The controversial forty-five

The controversial forty-five

France was the first to take action against the practice of drivers spending their 45-hour rest period in a truck cabin. And they didn’t hold back. For breaking the law, entrepreneurs faced fines of up to 30,000 euros and, in the worst-case scenario, a year in prison. Why? Officially, it was about combating unfair social competition. In reality, Polish truckers were completing too many orders in the country through their reliability and hard work, which caused French carriers to lose out. Or did they? Drivers from across the Seine prefer short distances, and the system of benefits and taxes itself does not favor the interests of local entrepreneurs. However, this does not change the fact that high penalties can be imposed for the so-called “forty-five,” and Germany, Belgium, the Netherlands, England, and Italy have joined the group of countries monitoring weekly rest periods.

– After many interpretations of the applicable regulations and several guidelines from individual EU countries, it can currently be stated with certainty that every driver’s overnight stay on the road, lasting at least 45 hours, taken in the vehicle, is a major risk for a transport entrepreneur – says Łukasz Włoch, an expert at the National Center for Driver Settlement (OCRK).

To answer the question of why the risk is currently too high to take, it is worth looking at the history of inspections regarding weekly rest periods.

How did it start?
– One of the first countries to apply penalties for spending regular weekly rest periods in vehicle cabins was France. The regulation that enabled this entered into force on July 10, 2014, as an act to combat unfair social competition. In most cases, the carrier was burdened with a fine of 1,000-1,500 euros. Ultimately, the sanction was considered too low and fell into the highest bracket, reaching up to 30,000 euros or a year of imprisonment for the entrepreneur. Currently, in inspection practice, the amount of the fine ranges from 2,000 to 4,000 euros, and the driver is not held responsible for not going to a hotel for the “45” – explains the OCRK expert. – To protect themselves from penalties, drivers began to use two solutions to the problem. One of them was “interrupting the rest” by registering other work – so-called “hammers” or driving in the data history on the driver’s card. At that time, an analysis of previous rest periods was carried out during the inspection, and if a reduced weekly rest period could be taken in that given week, it did not result in a penalty. In cases where it was not allowed to interrupt the rest period, a penalty was imposed not for spending the rest in the cabin, but for shortening it, which was ultimately always a cheaper solution than 2,000 euros. The second way was “simulating” leaving the vehicle to spend the rest time in a hotel/motel. To this end, drivers removed digital cards from tachographs to break the continuity of the weekly rest record, inserted the cards into the tachographs after 45 hours, and by making a manual entry on the card of the rest period, created a history confirming that they were not in the vehicle during the regular weekly rest period – adds Łukasz Włoch.

Document confirming the overnight stay
In the initial phase of road inspections in Europe, the above methods of avoiding or reducing the penalty were used frequently, and the specter of sanctions in the amount of two or four thousand euros was slowly fading. However, in France, inspectors began to require a document confirming the driver’s presence in a hotel.

– This type of practice by inspection services is inconsistent with the regulations announced by the French Ministry of Transport. According to the law, the driver does not have to possess any document that could confirm to the inspecting person that they were in a place other than the driver’s cabin during the weekly rest period. They should be “caught in the act,” and it is the inspector’s duty to prove guilt – argues the OCRK expert. – However, French inspectors, in a situation where the driver did not have documents confirming an overnight stay outside the cabin, imposed fines, explaining that it is a “deposit” towards a future potential sanction in case the entrepreneur does not provide the indicated documents verifying the history of the driver’s overnight stay.

Drivers’ methods
The solution to the problem for some entrepreneurs was to leave the country where one could be punished for spending a regular weekly rest in a vehicle cabin and go to a country that had not yet introduced its local regulations sanctioning the violation of the rule of Art. 8(8) of Regulation 561/2006. Trips for “45s” to Germany or Italy were common, only to return to France after the rest period had passed. If the driver’s card showed a record of the “country of end and start of work” other than the French Republic, then during road inspections, local officials did not inquire where the driver spent the 45-hour rest.

– For a long time, this way of bypassing the regulations worked. However, more countries began to join the group of countries monitoring this violation: Germany, Belgium, the Netherlands, Italy, or England – says Łukasz Włoch. – Belgian inspection services began issuing fines of 1,800 euros, but if the carrier does not agree with the fine and takes the case to court, then in the event of a loss, the fine can be as high as 60,000 euros. Germany also confirmed the application of sanctions in May 2017. However, it was considered fairer for the driver to also receive a fine of up to 500 euros, and the administrative penalty aimed at the carrier was estimated at a value close to 1,500 euros – adds the OCRK expert.

No longer just caught in the act
In the first half of 2018, the practice of European inspection services changed again. The “driver caught in the act” rule was extended to events where the driver admits during an inspection to staying in the vehicle cabin for a period reaching up to 28 days preceding the inspection. The first such situation took place in France, where the inspector demanded that the driver show documents confirming their presence in hotels in February and March 2018 while taking 45-hour rest periods outside France.
According to the data from the driver’s card, the driver spent regular weekly rest periods in Luxembourg and the Netherlands; unfortunately, neither at the time of the road inspection nor during the administrative proceedings were “hotel receipts” presented, and the 1,500 euro deposit was converted into a fine. The same procedure, i.e., checking the 28-day period (backwards), found recognition among German and Italian inspectors. For example, for failing to present a hotel document confirming the rest spent outside the vehicle in Italy in the period of September – October 2018, the driver received a 275 euro fine, while the carrier received 1,575 euros.

How to proceed?
– In light of the applicable law, it is therefore forbidden to spend regular weekly rest periods in a vehicle cabin. It is always worth having confirmation of an overnight stay spent outside the truck in a country other than the one in which one is employed. Consequently, the driver’s card in such a situation should always be outside the tachograph. What if the driver planned a correct reduced weekly rest period, which they could have taken in the vehicle cabin, but for reasons beyond their control, they took more than 45 hours? The driver can then interrupt it with an event of other work or availability no later than the 44th hour or, after taking the entire rest, make a printout and add an appropriate annotation justifying their stay in the vehicle cabin – advises Łukasz Włoch from OCRK.