
Transport orders are often riddled with contractual penalties, the imposition of which is not always justified. One argument may be the fact that some additional obligations set out in the contract are impossible to fulfill. It was precisely this premise that became the basis for a ruling in the form of a judgment undermining the effectiveness of a contractual penalty for transshipment.
The aforementioned case was reported to a law firm by a carrier whose company was charged by “ABC” with a penalty for transshipment of goods.
The client received two transport orders from their principal, which were to be carried out separately, using two different vehicles. During transport, however, one of the vehicles broke down, which cast doubt on the execution of one of the orders. Consequently, the client made the decision to transship the goods onto the first vehicle in order to be able to fulfill the contract.
After completing the order, the “ABC” company decided to charge the client a contractual penalty in connection with the unauthorized transshipment of goods. It cited point 8 of the transport order, which read: “The Contractor is subject to a total ban on transshipments or reloading without obtaining prior written consent from the Principal, under penalty of a contractual fine in the amount of the freight.”
The law firm’s task was to challenge the imposition of the penalty as unfounded in court proceedings. After analyzing the documents provided by the client, the lawyer proposed taking the case to court to obtain payment for the two completed transport orders.
There was a transshipment, so the order was not executed correctly
The court ruling on the case in the first instance did not share the law firm’s argumentation and dismissed the claim in its entirety, additionally awarding the costs of the proceedings to the “ABC” company. The reason for the dismissal was the fact that two separate orders were executed with one vehicle. As a result, the Court found that the first of the orders was, in fact, not executed, because only one vehicle reached the destination, which was used to perform both orders.
– The court additionally emphasized that, regardless of the contractual penalty imposed by the “ABC” company, the client’s demand for payment for the second transport in this situation would constitute an abuse of rights and unjust enrichment of the carrier. In such a situation, they would have saved on the cost of one vehicle’s trip while gaining remuneration as if two transports had taken place – explains Paweł Łazarewicz, a lawyer at TC Kancelaria Prawna.
The carrier could not fulfill the obligation
An appeal was filed on behalf of the client against the judgment issued in the case, challenging the validity of charging them with a contractual penalty for transshipment of goods and the violation of the very essence of the transport contract. The second-instance court shared the opinion that the solutions agreed upon by the parties to the contract resulting in the calculation of a contractual penalty for transshipment would have to be formulated in a way that leaves no doubt and no margin for interpretation. It also pointed out that a penalty for failure to fulfill obligations can only be imposed when the carrier was in a position to perform them. In this case, the conditions imposed by the principal, i.e., the necessity of obtaining written consent for transshipment, were impossible to fulfill.
Written consent in transport – is it realistic and does it make sense?
The second-instance court noted that, according to the contract provisions, the “ABC” company had to express consent for transshipment in writing. Thus, it excluded the possibility of expressing consent via email, text messenger, or SMS. In light of the regulations, these do not count as means of written communication, but rather as categories of remote communication means.
– Providing information in writing in this situation was not possible because the transport was international in nature and had to be completed within a set time. It is difficult to imagine that in an emergency situation where a transshipment must occur, the carrier would receive written consent by mail or courier. In such a situation, one must take into account the time for the correspondence to reach the recipient. Such an action would extend the transport completion deadline, leading to improper performance of the primary obligation, which is transporting the cargo on time. For these very reasons, various types of messengers, emails, or phones are commonly used in international transport, as they ensure efficient and timely communication – points out Paweł Łazarewicz.
Unrealistic requirement means an ineffective penalty
As the discussed example showed, it is worth seeking legal advice regarding the imposition of a penalty that raises our doubts. The basis for its calculation cannot be contrary to the practice of conducting transport business and must be feasible, taking into account the type of transport activity being conducted. Only after these conditions are met can a contractual penalty be considered effective and justified.
It is a fact that in the described case, the client, by performing the transshipment of goods without consent, did indeed perform the contract binding the parties improperly. However, the failure to perform this obligation could not, for the aforementioned reasons, lead to the calculation of a contractual penalty.
In case of doubt – ask a lawyer
– It is worth emphasizing that the obligations imposed by the principal on the carrier were not additional activities, but were strictly related to the primary obligation. If the obligation regarding consent for transshipment could have been communicated in a form other than written, nothing would have stood in the way of considering such an obligation effective – says Paweł Łazarewicz from TC Kancelaria Prawna.
Both parties to a transport contract have the right to include provisions regarding specific obligations, including the necessity of obtaining consent for certain actions. However, one must remember that fulfilling these obligations must be practically feasible. If this is not the case, the imposition of a penalty in connection with the failure to fulfill a given obligation will not be effective. It is therefore worth paying attention to the detailed provisions of transport orders and reacting when they raise our doubts. An experienced law firm can provide an opinion on a contract even before it is signed or check the validity of a penalty after it has been imposed.
Source: TC Kancelaria Prawna







