
This legal study is a continuation of the previous publication dedicated to the consignor’s liability for transport damages resulting from improper cargo securing. The previous study referred to the regulations of national (Polish) transport law. It is therefore worth assessing how the same issue of liability for damages resulting from improper cargo securing is regulated by international transport law – the Convention on the Contract for the International Carriage of Goods by Road (CMR).
25% of road accidents and incidents are a derivative of improper cargo securing
Although I already clearly suggested in the previous study that liability for damages incurred during transport resulting from improper cargo securing lies with the consignor, and not, as is commonly believed, with the carrier, this thesis must be clarified and expanded upon, as there are many subtle differences in this matter compared to Polish transport law. It is worth clearly establishing the scope of duties and liability of the consignor and the carrier in this regard, because failure to fulfill obligations in this area has far-reaching consequences for third parties who, colloquially speaking, “fall victim” to the negligence of consignors regarding improper cargo securing. This is confirmed by official European Commission studies indicating that 25% of all road accidents and incidents involving heavy goods vehicles are a direct derivative of improper cargo securing (source: Guidelines on European Best Practices for Cargo Securing for Road Transport – Jacques Barrot, p. 2).
Application of the CMR Convention
To begin with, it is worth recalling that the CMR Convention will apply when the carriage is for reward and when the place of taking over the goods and the place of delivery are situated in two different countries, of which at least one is a party to the CMR Convention. However, the place of residence and nationality of the parties to the contract of carriage are irrelevant (Art. 1(1) CMR).
Diversity of opinions
It is worth noting right at the beginning that some authors hold the position (with which it is impossible to agree) that liability for this type of damage is, in principle, borne by the carrier. One can cite a phrase from the textbook “Contract for the International Carriage of Goods by Road under the CMR” (Wolters Kluwer Publishing – Warsaw 2013), where the author posits that: although the CMR contract does not explicitly impose an obligation on the carrier to secure the cargo, the general principle of taking care of the shipment implies the carrier’s liability (p. 229 of the textbook). The author of the cited textbook does not directly state that the fact of the “obligation to secure the cargo” constitutes the source of the carrier’s liability for damages, but nevertheless leaves a certain type of understatement, unacceptable in my opinion, suggesting that it is not the consignor, but the carrier, who bears the obligation to properly secure the cargo. One could draw the erroneous conclusion that liability for the consequences of a lack of proper cargo securing is borne by the carrier, and not the consignor, whereas, in principle, the CMR Convention regulates this issue quite differently.
The importance of precision in the consignment note issued under the terms of the CMR Convention
International transport law clearly defines the consignor’s liability for damages resulting from the lack of precise entries in the consignment note, which resulted in damage during transport. Art. 6(1)(f) and (h) imposes a legal obligation to specify in the consignment note: the nature of the goods, the type of packaging, and the gross weight. All of the above elements are absolutely necessary to determine the type of cargo securing measures planned for use, the forces that must be “tamed,” and the methods of applying the selected securing measures. It is impossible to make an accurate choice of cargo securing measures without knowing the characteristics of the cargo unit (e.g., whether it is susceptible to crushing at a certain temperature, fragile, etc.). It is also impossible to make the right choice regarding the quantity of cargo securing measures without determining the gross weight. Finally, it is extremely difficult to properly adapt the method of using a securing device without defining the packaging parameters of the cargo (e.g., a different method for the same cargo will have to be applied to secure a cargo unit placed on a “standard” pallet versus one on a pallet with a so-called “balcony”). There are many practical reasons for this state of affairs, but this study is not devoted to them.
Given the above arguments, it should be noted that the international legislator clearly stipulated in Art. 7 of the CMR Convention that it is not the carrier, but the consignor, who is liable for all costs and damages resulting from inaccuracies or insufficiency of the data indicated in the consignment note. Thus, in the case of providing an incorrect (understated) gross weight of the cargo (which may result in the use of an insufficient quantity of appropriate securing measures), the consignor bears the liability. It is worth paying attention to this circumstance, because in the vast majority of cases, the gross weight declared by consignors in consignment notes is significantly understated. There are several reasons for understating the gross weight: underestimating the weight of pallets (mainly wet ones), using different types of pallets, using approximate (catalog) assumptions regarding the unit weight of the product while ignoring the actual weight of a given cargo unit, etc. Moreover, underestimating the gross weight causes doubly negative effects for the consignor, because additionally, the consignor may claim from the carrier (in the event of total or partial loss of goods) compensation in an understated amount for every lost kilogram of cargo weight (pursuant to Art. 23 of the CMR Convention). So, no matter how one looks at the matter, in no configuration does it pay for the consignor to understate the value of the cargo, because ultimately, the problems associated with this will return to the consignor like a boomerang.
However, the international legislator goes even further in defining the consignor’s liability and states in Art. 7(1)(c) that the consignor is also liable in the case of: “insufficiency” (…) of all other data or instructions given by him for the purpose of drawing up the consignment note or for their inclusion therein.” A contrario, this means that the consignor is obliged to include in the consignment note all such detailed instructions that are “sufficient” for the proper and legal carriage of goods (in accordance with the PN EN 12195-1 standard). The consignor bears liability for all costs resulting from the failure to fulfill these obligations (Art. 7(1) CMR).
Also, Art. 8 of the CMR does not change this general principle of the consignor’s liability for the damages in question. Although this provision states that the carrier is obliged to check the data contained in the consignment note, this is a regulation that does not condition the transfer of liability to the carrier, and secondly, in matters related to the securing of cargo units, this provision is unenforceable for the carrier in almost every case. It is worth knowing that for the same cargo units, but packed and packaged differently, different securing measures or different methods of applying the same securing measures will most often apply. E.g., ceramics transported on “stretch-wrapped” pallets with hard bottom and top “lids” will often be secured differently than the exact same cargo without top “lids” or with soft “lids.” One could multiply examples here by the thousands – it is therefore worth remembering that the carrier has almost no chance of assessing, during loading, the correctness of the decisions, actions, methods, etc., taken by the consignor. And that is precisely why the consignor, not the carrier, bears the liability for all financial consequences of the imperfections of their own actions related to the effects of improper cargo securing. Therefore, in accordance with the content of Art. 9 of the CMR, any shortcomings (lack of specification of the proper method of cargo securing) in the consignment note will constitute evidence against the consignor.
Moreover, the legislator in Art. 10 of the CMR stipulated that the consignor additionally bears liability towards the carrier themselves for damages that arose on the part of third parties, the carrier’s assets, or other transported cargo, if these damages are caused by errors in defining the rules for the execution of the transport by the consignor. The above regulation can be illustrated with a real-life example in which a carrier is transporting, for example, a heavy electric motor that was improperly secured on the transport vehicle, and due to the improper choice of both the means and the methods of applying the securing measures, the vehicle tips over at a roundabout onto another vehicle, in which the female driver suffers permanent bodily injury. The carrier’s driver also suffers bodily injury.
In this case, in accordance with the content of Art. 10 of the CMR, the consignor is liable for:
– damage to the carrier’s assets (up to the value of the damage to the truck, the cost of lifting the vehicle and disposing of the accident consequences, vehicle downtime during repairs, etc.),
– damage to the cargo unit itself (the motor) consigned by the consignor,
– damage to other simultaneously transported cargo units,
– damage (by way of a property damage claim) to the car crushed by the carrier’s truck,
– damage (by way of a personal injury claim) to the driver in the car crushed by the carrier’s truck,
– damage (by way of a personal injury claim) to the driver in the carrier’s vehicle,
– damage in the form of an administrative sanction (if such were imposed on the carrier under the Road Transport Act).
Furthermore, of course, criminal consequences will also be drawn against, among others, the consignor’s employees, but this issue will be treated separately in the next publication.
Perhaps some consignors may find the above conclusions too restrictive, but the legislator takes a different stance, further strengthening the scope of the consignor’s liability in Art. 14 of the CMR, stating that if the execution of the transport has become impossible for any reason (e.g., as a result of an ITD inspection finding that the cargo was not properly secured), the carrier does not have the right to make corrections themselves, but “is obliged to request instructions from the person entitled to dispose of the goods” (the consignor/consignee). This seems logical, because no one other than the entitled entities (the consignor, the consignee) knows the characteristics of their own cargo better, and no one other than them can know better what measures and methods of cargo securing should be applied in connection with this to legally continue the transport.
Furthermore, in accordance with the content of Art. 16(1) of the CMR, the carrier has the right to reimbursement of costs from the consignor resulting from the fact that they requested instructions from the consignor and were obliged to execute them. A real-life example will illustrate this well – when a carrier, while transporting 24 tons of steel bars, secured this cargo according to the consignor’s instructions with twelve straps, the angle formed by the securing device with the base of the loading box was below 30 degrees with a friction coefficient of µ = 0.2. After a BAG inspection, the vehicle was stopped and ordered to properly secure the cargo. The carrier turned to the consignor for instructions, and the latter, using expert knowledge, instructed the carrier to install an additional 80 securing straps. In such a case, in accordance with the content of Art. 16(1), the consignor covers the costs of executing the additional instructions for the carrier and finances the cost of purchasing the 80 additional securing straps.
The culmination of the idea of establishing liability on the consignor for transport damages resulting from a lack of cargo securing is the content of Art. 17(2) of the CMR Convention, which regulates that the carrier is not liable: “if (…) the damage (…) was caused by the wrongful act or neglect of the claimant, by the instructions of the claimant given otherwise than as the result of a wrongful act or neglect on the part of the carrier, (…) or through circumstances which the carrier could not avoid and the consequences of which he was unable to prevent.”
Clauses void by operation of law
In conclusion, it is worth emphasizing that in accordance with the content of Art. 40 of the CMR, “any stipulation which would directly or indirectly derogate from the provisions of this Convention shall be null and void.” This means the complete ineffectiveness of such contractual arrangements between the parties to the transport (consignor, consignee, carrier) that would result in the transfer of liability or costs of the consequences of cargo securing to the carrier – such attempts, besides having to be assessed as not very elegant, are additionally expressis verbis prohibited. In view of the above, it can only be signaled here that it is inadmissible to transfer liability from the consignor to the carrier or another entity (e.g., loader, consignee, etc.) under the Incoterms rules. This issue, however, will be described in more detail in a separate study.
Summary
Despite the differences between the regulations of the Transport Law Act and the CMR Convention, there is an undeniably discernible common denominator in the form of recognizing the consignor’s liability for damages resulting from the effects of improper cargo securing during transport, which are the result of a lack of guidelines or erroneous guidelines from the consignor. Furthermore, any separate arrangements between the parties attempting to transfer liability to the consignor are legally ineffective under the CMR Convention regulations.
Mariusz Miąsko, President of the Viggen Sp. J. Law Firm, President of Logistic Technologies Sp. z o.o.
READ ALSO: The consignor’s liability for damages resulting from improper cargo securing







