
What product value should be the subject of a customer’s claim in the event of product damage – the value at which the customer purchased the product being the subject of the claim, or the value at which the product is sold?
Expert answer: In domestic transport, the primary regulation regarding the amount of compensation for transport damage is Article 80(1) of the Transport Law Act, according to which: The amount of compensation for the loss or shortage of a shipment may not exceed the value determined on the basis of and in the following order:
1) the price indicated in the supplier’s or seller’s invoice, or
2) the price resulting from the price list in force on the day the shipment was handed over for transport, or
3) the value of goods of the same kind and quality at the place and time they were handed over for transport.
2. If it is impossible to determine the amount of compensation in the manner specified in paragraph 1, the amount shall be determined by an expert.
The above criteria should be applied in a strictly defined order. If there is a bill (invoice) from the seller, there is generally no possibility of using the other criteria for determining the amount of compensation, including the appointment of an expert. Except in situations where the value of the shipment has been declared, the provisions of the Act do not provide for the possibility of providing evidence of a shipment value other than that resulting from the content of the bill or invoice. This also applies to situations where there are obvious discrepancies between the value of the shipped goods and the price stated on the invoice. This concerns in particular the transport of goods intended for promotional or bundled sales, where the seller deliberately decides to sell the goods at a price lower than their value […] (see: Ambrożuk D., Dąbrowski D., Wesołowski K., Prawo przewozowe. Komentarz, Published: LEX, 2014).
The primary method for determining the amount of compensation for the loss or shortage of a shipment, applicable in this case, is the price stated in the seller’s or supplier’s invoice. The transport of goods usually takes place in the performance of another civil law contract (sale, supply, etc.), i.e., a contract as a result of which the goods are sold, accompanied by the issuance of a commercial document objectively determining the price of the goods. Although the Act does not state this explicitly, it should be assumed that it refers to the bill (invoice) accompanying the shipment (i.e., existing at the time the shipment is handed over for transport), and only in the commercial relationship for the performance of which the transport contract was concluded (see D. Ambrożuk, Ustalenie wysokości…, pp. 128–129).
Conclusion:
The above considerations lead to the conclusion that if the principal sells a product and damage occurs during transport between the principal and the customer, the price taken into account should be the price at which the principal sells the goods at that given moment, and not the price at which they purchased the goods some time ago. Similarly, under the CMR Convention, in accordance with Article 23(1), compensation is calculated according to the value of the goods at the place and time at which they were accepted for carriage. Therefore, since the principal sells the goods at a lower price than they previously purchased them for, this new, lower price should be taken into account for determining the compensation.
- Legal basis: Act of 15 November 1984 Transport Law
- Convention on the Contract for the International Carriage of Goods by Road (CMR) and Protocol of signature, done at Geneva on 19 May 1956
- Legal status of the publication (date): 2016-11-14







