
Many years of observing the TSL (Transport, Shipping, Logistics) industry allow us to posit that the overwhelming majority of transport damages result from improper cargo immobilization. Most frequently, so-called crush-susceptible loads are damaged, which in practice accounts for the vast majority of all transported cargo. This cause stems from three types of errors generated during the transport organization process:
a) submitting an incorrect request for transport means,
b) submitting an incorrect request for cargo immobilization means,
c) failure to specify the proper method of using securing devices.
A natural question arises: who bears the liability for damages resulting from improper cargo immobilization during transport – and thus, who in the transport chain is responsible for specifying the above three parameters in the transport order and/or the consignment note.
For reasons that have remained inexplicable for years, a completely unfounded belief has taken root in the TSL environment that the carrier is liable for this type of damage (resulting from improper cargo immobilization) – which is obviously inconsistent with the content of both national and international transport law. Since the last amendment to Art. 43(1) of the Transport Law Act, a completely erroneous view has been festering in the TSL environment that the consignor can contractually transfer liability to the carrier for damages caused by improper cargo immobilization. In this publication, I will focus primarily on Polish law (with few references to the CMR Convention regulations), while in the next study, I will try to explain how the same issue is regulated in international transport law – although it can be noted immediately that these regulations are relatively consistent in the scope of our interest.
Source of misunderstanding
There are two primary sources of misunderstanding regarding this issue, which result in the TSL industry representatives’ mistaken belief about the carrier’s liability for damages caused by improper cargo immobilization. The primary source is the lack of knowledge of the exact content of Art. 43(1) and (2) of the Transport Law Act and Art. 71(1)(2) of the Transport Law Act in the context of the regulations of Art. 36(1)(1)(b) of the Transport Law Act and in the context of Art. 55a(2) of the Transport Law Act. A compilation of the content of these regulations leads to the obvious conclusion that, in principle, the only entities liable for damages due to lack of cargo immobilization are the “consignor” and, in some cases (transport of hazardous materials), the “loader” acting on behalf of the consignor. Before I perform a detailed legal analysis of the cited regulations in the area of this issue, I will first address the second source of the TSL environment’s misconceptions about the alleged liability of the carrier for damages resulting from cargo immobilization. One can cite, for example: “Transport Law Commentary” – Wolters Kluwer Publishing – Warsaw 2014, to Art. 3(2) of the Act, in which the author expresses the opinion that the content of Art. 3 of the Transport Law Act implies that it is the carrier’s duty to choose not only the appropriate means of transport but also the appropriate securing device (p. 42, paragraph 4 of the commentary). A similar thesis was articulated in the textbook “International Road Transport Contract under CMR” (Wolters Kluwer Publishing – Warsaw 2013), where the author posits that: although expressis verbis the CMR contract does not impose an obligation on the carrier to secure the cargo, the general principle of exercising care over the shipment implies the carrier’s liability (p. 229 of the textbook). The authors of the cited commentaries do not directly state that they understand the duty of “securing the cargo” as its immobilization, but they leave a certain ambiguity, which causes the reader to get the impression that it is not the consignor but the carrier who bears the duty of proper cargo immobilization. Thus, the source of the misconception about carrier liability is even some commentaries and textbooks on transport law.
Additionally, various interpreters of the content of the amended Art. 43 of the Transport Law Act add fuel to the fire, claiming that the consignor can agree by contract to transfer liability for damages resulting from the performance of so-called “loading operations”. For example, on page 181 of the “Transport Law Commentary” – Publishing House (Wolters Kluwer – Warsaw 2014), a thesis was presented that: “transport law does not determine which entity is responsible for securing the shipment for the duration of transport (…)”. Full agreement – it is not explicitly written in transport law that the liability for cargo immobilization rests with the carrier or the consignor. The point, however, is that the author equates “loading operations” with cargo immobilization operations, because he writes that “this is supported by the general principle of the carrier exercising care over the shipment”. Further, the commentator goes even further, claiming on the same page in the second paragraph that “there are no obstacles for the parties to agree in the transport contract that activities related to securing the shipment will be borne by the consignor”.
One cannot agree at all with such presented logic of relations regarding liability for damages resulting from improper cargo immobilization, because it falsely suggests that the principle is the carrier’s liability for such damages and that the parties (carrier and consignor) can optionally agree that the consignor will bear the liability. Meanwhile, according to the current legal status, it is exactly the opposite (!) The principle is that the liability for damages resulting from “loading operations” is borne by the consignor, and they can only optionally entrust the performance of such activities to other entities contractually. Furthermore, it is not at all as the authors of the cited commentary suggest, that the consignor can cede liability for the consequences of “loading operation” errors. According to the content of Art. 43(1) of the Transport Law Act, the consignor may cede to various other entities only the physical performance of the “loading operations” themselves, but in no case has the legislator allowed for the possibility of transferring liability from the consignor to the carrier for the consequences of such action, which directly follows from the content of Art. 72(1)(2) of the Transport Law Act as well as a number of other provisions.
Analysis of the current legal status under the Transport Law Act
Firstly, the analysis should begin with Art. 3 of the Transport Law Act, which states that the carrier is obligated (and thus liable) solely to provide – quote: “means of transport suitable for the performance of a given transport” and contrary to the opinions of some experts and trainers, this provision does not at all impose on the carrier the obligation to select and provide appropriate means for immobilizing cargo units. The previously cited opinions of commentators, from which they derive on the basis of teleological interpretation that cargo immobilization means are supposedly a component of transport means and for this reason the carrier would be liable for the proper securing of cargo units, are unjustified. Such overinterpretation resulting from the application of an extensive interpretation of the content of Art. 3 is inadmissible under the paradigm of legal interpretation and contrary to the doctrine of jurisprudence as well as contrary to the Supreme Court’s case law, e.g., III CSK 18/12; III CZP 29/01, III CZP 46/02, I CK 46/02, unpublished, which states that it is categorically inadmissible to overinterpret the content of a norm beyond the content actually contained therein. This means in this specific case that, according to the content of Art. 3 of the Transport Law Act, the carrier bears liability solely for providing appropriate means of transport (according to the demand specified by the consignor in the transport order) and for nothing more.
Secondly, Art. 36(1)(2)(b) states directly that “excluded from transport” are such cargo units (things) whose transport – quote: “would cause a violation of regulations specifying the conditions for performing road transport (…), traffic regulations (…)”. Meanwhile, Art. 61(3) of the Road Traffic Law Act states directly that “the cargo placed on the vehicle should be secured against shifting (…)” – that is, it must be immobilized. It follows that “excluded from transport” are such cargo units that have not been properly immobilized. A logical question arises: how would the carrier know how to immobilize an infinitely large number of various cargo units using an almost countless number of the most diverse cargo immobilization means and using various immobilization methods? The answer is obvious – the carrier cannot know this. This is apparently what the legislator thought, who very rationally indicated in the content of Art. 38(1) of the Transport Law Act that it is – quote: “the consignor who submits a consignment note to the carrier (…) (or – note) in another way provides information necessary for the proper performance of the transport”.
Proper performance of transport requires that the transport is not legally excluded at all, and therefore that it is not performed in violation of Art. 61(3) of the Road Traffic Law, and for this very reason, the legislator specified that it is the consignor who has the duty – quote: “to provide information necessary for the proper performance of the transport”. This is fully logical, because if someone (the consignor) wants to carry out the transport of goods, they must provide the carrier with information on how the transport of a specific cargo is to be carried out safely and in accordance with the law.
Thirdly – for the reasons cited above, the legislator very rightly stipulated expressis verbis in Art. 65(2) of the Transport Law Act that – quote: “the carrier is not liable if (…) damage to the shipment arose from causes occurring on the part of the consignor or (…) not caused by the carrier’s fault (…)”. In essence, therefore, the carrier can almost never be liable for damages in transport caused by improper cargo immobilization, because as I have already shown, it is the consignor who is responsible for the selection of appropriate means of transport (Art. 3 of the Transport Law Act), the consignor provides the carrier with information necessary for the proper performance of the transport (Art. 38(1) of the Transport Law Act), and it is the consignor who must ensure that the method of performing the transport does not result in its exclusion from transport (Art. 36(1)(2)(b) of the Transport Law Act). This follows directly from the content of Art. 65(3)(1), which states that quote: “the carrier is released from liability (for damages in transport – note) if (…) damage to the shipment arose at least from (…) causes: (…) failure by the consignor to observe (…) conditions (of transport – note)”. An exception where the carrier could bear liability for damages in transport would be a case where the carrier performed transshipment or loading and immobilized the cargo in a manner inconsistent with the content of the order issued by the consignor in the consignment note or transport order.
Fourthly, taking into account all the above regulations and arguments, the legislator in Art. 72(1)(1) of the Transport Law Act directly clarified that it is not the carrier but – quote: “the consignor who bears liability for damage resulting from providing in the consignment note or in another form indications and declarations (…) that are inaccurate, insufficient (…)”. The legislator further highlights the consignor’s liability in paragraph 2 of the same article, where it indicates that it is the consignor who bears liability for damage resulting from quote: “improper performance of loading operations”. If we assume that “loading operations” also include cargo immobilization, then the content of the cited provision directly implies that the consignor and only the consignor bears liability for irregularities in this scope and cannot “share” this liability with anyone, and certainly not with the carrier.
Fifthly, it is also worth citing the regulation of Art. 65(3) stating that: “the carrier is released from liability (…) if (the damage – note) occurred due to improper placement of things”. It is worth knowing that one of the ways to immobilize cargo is the so-called tight packing method. Roughly speaking, it consists of the fact that, for example, when using a transport means with a fixed body or light cargo on a semi-trailer with an L and/or XL certificate, the cargo units must adhere to each other on the loading platform in such a way that the free spaces are no larger than 7 cm. Then it can be assessed that the cargo units have been properly “placed”, which follows from the “EU Guidelines on European Best Practices for Cargo Securing in Road Transport” from 2014. Since in practice the carrier has no influence on the physical loading of the transport unit, the legislator provided in Art. 72 of the Transport Law Act for the consignor’s liability for any irregularities due to performed “loading operations”.
Analysis of the content of the “infamous” Art. 43 of the Transport Law Act
An argument is often presented for the alleged liability of carriers for damages caused by improper cargo immobilization, that according to the content of Art. 43, the consignor may, by contract, entrust the performance of “loading operations” to, for example, the carrier or another “loader” and thus release the consignor from liability.
Such a claim is argued in such a way that, according to the content of Art. 43(2) of the Transport Law Act, an “other entity” than the consignor – performing “loading operations” is “obliged to perform them in a manner ensuring the transport of the shipment in accordance with road traffic regulations (…) and in particular not causing a threat to road traffic safety (…)”. Here, several elementary issues should be explained.
Firstly, the discussed Art. 43(1) and (2) of the Transport Law Act only specifies that the consignor may agree with any other entity (loader) that this entity will physically perform “loading operations” and that these operations must be performed in a manner ensuring the transport of the shipment in accordance with road traffic regulations. This provision, however, does not allow for transferring liability for damages for “loading operations” from the consignor to any other entity performing loading operations. Thus, by virtue of Art. 43(1) of the Transport Law Act, it can be agreed that on behalf of the consignor, loading operations will be performed by another entity (which in practice happens in the overwhelming majority of cases because loading most often takes place not at the consignor’s but at manufacturers, logistics centers, etc.), but according to the content of Art. 72(1)(2), l i a b i l i t y for improper performance of loading operations is still borne by the consignor.
One might ask why this is so? Well, it follows directly from the content of the regulation of Art. 47(1) of the Transport Law Act, which states that: “the person who hands over the shipment to the carrier for transport is considered authorized by the consignor to perform a l l a c t i v i t i e s related to the conclusion of the transport contract”. Leaving aside the historical aspects of this regulation (which until 1995 was linked to the real nature of concluding transport contracts), one should agree with the position of D. Dąbrowski (Wolters Kluwer 2014 “Transport Law. Commentary” p. 189 et seq.) that the entity handing over the shipment for transport (e.g., at a logistics center or at a manufacturer) does not have the right to change the scope of conditions, guidelines, or instructions regarding the principles of contract performance. One must fully agree with such a view, because the cited regulation indirectly explains why, even though the consignor can agree to the physical performance of “loading operations” by, for example, the carrier or, for example, the manufacturer (loader), the liability for the consequences of damages related to the lack of precision in the choice of means and methods of cargo immobilization will still be borne by the consignor.
Secondly, it is worth noting that even if one wanted to accept the extremely difficult to defend and contrary to Art. 72 of the Transport Law Act thesis that Art. 43(1) transfers to the carrier the liability for errors in the consignor’s specification of the methodology for performing loading operations – the carrier would have to physically perform these “loading operations” at all. In practice, it is known that in very few cases (e.g., loading using a HDS crane) are loading operations performed by the driver on behalf of the employer. Furthermore, the driver would also have to have these activities included in the Occupational Risk Assessment – which in practice almost never occurs, and thus disqualifies the driver as a potential legal loader, which of course does not exclude the physical performance of such a loading operation in a manner inconsistent with labor law.
Thirdly, there is a serious doubt whether the legislator allowed at all for the possibility of entrusting the carrier with activities related to performing “loading operations”. Well, these loading operations can be performed by the “consignor”, “consignee”, or “other entity”. The point is that the legislator did not use the term “carrier”, which is significant. When the legislator wants to refer to the legal institution of a “carrier”, they write directly about the “carrier” in the Act every time and have never used a substitute in the form of “other entity”. According to the principles of rational legislator resulting from jurisprudence, it is assumed that the use of different terms in legal acts suggests that they apply to different entities. This is a fundamental principle of jurisprudence. Thus, it can be reasonably assumed that the term “other entity” does not apply to the institution of a “carrier” at all. This understanding of this institution is also supported by the content of Art. 55a of the Transport Law Act. This would mean that the carrier cannot perform “loading operations” under the Transport Law Act (even if they performed them physically) and therefore no statutory obligations regarding cargo immobilization rest on them – which is logical, because in practice they do not have any knowledge about the cargo itself and its characteristics, cargo packing, cargo packaging, susceptibility to pressure, cargo dimensions, etc.).
Practical aspects
Formal legal issues are easier to understand by understanding the given matter on a practical and physical level. As an active auditor of loading processes related to the immobilization of cargo units in transport, I can state that there is an almost countless number of cargo units, immobilization means, and combinations of immobilization methods. This issue is a separate topic in itself. However, it can be signaled that due to the characteristics of the cargo, the carrier has practically no chance to independently choose the correct securing means adequate for immobilization in transport of specific cargo units. Hence, based on numerous audit experiences, I posit that 99% of all cargo units in Poland are carried out in violation of the PN EN 12195-1 standard specifying the conditions for cargo immobilization. This is confirmed by European Commission studies, which show that 25% of all road accidents and incidents involving heavy transport means are a derivative of the lack of cargo immobilization. There is no such thing as partial cargo immobilization. The cargo is either immobilized (normatively) or it is not immobilized at all and is at best stabilized – which is the source of most damages in transport. A properly (normatively) immobilized cargo prevents its damage in principle. If damage to the cargo occurred during transport without the participation of third parties/entities, and for reasons not resulting from the properties of the cargo (leaking gas in a leaky package), then one can a priori assume that the source of the damage was fault lying on the part of the consignor, who incorrectly parameterized the requirements regarding: a) the transport means, b) the cargo immobilization device, c) the cargo immobilization methodology.
In conclusion, I will allow myself to illustrate the scale of the discussed issue. The number of cargo immobilization means adequate for use in relation to the transport of individual cargo units is so large that if the duty to specify in the transport order/consignment note did not rest with the consignor, the carrier, by sending a truck for almost every loading, would have to take with them such a quantity of types of immobilization means that there would be no free space left on the loading platform for the cargo. Even if the carrier did so, it still does not solve the problem, because the same immobilization means can be used in different ways depending on the characteristics of the cargo units. This characteristic can only be known by the consignor or the manufacturer, i.e., an entity that participates in forming the cargo unit. For this reason, it is the consignor who has the duty to specify extremely precisely and in detail in the transport order the parameters of loading and cargo immobilization, broken down into three aspects: parameterization of the transport means, immobilization devices, and immobilization methods. It should be signaled that this parameterization must be extremely precise and detailed. For example, it can only be signaled that indicating in the transport order, e.g., for lashing straps, the LC coefficient instead of S TF or vice versa, suggests the use of a completely different immobilization method using the same securing device (strap). This means that the consignor must precisely indicate the parameters of the securing means so that the carrier knows what means they are to provide and whether they have such means at their disposal at all. Furthermore, it should be signaled in passing that the use of a securing means in the form of lashing straps using the cross-lashing method (i.e., the so-called “force method”) is permissible in very few cases (!) Meanwhile, in almost 100% of cases, consignors recommend in transport orders that carriers provide straps for loading and use them using the cross-lashing method, which constitutes a very serious error.
Summary
Bearing in mind all the above aspects, it is easy to understand why the national legislator clearly separated the issue of performing loading operations from liability for damages and, both under national and international law, excluded the carrier’s liability for the consequences of “loading operations”. The international legislator sees this issue no differently, having regulated in Art. 17(2) of the CMR Convention that the carrier is not liable: “if (…) the damage (…) was caused by the fault of the authorized person, their order not resulting from the carrier’s fault, (…) or circumstances which the carrier could not avoid and the consequences of which they could not prevent”.
Mariusz Miąsko, President of the Viggen Sp. J. Law Firm, President of Logistic Technologies Sp. z o.o.







