
The Russian-Ukrainian conflict, ongoing since February 24, 2022, is increasingly impacting international trade and business relations. The weakening of logistics chains, rising prices of fuel and raw materials, as well as being cut off from eastern suppliers, means a crisis for many companies. What is the economic situation in Poland in light of the war being fought on transit territory, and how can companies defend themselves against economic disaster?
Which industries are affected by the consequences of the conflict across the eastern border?
Severe losses have primarily affected the transport and construction industries. Of course, these are not the only branches of the economy that are losing out due to the ongoing armed conflict. Current Eurostat data show that Poland is also a recipient of many other goods:
- industrial goods classified by raw material (almost 30% of imports),
- inedible raw materials excluding fuels (almost 23% of imports),
- food and live animals (over 13% of imports),
- animal and vegetable oils, fats, and waxes (over 10% of imports).
Polish entrepreneurs also import chemicals, machinery, equipment, and transport gear. The armed conflict being fought on transit territory makes it impossible to maintain existing economic relations.
To avoid huge losses in time, it is worth considering invoking the clause of extraordinary change of circumstances.
What is the clause of extraordinary change of circumstances?
Polish civil law regulations recognize an institution known as the rebus sic stantibus clause (also called the clause of extraordinary change of circumstances). It is an exception to the widely known and respected principle that contracts once concluded must be kept.
The legislator introduced the rebus sic stantibus clause in Article 3571 of the Civil Code. By virtue of this provision, any party to a contract may invoke an extraordinary change of circumstances that was not possible to foresee at the time of concluding the contract by any of the contractors, and the performance of the obligation:
- would be associated with excessive difficulties, e.g., of a logistical, technical, or economic nature,
- would threaten one of the parties with a gross loss, where the concept of loss should be understood very broadly, as a comparison of the overall situation before and after the event, and not just a simple calculation of profits and losses
There must be a causal link between the lack of predictability and the economic difficulties or loss that connects both these elements.
It should also be noted that the party does not have to wait for the actual occurrence of a business loss. It is enough that, by rationally assessing the situation (e.g., based on economic reports), it could be foreseen.
In jurisprudence and case law, it is accepted that the premises justifying the use of this breach of the pacta sunt servanda principle include:
- armed conflict,
- global epidemic,
- change in tax rates,
- closure of borders for imports,
- natural disaster (e.g., flood).
Circumstances that are universal and completely independent of the parties are considered sufficiently significant events. However, it is worth noting that a closed catalog of situations authorizing the use of this solution cannot be provided in a contract, because its essence lies precisely in creating a “safety valve” in case of an unforeseen situation.
It should be emphasized, however, that an extraordinary change of circumstances is not the same as an objective impossibility of performance. In the latter case, the obligation simply expires, but one cannot demand its modification.

What can the parties demand under the rebus sic stantibus clause?
If a party wants to demand the application of the clause of extraordinary change of circumstances, they can do so in court by filing a lawsuit in which they demand the modification of the contract by:
- designating a different method of performing the obligation,
- changing the amount of the performance,
- terminating the contract.
When deciding to terminate the contract, the court should also rule on the mutual settlement of the parties.
When adjudicating, the court should be guided by the interests of both parties, as well as the principles of social coexistence, due to the universal nature of the obstacle.
Can the parties always use the rebus sic stantibus clause?
The clause of extraordinary change of circumstances can be applied to all contracts, both those concluded with the participation of consumers and entrepreneurs. However, it will not always be possible to invoke it.
If a provision has been included in the contract according to which the parties assume all forms of risk resulting from the contract or another of similar wording, invoking Article 3571 of the Civil Code will be impossible.
It does not matter whether the conditions that would objectively justify a lawsuit for modification or termination of the contract have been met; entrepreneurs cannot avoid the consequences resulting from non-performance of an obligation.
If, due to border closures and limited transit of goods, your company is unable to fulfill its obligations, this does not always have to mean the risk of having to pay damages or a contractual penalty. It is worth contacting a law firm that will help determine whether, in the given circumstances, the rebus sic stantibus clause can be invoked, and will also analyze existing commercial contracts.







