Proceedings regarding the infringement of collective consumer interests from the entrepreneur’s perspective

Proceedings regarding the infringement of collective consumer interests from the entrepreneur's perspective

If consumers suspect that entrepreneurs are engaging in practices that infringe upon the collective interests of consumers, they may notify the appropriate office. Such a report results in the initiation of administrative proceedings by the President of the Office of Competition and Consumer Protection (UOKiK). Interestingly, such proceedings are initiated very frequently against companies from various industries. This usually happens in the case of banks, financial institutions, and mobile network operators.

Infringement of collective consumer interests

Article 24 of the Act on Competition and Consumer Protection indicates what exactly constitutes practices infringing upon the collective interests of consumers. First of all, it is worth knowing that an infringement of collective consumer interests occurs when an entrepreneur uses an unlawful practice that affects a certain group of consumers.

Importantly, this practice cannot be the sum of individual consumer interests. This means that in the case of incorrectly calculated bills or the use of an unfair contract term in one specific contract, this does not constitute an infringement as indicated in the aforementioned act.

According to the aforementioned act, one cannot use practices that are contrary to the law, good practices, or infringe upon the interests of consumers. These will primarily be:

  • Unfair market practices or acts of unfair competition;
  • Violation of the obligation to provide reliable, truthful, and complete information;
  • Proposing to consumers the purchase of financial services that do not correspond to the needs of those consumers, determined taking into account information available to the entrepreneur regarding the characteristics of those consumers, or proposing the purchase of these services in a manner inadequate to their nature.

When can proceedings regarding an infringement be initiated?

The proceedings of the President of UOKiK are initiated ex officio, but the institution of notification about practices that infringe upon the collective interest of consumers has been included in the regulations. We can find it in Article 100 of the act, according to which anyone can submit such a notification in writing. Nevertheless, proceedings cannot be initiated upon request – meaning that filing a notification does not oblige the President of UOKiK to initiate these proceedings.
The submitted notification is treated only as a source of information about a probable problem. The Office independently decides whether further steps should be taken in the matter. A complaint filed by a consumer only obliges the President of UOKiK to consider the validity of the notification. Furthermore, the President is not bound by the content of the notification. In addition to charging the entrepreneur with the practices indicated by the consumer, the President may also accuse the entrepreneur of other infringements.

supermarket 949913 750x500

Filing a complaint by a single consumer vs. collective interest

A written complaint regarding the infringement of collective consumer interest can be filed by anyone. As you can see, the catalog of authorized persons is broad, and even one person can do it. The most important thing is that the infringement indicated in the notification does not constitute merely an individual problem of a given consumer. It must relate to prohibited practices within the meaning previously indicated by the article. It should therefore constitute a symptom of a given entrepreneur’s practice.

Course of proceedings

The regulations include the possibility of conducting explanatory proceedings, which precede the initiation of the proper proceedings.

Explanatory proceedings

This is a proceeding that can be initiated by way of a resolution when circumstances indicate that there may have been a violation of the provisions of the act. The purpose of this type of proceeding is to initially determine whether an infringement of the provisions actually took place. The entire course of the explanatory proceedings does not take more than 4 months. However, it happens that in exceptionally complex cases, this time is extended to 5 months.

Proceedings regarding the infringement of collective consumer interests

As part of the proper proceedings, the President of UOKiK may issue a temporary decision that will oblige the entrepreneur to cease the indicated actions. This happens provided that it has been made probable that these actions may cause serious threats to consumers that are difficult for the entrepreneur to remove.

During the conduct of the proceedings, the President of UOKiK collects all information, explanations, and documents from the party to the proceedings. They may also interview witnesses, appoint experts, or gain access to evidence that constitutes a trade secret.

At the same time, office employees are obliged to protect the secret and all information they have learned during the proceedings.

Addressing the entrepreneur without initiating proceedings

The mildest form of resolving such a matter is for the President of the Office to address the entrepreneur without initiating proceedings. Then the entrepreneur can submit their position on the matter within a specified time. Such a mode provides a great deal of voluntariness and is often used not as a stage “before” initiating proceedings, but “instead” of them. If the entrepreneur provides information and explanations, this may result in an effective and faster assurance of the entrepreneur’s compliance with the law. Of course, in this mode, the entrepreneur is not obliged to take any reaction to the action of the President of UOKiK. They will not be subject to any criminal sanctions as a result.

How can an entrepreneur defend themselves? Amicable settlement of the case

To begin with, it should be noted that proceedings before the antitrust office are in most cases settled amicably. For years, we have been dealing with a settlement trend both in proceedings conducted before the President of the Office of Competition and Consumer Protection and before the European Commission.

Therefore, if proceedings have been initiated against an entrepreneur, they can still end in a settlement. This form of resolving the case allows for closing the proceedings without imposing a penalty or by imposing a reduced penalty.

The Act on Competition and Consumer Protection provides for two ways of settling such cases amicably:

  • Issuing a commitment decision
  • Voluntary submission to a penalty.

The result of each of these modes is the issuance of a decision, but the entrepreneur can mitigate the negative consequences of the proceedings.

Commitment decision

Issuing a commitment decision is one of the ways to amicably close a case before UOKiK. As part of this, the entrepreneur proposes taking actions aimed at removing the negative effects of the practices they have been accused of.

The entrepreneur can do this at all stages of the proceedings before the President. It is important, however, that the President cannot issue a commitment decision without the party submitting a proposal for such a commitment by the entrepreneur. The function of the President here consists solely of accepting the commitment proposed by the party to the proceedings.

Such a method gives the entrepreneur a chance to completely avoid a financial penalty and the costs resulting from conducting the proceedings. Additionally, the issued commitment decision does not contain a judgment on whether the given infringement actually occurred.

production 4460363 750x500

Example: proceedings against Polkomtel

As an example of a commitment decision, one can point to decision no. DOZIK 2/2021 of April 21, 2021, concerning Polkomtel sp. z o.o. The company was accused, among other things, of infringing upon the collective interest of consumers as a result of providing them with premium-rate services without having knowledge of the entity implementing the additional services and without exercising effective control over the manner of preparation and implementation of these services. Furthermore, the company provided responses to complaints without full information about these services, i.e., without indicating the name of the service provided and the entity implementing this service, which significantly hindered the consumer’s verification of the correctness of the service.

Polkomtel sp. z o.o. committed to taking actions leading to the termination of infringements and the removal of their effects, including by:

  • Introducing changes in the method of activating and providing premium-rate services;
  • Starting to use a changed service activation application template in relations with contractors involved in the implementation of the additional service;
  • Verifying the implementation of obligations

All listed activities were to be implemented within one month from the date the decision of the President of the Office became final.

Voluntary submission to a penalty

A proposal for voluntary submission to a penalty can come from both the entrepreneur and the President of the Office. Nevertheless, the final decision belongs to the competence of UOKiK. The conditions that must be met in order to close the case in such a way are:

  • Submission of a statement by the party on voluntary submission to a penalty;
  • Confirmation by the party of the findings of the antitrust proceedings concerning them;
  • Confirmation of informing the party about the infringements charged to them, the expected content of the decision, and the amount of the penalty, taking into account its reduction by 10%, and enabling the party to take a position;
  • Confirmation that the party has been informed about the consequences of filing an appeal to the court.

Concluding an agreement with voluntary submission to a penalty will be particularly beneficial for the entrepreneur because it results in:

  • A 10% reduction in the penalty, and together with the penalty reduction under the leniency program by 50%, it may result in a 60% reduction;
  • Faster closure of proceedings and return to business operations;
  • Avoiding a time-consuming, burdensome court process;
  • Reducing the costs of proceedings and avoiding costs in the court process.

What penalty for infringing collective consumer interests?

In addition to penalties consisting of imposing an obligation to cease practices that infringe upon collective consumer interests and removing the effects of these practices, the President of UOKiK may also impose a financial penalty.

The amount of financial penalties is determined by Article 106 of the Act on Competition and Consumer Protection. If an entrepreneur commits infringements even unintentionally, the financial penalty imposed on them may not exceed 10% of the turnover achieved in the financial year preceding the year of imposing the penalty.

Additionally, the President of UOKiK may impose on the entrepreneur a penalty equivalent to up to 50 million euros if the entrepreneur has not provided the information requested by the President or has provided untrue, false data, hindered the conduct of an inspection, or in any way prevented the conduct of proceedings.

Besides this, it should be remembered that the President of the Office may impose a penalty not only on the enterprise but also on the managing person in an amount reaching up to 2 million PLN. This may happen when this person has intentionally committed infringements related to a contract template or the prohibition of using practices that infringe upon collective consumer interests.

Conclusions

Conducting proceedings before the President of the Office of Competition and Consumer Protection can have far-reaching, negative consequences for the entrepreneur. However, there are ways to effectively mitigate them, such as: voluntary provision of information, cooperation with the Office, as well as indicating proposals that will allow for the improvement of the enterprise’s functioning.

It would therefore be groundless to stand in opposition to the President of UOKiK. Instead, it is better to aim for a settlement and give the Office the opportunity to process the case. Any obstacles during the inspection may result in the imposition of a financial penalty in an amount that would constitute a serious burden for the enterprise.