
In 2020, Road Transport Inspectorate (GITD) inspectors identified over 65,000 cases of violations of the Road Transport Act. Nearly half of them concerned irregularities related to drivers’ compliance with working time, and 35% were errors in the use of recording equipment.
– The working time settlements we perform indicate that in 2020 alone, professional drivers serviced by the National Driver Settlement Center (OCRK) committed over 1.3 million potential violations, of which over 1.1 million were very serious violations. Regular training for transport employees is key to avoiding them – comments Piotr Dajema, expert in implementations and training at OCRK, INELO Group.
Professional drivers on Polish roads can be penalized by several authorities, including the police and the Road Transport Inspectorate (ITD). Their powers partially overlap: both the police and the ITD are tasked with monitoring whether drivers moving on the roads are doing so in accordance with regulations.
Soon, by the end of 2024, inspectors will gain a new tool for monitoring proper transit. Thanks to the use of DSRC transmission, available in smart tachographs, the control authority will be able to perform a remote pre-selection check. In the event of detecting, for example, driving without a logged-in card or other events signaling improper tachograph operation, the vehicle could be stopped for a roadside inspection. According to OCRK experts, it is precisely the improper use of tachographs that results in many of the violations committed by drivers.
– The most common violations result from minor exceedances of driving and rest times. An unaware driver assumes that minor violations of up to 15 minutes do not carry any consequences. Other frequently occurring violations result from improper tachograph operation. A driver often forgets, out of absent-mindedness, to enter the country symbol where they start or end their work. That is why training drivers is so important – comments Piotr Dajema, adding that although financial penalties resulting from incorrect tachograph operation are not severe, when combined with their frequency – which experts say is high – they lead to serious consequences.
– It happens that a driver, as a result of incorrect tachograph operation, is able to generate a dozen or so violations during the period covered by a roadside inspection – concludes Piotr Dajema.
What are the most serious road violations?
The most serious offenses result from various methods of falsifying tachograph records. The simplest is driving without a card or using someone else’s card. Another method is interfering with the tachograph record itself. In the case of older recording devices, a neodymium magnet was enough for modification, which disrupted the proper operation of the pulse generator. In this way, dishonest drivers could drive the vehicle even though, according to the device, they were officially resting. Currently, new methods of falsification are based on software solutions. Data from the GITD shows that during inspections in 2020, over 2,000 cases of tampering with measuring devices were detected.
– Based on data from the vehicles of over 26,000 drivers, we can state that the number of potential violations is over a million, but only 250 cases are classified as the most serious, which can have the same effect as tampering. The vast majority are very serious violations – comments Piotr Dajema.
What can threaten a company whose drivers or transport managers regularly commit violations?
Good repute in transport
Good repute in the transport industry is crucial from the carrier’s point of view. Its loss is equivalent to the suspension of a license. Transporters who commit violations too often can say goodbye to it, although sometimes one – the most serious (MSI) – is enough to lose the license.
– Every type of violation has its weight: minor infringement, serious infringement, very serious infringement, and most serious infringement. Whether a transport entrepreneur will be subject to proceedings depends on which of these are committed. It is important to remember that it is not the amount of the fine, but the degree of the violation that is decisive here – comments Piotr Dajema. – The growing number of proceedings initiated regarding the loss of good repute by control authorities results in greater awareness among carriers. Fearing the revocation of their transport license, companies place greater emphasis on training drivers and management staff – he concludes.
In practice, the status of good repute can be lost by committing one most serious violation or several serious ones. Inspectors use a special formula for this, which takes into account the number of drivers employed in the company and the number of violations they have committed (1 MSI = 3 SI). Proceedings against a carrier can also be initiated if they regularly commit “larger caliber” violations. If it turns out that the evidence speaks against the carrier, their license is suspended by the Chief Inspectorate of Road Transport or the district governor (starosta).
Can a driver refuse to accept a fine?
If a driver does not agree with the decision to issue a fine, they can refuse to accept it. In Poland, the case is then referred to court. After the driver decides not to accept the fine, the institution for which the inspecting person works files a motion to the court to punish the perpetrator of the offense.
On the other hand, during foreign inspections, the driver is obliged to pay a deposit towards the fine before continuing the journey. If the payment is not made during the roadside inspection, the vehicle is transported to a deposit parking lot and is released to the driver after the payment is settled, which exposes the carrier to additional costs and the threat of failing to meet delivery deadlines.
– Financial penalties imposed for individual violations may seem small, but the summed-up numbers make a huge impression. Settlements of OCRK clients show that the drivers of these carriers could have committed errors that, in the event of an inspection, would translate into fines of up to 122 million PLN. However, it may turn out that the fines were imposed unfairly. In such cases, one should intervene with the appropriate authority. In 2020, OCRK experts took such actions, preparing appeals to authorities such as the National Labor Inspectorate or the ITD nearly 700 times – says Piotr Dajema.
Financial penalties are not everything
In addition to financial penalties, control authorities can use a whole range of sanctions, although it is worth noting that ultimately the fine imposed on the company cannot be higher than the limits resulting from the Road Transport Act. The most restrictive ones are imposed on the company in the event of finding the most serious violations. The procedure for the loss of repute by a carrier, and often also by the transport manager, is triggered automatically through the KREPTD system. Thanks to the integration of the KREPTD system with the European ERRU system, the initiation of proceedings regarding the loss of good repute can also begin as a result of finding the most serious violation outside of Poland. If the carrier does not properly implement the so-called rehabilitation procedure, they must count on having their license revoked.
– It is worth emphasizing that in the case of finding falsification of a tachograph record, the control authority may direct the vehicle to a diagnostic station to verify the operation of the recording device. This results in additional costs and a delay in picking up or delivering the cargo – adds Piotr Dajema.
In many countries, falsifying tachograph records is punishable not only by financial penalties but also by criminal liability. For example, in the UK up to two years, and in Northern Ireland even three years of imprisonment. An additional penalty that a controller can impose in the absence of the required rest is directing the driver to a parking lot and prohibiting further driving, even for the duration of the regular weekly rest.
New regulations on the way
The European Commission is already working on changes to the classification of violations. This mainly concerns adding those resulting from non-compliance with the new rules of the Mobility Package: violations related to posting, tightened cabotage rules, or the mandatory return to base (for drivers every 4 weeks, and for trucks every 8). Carriers must already comply with the regulations changing the organization of drivers’ returns. The rest of the changes will come into force from February 2022. This means that non-compliance with these rules will carry not only a financial penalty but, after classifying the violations as very serious or most serious, also the suspension of the license.
Source: Inelo







