Dramatically rising costs, deepening financial problems and carrier debt, unclear regulations and the absurdities of the Mobility Package, or unfair competition from third countries – these are just some of the problems that the Polish transport industry has to deal with every day. For this reason, the situation requires the introduction of decisive and bold changes. What legal regulations would help heal the transport, forwarding, and logistics sector? Commentary provided by Maciej Maroszyk, Chief Operating Officer of TC Kancelaria Prawna.

Maciej Maroszyk, Chief Operating Officer of TC Kancelaria Prawna: Polish transport is facing a serious financial crisis. Recently, a significant number of companies have been forced to liquidate part of their fleet and lay off employees. To survive, entrepreneurs are looking for savings – and this is particularly difficult in the face of rising labor costs. The crisis is also deepened by reduced demand for transport services, caused by the post-pandemic decline in production and the number of orders. To make matters worse, the increase in road tolls in Germany – for which Poland is the fifth most important trading partner – is not offset by a corresponding increase in freight rates in Europe. This places an additional burden on carriers. In the face of these challenges, the question arises as to what new regulations will be able to effectively support the transport industry and prevent further deterioration of its condition. The industry points to the need to introduce a minimum freight rate along the lines of Hungary and to limit the number of intermediaries in the industry. Moreover, there are also proposals to shorten payment terms to 30 days. Carriers are also asking for a reduction in employment costs and a modification of driver salary rates, as well as the restoration of per diems for bilateral transport. A solution to mitigate the financial collapse would also be subsidies for road and fuel charges along the lines of Germany, or the introduction of a uniform road tax rate or its complete abolition.
Another problem is the increasing inequality and competition from carriers from third countries. This concerns, among other things, lower operating costs, the lack of a requirement to have permits for bilateral transport between Poland and Ukraine, the small number of road checks of foreign carriers conducted by the Road Transport Inspectorate, or entering Poland with large fuel reserves. In the case of the latter, this puts Polish companies, limited by fuel limits imposed by the EU, at a disadvantage and simultaneously negatively affects the state budget. The industry requires the introduction of regulations that will ensure better working conditions and level the playing field between transport companies from different countries. The government is planning changes to previously scheduled amendments to the Road Transport Act. This is a response to the demands made during protests at the eastern border crossings. The proposed changes are to concern the obligation to report cabotage and international transport and to hold appropriate permits. A uniform national strategy for monitoring cabotage regulations is intended to help better enforce the law and eliminate unfair competition and abuse.
Numerous difficulties are generated by the Mobility Package regulations, mainly through unclearly formulated provisions, rising implementation costs, and a negative impact on working conditions and competitiveness. This forces many transport companies to limit or even cease operations, regardless of their size or market position. An additional burden is the absurdity resulting from poorly functioning regulations. This concerns, among other things, the obligation for the fleet to return to the home base every three weeks – even if it is located far from the main transport routes. Entrepreneurs are fighting for new legal regulations implementing EU directives in Poland to be more effective. They want further work on changes to facilitate business operations and ensure fairer competitive conditions. An example here is the proposal for state aid in financing the purchase and replacement of new tachographs required by the Mobility Package. This type of support would resemble that provided in Germany. The high cost of the devices, reaching over 4,000 PLN and multiplied by a dozen or even several dozen vehicles, is beyond the means of many carriers.
Appropriate regulations are also required for the spreading problem of abuse of international road transport permits. The lack of effective monitoring and control allows carriers to carry out routes for which they are not entitled. In turn, falsifying documents and circumventing regulations causes legally operating companies to lose income and market position. For this reason, an important change is to accelerate by six months the planned reforms in the monitoring system for sensitive goods, known as SENT. The Ministry of Infrastructure is striving for more effective control of permits for international road transport. This would take place through the earlier introduction of the obligation for foreign carriers to register in the SENT system. The monitoring system for sensitive goods has the potential to increase the effectiveness of control over international transport. However, for foreign carriers, this may constitute an additional administrative burden, generating delays or difficulties in logistics processes.







