
With the intensive development of the economy and the gradual shift of most services to the web, new mechanisms are emerging that facilitate the provision of services via the Internet. One such change is the ongoing digitalization of the TSL (Transport, Shipping, Logistics) industry. Electronic transport platforms have existed since the second half of the 1990s. Until recently, about 20% of transport within the EU was carried out this way. Currently, this percentage is higher and continues to grow. How do online freight forwarding platforms work from a legal perspective?
Where did online freight forwarding platforms come from? History
The first e-commerce solutions in B2B relations date back to the times before the advent of the widely available Internet. In the 1970s, the German company SVG created a database where communication was based on telephone lines. A similar solution was used in the 1990s by the French company Teleroute, a Wolters Kluwer Business – however, instead of a phone, they used a fax machine for this purpose.
Currently, the TSL industry includes many operating entities that support the execution of transactions via online platforms. According to available data, the most popular freight forwarding platforms are:
- Teleroute,
- Timo-Com,
- Trans.eu,
- Wtransnet
The role of online transport platforms
An online freight exchange is based on brokerage services. Within such platforms, communication and the execution of transport orders are supervised between TSL industry entrepreneurs and companies that commission cargo or the performance of related services.
Currently, service providers do not use offline services. Instead, they use modern websites and real-time messengers.
A precise and detailed description of the offer, e.g., cargo, plays an important role on transport platforms. This way, companies receive the best-matched applications from potential carriers.
These types of platforms operate, of course, based on terms and conditions. They regulate, among other things, the following issues:
- registration on the platform (creating and deleting an account),
- account authorization (granting, refusal to grant, and revocation),
- the scope of user liability for using the service,
- the scope of liability and powers of the service provider (the entity operating the service),
- conditions for concluding and terminating contracts,
- price and payment methods for using the service,
- products and services supported within the service,
- complaints,
- personal data protection.
Benefits of using freight forwarding platforms
What are the main advantages of using freight forwarding platforms? First of all, it is a solution that connects business partners, which benefits every party involved. Within the platforms, carriers increase the profitability of transport by consolidating cargo on the same route. As a result, they reduce fuel consumption, vehicle wear and tear, and reduce the number of driver man-hours.
On the other hand, shippers who choose such a carrier have access to the lowest service cost in relation to transport conditions and guaranteed volume. Numerous platforms also offer the possibility of uploading quality certificates and attestations, or recommendations that confirm the competence of a given carrier. This reduces the risk of encountering a dishonest service provider and improves the quality of service for the end recipient.
Verification conditions within an e-TSL platform can go even further. For example, the Wtransnet service has introduced secure login, the possibility of removing an entry of a dishonest contractor by an audit committee, assessment of a given entity’s solvency, or the option of reporting abuses. Furthermore, users have the ability to offer not only transport services but also those based on route and cost planning systems, debt collection, warehouse space exchanges, or employment agencies for drivers.
Of course, choosing the right contractor is not a simple matter. Therefore, the best solution is to compare all parameters or entrust this task to experts with experience in the TSL industry.
Disadvantages of e-TSL platforms
The disadvantages of electronic platforms include very high competition among entrepreneurs in this industry. At the same time, this means that service providers are often forced to provide services with a low margin, sometimes even on the verge of profitability.
Due to the fact that such platforms operate based on specific schemes and algorithms, it is often necessary to provide homogeneous or very similar services. However, when the ordering party expects a one-time, individually tailored service, it will need to be individually designed and priced.
Furthermore, to enter an e-TSL platform, the following are usually required:
- entry in the CEIDG or KRS,
- carrier license,
- valid third-party liability insurance for vehicles made available for transport,
- copies of vehicle registration certificates,
- certificate of professional competence.
When is a contract concluded on a transport exchange?
According to civil law, posting an offer on a transport exchange is an invitation to conclude a contract with pre-determined parameters. After contact is established between the carrier and the forwarder, the terms of cooperation regarding the place and date of loading and unloading, type of cargo, freight price, and payment deadline are clarified.
These are the minimum contractual requirements regarding transport, i.e., a transport order. It is also possible to expand it to include cargo security, contractual penalties, or conditions for withdrawal from the contract, etc. Before concluding such a contract, it is worth comparing the data from the offer with those included in the order. The most important of these are:
- the route, which should be the same as agreed,
- service execution time (carriers usually provide the so-called Fix, i.e., delivery at a specific time, or the so-called Timeslot, i.e., delivery of goods within a specific time interval),
- technical specification of the vehicle (tonnage, dimensions, specific solutions such as deep-freeze refrigerators)
Introducing these elements is not mandatory, but it allows for the best possible protection of the interests of the contract parties. It thus allows avoiding costly and time-consuming litigation.
Although from an evidentiary perspective it would be most beneficial for the parties to exchange scans of signed documents, the conclusion of a contract can also take place on the freight forwarding platform itself, e.g., through the exchange and acceptance of the most important data via a messenger. According to the principles of civil law, a contract can also be concluded implicitly, i.e., by starting its execution.
Such actions are common mainly in the case of companies that have been working together for a long time. Then formalities are kept to a minimum, and after establishing the essentialia negotii, the task is immediately executed. According to the regulations, in relations between entrepreneurs, the lack of an immediate response to an offer is equivalent to its acceptance. These relations are not covered by the general rules regarding declarations of intent made in electronic form, which are mentioned in Article 66, paragraphs 1-3 of the Civil Code.
Regulations governing the operation of online freight forwarding platforms
It must be remembered that the TSL industry very often operates internationally. Fast, efficient transport is a condition for maintaining the operational liquidity of many Polish and foreign companies. Consequently, it became necessary to create universal mechanisms allowing for the regulation of cooperation rules regardless of the place of service provision.
Although using a freight forwarding platform seems similar to using online auctions, where the buyer of the service is guided by a price updated in real-time, the execution of the service itself requires compliance with many regulations governing the transport of goods.
The most important legal acts that apply to the cooperation of forwarders in the B2B sector are:
- CMR Convention of 1956 on international road transport
- ADR Convention of 1957 on the transport of dangerous goods and cargo
- ATP Convention of 1970 on international transport of perishable foodstuffs
- TIR Convention of 1975 on international road transit
- AETR Agreement of 1976 concerning the work of crews of vehicles engaged in international road transport
Transport of goods within the European Union also requires compliance with Community regulations related to the transport of goods. However, in the case of domestic transport of goods, it must be carried out in accordance with the Polish legal order. The most important acts in this regard are:
- Transport Law Act,
- Road Transport Act,
- Drivers’ Working Time Act
The number of legal acts regulating transport law issues and their interdependence are truly extensive. Therefore, before concluding a contract for the transport of goods, it is worth seeking advice from a law firm that specializes in serving entities from the TSL industry. Lawyers will create or review the contract and will also ensure that every stage of the transaction is 100% legal and in accordance with applicable regulations.
The issue of security of electronic transport exchanges
Unfortunately, moving TSL industry services to the Internet does not exclude problems with unreliable or dishonest contractors. We can still encounter companies that impersonate the data of existing companies with a good reputation or situations where goods are released to an unauthorized person.
In order to effectively protect against such practices, it is worth initiating certain actions even before signing the contract. Evaluating entities based on the platform’s internal rating systems is not everything. In addition, one should spend time verifying the contractor – and not just within the registration documentation.
We can independently verify elements such as:
- vehicle registration certificate,
- driver’s data (based on an ID card or other document),
- extract from the license (official confirmation of holding the appropriate permit),
- third-party liability insurance policy for the car.
All these documents should be in the vehicle accepting the cargo. However, the effectiveness of any potential claim enforcement also depends on the attentiveness and foresight of the shipper’s employees. It is therefore worth checking the contractor in the register of debtors, on TSL industry forums, as well as in the CEIDG, KRS, VIES (VAT number), or KREPRD (National Electronic Register of Road Transport Entrepreneurs) registers.
One should also remember the basic function of a forwarding order – the consignment note introduced by the CMR Convention has a secondary (evidentiary) character, therefore, when the data on both documents are divergent, the content of the order plays the decisive role.
Conclusions
In the transport sector, there is a gradual digitalization, which is referred to as Transport 4.0. Freight exchanges are a great convenience that speeds up and streamlines the execution of logistics services. Nevertheless, the formal and legal aspects of cooperation and thorough verification of a new contractor are still of great importance.







