The plague of tacho manipulation: ITD’s fight against illegal practices

The plague of tacho manipulation: ITD's fight against illegal practices

Tachograph data indicates that the driver covered 1550 km, while the map shows that the distance traveled is 20% longer. Moreover, the driver card recorded a distance more than 50% shorter than the actual one. Why do truck drivers manipulate tachographs?

We can speak of tachograph manipulation when the vehicle is moving while the “rest” function is enabled on the device. Truckers have developed many methods of falsifying driving time – ranging from deliberately not using a driver card, using multiple cards, to magnets or complex, expensive devices specialized for falsifying data. The practice concerns both older generation analog tachographs, whose operation can be disrupted by a magnet, and newer, more complex digital tachographs.
“A device for diagnosing your tachograph and energy-saving light bulbs. (…) We inform you that the device we sell has many other features.”[1] What does this mean? Anyone can buy a tool to falsify digital reader records.

– The newer the version of the tachograph, the more complicated the anti-tampering security measures – and consequently – the methods of manipulating newer versions of tachographs are much more expensive. However, this does not discourage drivers from investing in such mechanisms, the cost of which reaches up to 2,000 euros – comments Mateusz Włoch, an expert at Inelo.

Driver, why?
Tight delivery deadlines, the prospect of high fines for failing to meet contract terms, staff shortages in road transport, road obstacles, the desire to return home faster… There are plenty of reasons why drivers manipulate tachograph records, and the use of these illegal practices – especially recently – has unfortunately become quite common. In just three hours of inspection, the Road Transport Inspectorate (WITD) in Bydgoszcz revealed as many as six cases of tachograph manipulation. [2] On the same day, 15 such violations were detected in the Greater Poland Voivodeship. [3] And four days earlier, the Białystok WITD stopped a driver using three driver cards who had exceeded the maximum driving time without a break six times and shortened the required daily rest fourteen times. The total sum of fines for this record-breaker amounted to 77,000 PLN. [4] The Rzeszów WITD, in its summary of the inspection campaign, points out that there are situations where drivers themselves admit to having committed manipulation. [5]

– It happens that carriers knowingly expose themselves to potential fines for manipulating tachograph records because the costs resulting from failing to meet contract terms regarding delivery deadlines are usually much higher. This results in increased pressure on employee efficiency, which translates into violating driver working time rules and very often also manipulation – notes Mateusz Włoch. – The 2017 report on the activities of the National Labour Inspectorate shows that a total of 508 inspections regarding compliance with working time and rest regulations were carried out last year. In over 45% of cases, exceeding the daily driving time limit was detected. [6]

Fines do not scare them
– Recently, we have observed increased activity by the European Commission and other legislative bodies in the legal sphere, aimed at effectively limiting the prevalence of tacho manipulation among drivers – notes the Inelo expert. – Since September 3, 2018, a new tariff of the Road Transport Act has been in force, which has increased fines for interfering with tachograph records.

In Poland, the sanction for using illegal practices is a fine of 2,000 PLN for the vehicle driver and the person managing transport, and 10,000 PLN for the carrier. Which can cost the company a total of 14,000 PLN – informs Mateusz Włoch from Inelo.

The aforementioned act also increases the scope of inspectors’ capabilities. Vehicles suspected of using illegal practices can be sent to specialized workshops.

– In the event that an examination reveals interference with the device’s operation, in accordance with the new tariff, all costs related to the inspection are covered by the carrier – explains Mateusz Włoch. – Financial penalties are not the only sanctions awaiting transport companies. Tachograph manipulation is considered one of the most serious violations, which means that the Road Transport Inspectorate is obliged to assess the “good repute of the carrier,” which can effectively result in the suspension of the transport license.

It is worth noting that different regulations apply in each country, providing for varied penalties for manipulating tachograph records – often much higher than in Poland, and even including 48-hour imprisonment.

Will it get better?
The answer to the prevalence of manipulation is legislative solutions, but also the introduction of 4th generation tachographs, which are intended to even more effectively limit the possibility of interfering with records. Furthermore, inspections will be able to control vehicles for manipulation much more effectively. All these actions, aimed at eliminating fraud, are primarily focused on increasing road safety. Studies prove that a tired driver poses exactly the same threat as a drunk one. Inspections are fighting manipulation with legal solutions, but carriers themselves should also ensure that their drivers do not engage in this practice, which can even result in the suspension of a transport license.

– The wide package of products and services that we offer to transport companies also includes software that will allow a carrier to check whether illegal practices are being used in their vehicles – says Mateusz Włoch.

The plague of tachograph record manipulation is a huge problem that the transport industry must face. It is extremely important to raise awareness regarding compliance with working time rules, which drivers are obligated to follow. Is the threat of losing a license for the carrier still not enough?

[1] Example of a description of one of the tools for disrupting tachograph operation.
[2] http://www.witd.bydgoszcz.pl/AKTUALNOSCI/6-przypadkow-ingerencji-w-zapisy-tachografow-655.html
[3] http://www.gitd.gov.pl/dla-mediow/aktualnosci/archiwum/15-przypadkow-manipulacji-tachografem
[4] http://www.gitd.gov.pl/dla-mediow/aktualnosci/jazda-na-trzech-kartach.-40-ujawnionych-naruszen
[5] https://witd.rzeszow.pl/338-naruszenie-przepisow-adr-i-ingerencja-w-zapisy-tachografu
[6] https://www.pip.gov.pl/pl/f/v/192642/Sprawozdanie%20z%20dzialalnosci%20PIP%20w%202017.pdf

{youtube}https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KWUDkhtSq2M&feature=youtu.be{/youtube}