
A few months ago, my transport company entered into an agreement with a company involved in pallet production. At the beginning, the cooperation was exemplary. We carried out several pallet transports to Germany. Payments for these services were even made before the agreed deadlines. Unfortunately, this did not last long. We did not receive payment for several shipments. From unofficial information, we learned that the pallet manufacturing company is having financial problems. Additionally, it is rumored that the owner of this company, fearing bailiffs, sold part of the company to his wife. Do we have a chance to recover our money in this situation?
Expert response: The presented case raises several topics that require clarification. First of all, it is in the interest of the transport company to take steps to recover the debt as soon as possible. The content of the question does not specify exactly at what stage this matter is currently. If nothing has been done yet, the first step should be to try to settle the matter amicably. Perhaps the indebted company will want to pay for the completed transports if the debt is spread out in installments or the debt amount is reduced. It may turn out that this way of recovering at least part of the debt will be more effective than quickly taking the case to court. If, however, no amicable steps to recover the debt are effective, the case should be referred to court. Ultimately, this should lead to a judgment favorable to the transport company, which, when subsequently handed over to a bailiff, is the basis for initiating enforcement proceedings. However, this final path has two fundamental drawbacks. First, time; from referring the case to court to the start of actions by the bailiff, many months or even years may pass. Second, even a final judgment does not guarantee that the bailiff will be able to recover our money.
Regarding the problem of the debtor “moving assets,” the creditor (transport company) in this case is protected by the provisions of the Act of April 23, 1964 – Civil Code. The institution of the so-called “Paulian action” may apply in this case. What does this involve? According to Art. 527 § 1 of the Civil Code, when, as a result of a legal act by a debtor performed to the detriment of creditors, a third party has obtained a financial benefit, any of the creditors may demand that this act be declared ineffective against them if the debtor acted with the awareness of harming creditors and the third party knew about it or could have found out with due diligence. The content of the question indicates that this is exactly the situation we are dealing with. Additionally, it is significant that the debtor is “getting rid of assets” to his wife. If, as a result of a legal act by a debtor performed to the detriment of creditors, a financial benefit was obtained by a person in a close relationship with them, it is presumed that this person knew that the debtor was acting with the awareness of harming creditors.
In practice, using the “Paulian action” still requires taking the case to court. Most often, creditors in this mode sue the persons to whom the assets were transferred. In the presented case, this person would be the debtor’s wife.
- Legal basis: Act of April 23, 1964 – Civil Code (Journal of Laws of 1964, No. 16, item 93, as amended)
- Legal status of the publication (date): 2016-10-10







