-distance and international transport industry. Programs for building a European network of chargers are only in their infancy, and it will take a long time before their density and efficiency are sufficient. Added to this is the issue of energy consumption, and thus also range. Pulling a 40-ton set at a speed of 80 km/h or more causes the currently used batteries to become empty in an instant. In this case, “in an instant” means about 300 km, which compares poorly to the range of diesel tractor units.

Nevertheless, this situation may change soon. However, it depends on progress in developing cell technology. Manufacturers are already experimenting and working intensively on solid-state batteries. These are semiconductor batteries that do not use an electrolyte. That is the theory. In practice, such cells offer a greater range, have less mass, and allow for instant energy replenishment. Will this type of cell be a game-changer that will cause international transport to switch to electricity? Time will tell if that happens.

Source: Truck Care/Credit Agricole