Termination of a fixed-term mandate contract

Termination of a fixed-term mandate contract

Is it possible to terminate a fixed-term cooperation agreement? Can the mandator terminate such an agreement without a valid reason? On what terms and will they have to pay a contractual penalty?

Expert answer: The rules for terminating mandate contracts are defined in Article 746 of the Civil Code, which also applies accordingly to service provision agreements not regulated by other provisions, i.e., in this case, a cooperation agreement. This provision states that the mandator may terminate the mandate at any time. In the case of a paid mandate, there is an obligation to pay the mandatary a portion of the remuneration corresponding to their activities performed to date, and if the termination occurred without a valid reason, also an obligation to compensate for damages.

Case law confirms that a fixed-term contract can be terminated before the expiry of the term, as it is a relationship based on mutual trust, and the parties cannot effectively waive in advance the right to terminate the contract for important reasons (Article 746 § 3 of the Civil Code) (Supreme Court judgment of September 28, 2004, IV CK 640/03, Supreme Court judgment of February 9, 2001, III CKN 304/00).
Courts hold the position that while it is not possible to completely exclude the possibility of terminating a contract in accordance with the content of Article 478(3) of the Civil Code, it is possible to limit the possibility of terminating the contract only to important reasons (Supreme Court judgment of February 9, 2001, III CKN 304/00).

A lot depends on whether the contract lists the reasons that allow for the termination of the contract with immediate effect. In such a case, however, a sufficient premise is the loss of trust (judgment of the Court of Appeal in Krakow of December 30, 2015, I ACa 1310/15, judgment of the Court of Appeal in Warsaw of October 12, 2012, I ACa 450/12). If, however, it happens that the contract is terminated without a valid reason, such termination is effective, but the party that withdrew from the contract without a valid reason is obliged to provide the other party with compensation for losses resulting from the termination of the contract (Supreme Court judgment of September 11, 2002, case file V CKN 1152/2000). A contractual penalty is such a form of compensation. However, it was provided for only in the event of termination of the contract by the Mandatary due to gross negligence of the Mandator. If it is determined that the service provision agreement was terminated for important reasons, the payment of a contractual penalty would not be considered at all.

  • Legal status of the publication (date): 2016-11-25